M83's earlier albums brimmed with promise, but their comely electronic textures sounded lifeless in the end—like dramatic gestures that aspired toward grandeur but got hung up where bombast goes to live and die. Saturdays=Youth corrected for that by cleaning up the edges and leaning hard against melody. The result is an album that traffics in songs rather than atmospheres, and even if the songs sound wedded to a sort of Breakfast Club memory of the 1980s, they play as distinctly modern for the space they luxuriate in.
The best music of 2008: The Ballots
And now, presented so you can find the writer you most closely resemble (or despise), this year's best-of-music ballots. First, some fun facts:
— Of the 30 records on the main list, 22 received a grade of B+ or higher in their initial A.V. Club review. Two were not reviewed (Flying Lotus and The Gaslight Anthem) when they came out. Three got straight Bs (Erykah Badu, Hercules And Love Affair, and Lil Wayne). Two got B-minuses (Vampire Weekend and Wolf Parade). And one got a whopping D+ (sorry, Mates Of State!).
— Of the 19 people who voted, there were 18 different number-ones.
— We haven't heard of most of the records on Aaron Burgess' list, either.
— The Abe Vigoda and Nick Cave records were cited four times each, but didn't come anywhere near charting.
— Please use the comments section not only to decry the lameness of our lists, but also to publish your own.
The Ballots
Joshua Alston, freelancer

New Amerykah Pt. 1
(10 pts)

Dear Science
(10 pts)

Leave It All Behind
(10 pts)

Third
(9 pts)

Los Angeles
(9 pts)

Love Behind The Melody
(8 pts)

The Renaissance
(8 pts)

Of All The Things
(7 pts)

Out My Window
(6 pts)

Tronic
(6 pts)

Into the Blue
(5 pts)

Chemical Chords
(5 pts)

Love To Make Music To
(3 pts)

Well Dressed For The Art Show
(2 pts)

Car Alarm
(2 pts)
The Ballots
Christopher Bahn, Minneapolis city editor

Feel Good Ghosts (Tea-Partying Through Tornadoes)
(15 pts)

Narrow Stairs
(10 pts)

Wreckless Eric And Amy Rigby
(9 pts)

In The 7th Moon, The Chief Turned Into A Swimming Fish And Ate The Head Of His Enemy By Magic
(8 pts)

Stay Positive
(8 pts)

Velocifero
(8 pts)

For Emma, Forever Ago
(7 pts)

Dear Science
(7 pts)

When Life Gives You Lemons, You Paint That Shit Gold
(7 pts)

Retribution Gospel Choir
(7 pts)

Jukebox
(4 pts)

The Golden Hour
(4 pts)

Hey Ma
(2 pts)

49:00
(2 pts)

A Mad And Faithful Telling
(2 pts)
The Ballots
Andy Battaglia, New York city editor

Saturdays=Youth
(12 pts)

New Amerykah: Part One
(10 pts)
Erykah Badu came back after a few years away with the calmest kind of vengeance, with an evocative series of R&B; sketches sung by a star so starry that she sounds most powerful when barely there.

Fabric 41
(10 pts)
A worldly DJ/producer (grown from a mix of Swiss and Chilean roots), Luciano reconciled dance music's appetite for ecstatic thrills and austere minimalism on a DJ mix that plays just as well on any scale—big vs. small, palpable vs. obscure, hands in the air vs. hands drawing diagrams of beats that build and recede when the mood calls for it.

Microcastle
(10 pts)

Tha Carter III
(8 pts)

The Midnight Organ Fight
(8 pts)
Indie-rock done totally right—with more passion than poise, and absolutely no anxiety-of-influence to fight against.

Skeletal Lamping
(8 pts)

First If You Please
(8 pts)
More than any other album I loved this year, First If You Please came out as a viable candidate for what pop might sound like in 20 or 30 years. It was made in a minimal-techno mold—as fashioned by the likes of Ricardo Villalobos and Luciano, among many rustling others. But Los Updates mastermind Jorge Gonzalez upends the album's propulsive purpose with songs about sex that writhe, churn, and moan—sometimes awkwardly but also automatically, like songs about sex should.

Furr
(8 pts)
It's hard to place what exactly about Blitzen Trapper can make a listener flash so hard on The Band. But it's hard to place Blitzen Trapper in almost every way—save for somewhere near the sweet spot where rootsy rock retains its formative swagger and faith in chance.

For Emma, Forever Ago
(5 pts)

Silent Movie
(5 pts)

Let The Blind Lead Those Who Can See But Cannot Feel
(3 pts)

Mothertongue
(3 pts)

Sound Sculptures Volume 1
(1 pts)
Maker of a magically patient kind of dance music, Theo Parrish wrings more out of the ephemeral aspects of rhythm and swing than most producers can hope to swallow in a lifetime. His slow, sensuous (and let's just say it: stoner) style of house-music is big in his native Detroit, but Parrish sounds like he'd be at home wherever a few beats can be given time to glisten.

The Way I See It
(1 pts)
HONORABLE MENTIONS
- 2562, Aerial
- Amp Fiddler/Sly & Robbie, Inspiration Information
- Carl Craig, Sessions
- Flying Lotus, Los Angeles
- Kid Creole, Going Places: The August Darnell Years 1976-1983
- The Mole, As High As The Sky
- Paavoharju, Laulu Laakson Kukista
- Ricardo Villalobos, Vasco
- Stefann Goldman, The Transitory State
- Kylie Minogue, "Wow"
The Ballots
Aaron Burgess, freelancer

Watershed
(15 pts)

obZen
(14 pts)

The Chemistry Of Common Life
(14 pts)

The Age Of Nero
(12 pts)

Vertebrae
(10 pts)

The Way Of All Flesh
(10 pts)

Life… The Best Game In Town
(9 pts)

New Lexicon
(8 pts)

Massive Conspiracy Against All Life
(6 pts)

Still Nothing Moves You
(6 pts)
The Ballots
Scott Gordon, Madison city editor

The Bees Made Honey In The Lion's Skull
(10 pts)

A Mad And Faithful Telling
(10 pts)

Offend Maggie
(10 pts)

The Chemistry Of Common Life
(10 pts)

If Children
(10 pts)

The Family Afloat
(10 pts)

Ice Cream Spiritual
(5 pts)
HONORABLE MENTIONS
Abe Vigoda, Skeleton
Black Mountain, In The
Future
Bon Iver, For Emma, Forever
Ago
Nick Cave And The Bad
Seeds, Dig, Lazarus, Dig!!!
The Dears, Missiles
Dengue Fever, Venus On
Earth
Doomtree, Doomtree
Damien Jurado, Caught In
The Trees
Flying Lotus, Los Angeles
Horse Feathers, House With
No Home
Land Of Talk, Some Are
Lakes
The Magnetic Fields,
Distortion
The Night Marchers, See You
In Magic
Oneida, Preteen Weaponry
Parts And Labor, Receivers
Retribution Gospel Choir,
Retribution Gospel Choir
Shearwater, Rook
Subtle, ExitingARM
Thee Oh Sees, The Master's
Bedroom is Worth Spending A Night In
We Versus The Shark, Dirty
Versions
Jim White, Transnormal
Skipperoo
The Ballots
Marc Hawthorne, San Francisco city editor

Viva La Vida Or Death And All His Friends
(10 pts)

The Golden Age
(10 pts)

April
(10 pts)

Secrets Of The Sea
(10 pts)

Made Of Bricks
(10 pts)

Med Sud I Eyrum Vid Spilum Endalaust
(10 pts)

Reality Check
(10 pts)

Vampire Weekend
(10 pts)

Keep Your Eyes Ahead
(10 pts)

Dreaming Of Revenge
(10 pts)
The Ballots
Jason Heller, Denver city editor

From The Bottom
(15 pts)

In The Future
(12 pts)

The Chemistry Of Common Life
(9 pts)

Missiles
(9 pts)

Matador Singles '08
(9 pts)

Trash Talk
(9 pts)

Vivian Girls
(8 pts)

The '59 Sound
(8 pts)

Old Wounds
(6 pts)

13 Blues For Thirteen Moons
(6 pts)

Gentleman Jesse And His Men
(3 pts)

Ice Cream Spiritual
(3 pts)

Eat The Low Dogs
(1 pts)

The Airing Of Grievances
(1 pts)

Static Thoughts
(1 pts)
RUNNERS UP
Earth, The Bees Made Honey In The Lion's Skull
Pierced Arrows, Straight To The Heart
The Magnetic Fields, Distortion
Torche, Meanderthal
Bonnie "Prince" Billy, Lie Down In The Light
Saviours, Into Abaddon
No Age, Nouns
New Bloods, The Secret Life
R.E.M., Accelerate
Times New Viking, Rip It Off
Russian Circles, Station
The Ballots
Steven Hyden, Milwaukee city editor

April
(15 pts)

Brighter Than Creation's Dark
(15 pts)

The Felice Brothers
(10 pts)

Dig, Lazarus, Dig!
(10 pts)

Stay Positive
(10 pts)

Skeletal Lamping
(4 pts)

Mudcrutch
(4 pts)

For Emma, Forever Ago
(4 pts)

Singles 06-07/Matador Singles 08
(4 pts)

The Cool
(4 pts)

The Hopeful And Unafraid
(4 pts)

Receivers
(4 pts)

Now Or Heaven
(4 pts)

Two Men With The Blues
(4 pts)

In The Future
(4 pts)
HONORABLE MENTIONS
Deerhunter, Mircocastle
Headlights, Some Racing, Some Stopping
The Championship, Midnight Golden
Beach House, Devotion
Alejandro Escovedo, Real Animal
Elusive Parallelograms, And Everything Changes
Evangelicals, The Evening Descends
The Black Crowes, Warpaint
Todd Snider, Peace Queer
Marah, Angels Of Destruction
Constantines, Kensington Heights
Conor Oberst, Conor Oberst
The Ballots
Genevieve Koski, copy editor

Santogold
(12 pts)

Hold On Now Youngster
(12 pts)

Flight Of The Conchords
(10 pts)

The '59 Sound
(10 pts)

The Bake Sale
(10 pts)

Stay Positive
(8 pts)

Brighter Than Creation's Dark
(8 pts)

Feed The Animals
(8 pts)

Robyn
(6 pts)

This Is It…
(4 pts)

Rockferry
(4 pts)

Jim
(4 pts)

The Cool
(4 pts)
The Ballots
Chris Martins, freelancer

The Chemistry Of Common Life
(15 pts)

Alopecia
(15 pts)

Lost Wisdom
(12 pts)

Exiting Arm
(10 pts)

Hercules And Love Affair
(10 pts)

For Emma, Forever Ago
(10 pts)

Dear Science
(8 pts)

Street Horrrsing
(5 pts)

Sexualityg
(5 pts)

Devotion
(5 pts)

Nouns
(4 pts)

Get Hot
(4 pts)
RUNNERS UP:
Lykke
Li, Youth Novels
Tobacco,
Fucked Up Friends
Dr.
Dog, Fate
Flying
Lotus, Los Angeles
Abe
Vigoda, Skeleton
Nick
Cave, Dig, Lazarus, Dig!!!
Department
Of Eagles, In Ear Park
Parenthetical
Girls, Entanglements
The
Cool Kids, The Bake Sale
Radiohead,
In Rainbows
Vampire
Weekend, Vampire Weekend
Restiform
Bodies, TV Loves You Back
BEST UNOFFICIAL RELEASES
1.
Buck 65, Dirtbike 2/3
2.
Buck 65, Dirtbike 1/3
3.
Buck 65, Dirtbike 3/3
BEST REISSUE OF A FAMOUS PIMP DOING SPOKEN WORD:
Iceberg Slim, Reflections
The Ballots
Michaelangelo Matos, freelancer

Year Of The Gentleman
(15 pts)

Poplife Presents Poplife Sucks
(15 pts)

New Amerykah Part 1
(10 pts)

The Way I See It
(10 pts)

Hercules And Love Affair
(10 pts)

Third
(10 pts)

Tha Carter III
(10 pts)

Los Angeles
(10 pts)

The Chemistry Of Common Life
(5 pts)

Sol-Angel And The Hadley St. Dreams
(5 pts)
The Ballots
Chris Mincher, freelancer

Jim Noir
(15 pts)
Jim Noir's 2006 debut Tower Of Love was one of the best collections of songs this decade, but that's also what it felt like: a weird, wonderful mix-tape of sorts. On his follow-up, the bowler-hatted one has turned his spaced-out aesthetic into an actual album, and the result is a delightful one-two punch of songwriting and artistic cohesion. There's a surging immediacy to this set, exploding on the opening "Welcome Commander Jameson" and soaring into the stratosphere with the bouncing electronic-pop gem "All Right." By its end, Noir's sophomore effort is the embodiment of perfect pop music as opposed to pop songs.

The Golden Age
(14 pts)

Dear Science
(13 pts)

Fleet Foxes
(12 pts)

Crimes
(12 pts)
Jesse Elliott has found a good way to ensure his music never gets pigeonholed: Release two albums in seven months, each eclectic in its own right and yet starkly different. On These United States' March debut A Picture Of The Three Of Us At The Gate To The Garden Of Eden, Elliott found an unusually seamless mix of Postal Service-esque indie electronica ("First Sight") and coolly compelling psych-folk ("Burn This Bridge" and "Slow Crows Over"). Then, in September, he rounded up a full band and released Crimes, a rousing, stylistic romp through roots music and rockabilly. Recorded in Kentucky, Crimes is an ambitious throwdown at a crowded, bourbon-drinking roadhouse, a type of blues-rock not made whatsoever for fans of blues rock.

Real Animal
(10 pts)
Who knows what "rock 'n 'roll" even means anymore? You can take almost any word in the dictionary, add a hyphen and stick "rock" on the end of it, and it's a genre someone's tried to create. "Rock" may now be too ubiquitous for simple characterization, but, if there's any value left in the term's original definition, Alejandro Escovedo's Real Animal is rich indeed. On his ninth studio album, decades into his musical career, Escovedo has an astounding level of passion for the kind of rough, unapologetic rock that finds strength in focus and power in simplicity. Escovedo is not dabbling in artfulness here; Real Animal brings together the swagger of his punk roots and the emotion of his bluesier days.

Vampire Weekend
(9 pts)

Sounds Like This
(7 pts)
Those looking for an obvious crack on, say, Lindsay Lohan can trust Perez Hilton to supply that to them. Serious music fans would not put much stock in his personal playlist—but after gushing about Hutchinson's Sounds Like This, it appears he at least got one right. Not that it's too hard to find merit in Hutchinson's sophomore studio effort; front to back, Sounds Like This is a playful, piano-powered pop album that brings to mind Stevie Wonder's most freewheelin' days. Sure, on first impression, Hutchinson looks like one of those dime-a-dozen sensitive pretty-boy songwriters who dominate the adult-alternative-driven soundtracks of certain TV network drama series, and, yes, the album is sure to get play in all the mainstream places that will make music snobs gag. But one can't knock the guy for putting out such an energetic, supremely catchy collection of sharply penned songs that people outside of the local independent CD shop will appreciate it.

Line In The Sand
(5 pts)
Beginning as a sort of reggae-ska-jam-band, then turning into a sort of generic funk-rock group, Zox never merited much attention, only hinting at any break with conventional "alternative" crapola best kept at community festivals and college bars. Which makes Line In The Sand, the group's third effort, a wonderful reminder that the most unlikely bands can create something worthwhile when they earnestly push themselves to. And Zox certainly have pushed themselves here, with a show of musicianship that lasts long after the CD has stopped spinning. On Line In The Sand, reggae and ska are just diverse elements in a larger musical formula that's open and without limits—whether it's substituting lead guitar with electric violin (it works), or borrowing qualities of The Police and their '80s brethren, or grounding songs in a weepy synth hook (as on "Goodnight"), everything fits and nothing feels forced.

At Mount Zoomer
(4 pts)
The Ballots
Josh Modell, managing editor

The Midnight Organ Fight
(15 pts)

Hold On Now Youngster
(15 pts)

Narrow Stairs
(12 pts)

You & Me
(12 pts)

At Mount Zoomer
(9 pts)

Curses
(9 pts)

Med Sud I Eyrum Vid Spilum Endalaust
(9 pts)

Elephant Shell
(4 pts)

Songs In A&E;
(4 pts)

Retribution Gospel Choir
(4 pts)

Lose Big
(4 pts)

A Hundred Million Suns
(3 pts)
AWESOME SONGS FROM ALBUMS THAT DIDN'T MAKE THE LIST
Deerhunter, "Little Kids"
R.E.M., "Horse To Water"
Titus Andronicus, "My Time
Outside The Womb"
Land Of Talk, "Some Are
Lakes"
Forward Russia, "We Are Grey
Matter"
Okkervil River, "Calling And
Not Calling My Ex"
Bloc Party, "Zephyrus"
Dead Confederate, "The Rat"
Abe Vigoda, "Dead City/Waste
Wilderness"
Elbow, "The Bones Of You"
Crooked Fingers, "Let's Not
Pretend (To Be New Men)"
The Wombats, "Let's Dance To
Joy Division"
Sun Kil Moon, "Moorestown"
Lil Mama, "Lip Gloss"
Los Campesinos, "We Are
Beautiful, We Are Doomed"
Cold War Kids, "Something Is
Not Right With Me"
M83, "Graveyard Girl"
Coldplay, "Lost!"
The Hold Steady, "Stay
Positive"
Pink, "So What"
Santogold, "L.E.S. Artistes"
The Ballots
Sean O'Neal, Austin city editor

Dear Science
(10 pts)

The Chemistry Of Common Life
(10 pts)

You & Me
(10 pts)

In Ear Park
(10 pts)

Rook
(10 pts)

Curses
(5 pts)

Songs In A&E;
(5 pts)

The Cool
(5 pts)

Antidotes
(5 pts)

Do You Like Rock Music?
(5 pts)

Entanglements
(5 pts)

Fleet Foxes
(5 pts)

Beat Pyramid
(5 pts)

For Emma, Forever Ago
(5 pts)

Kensington Heights
(5 pts)
NEAR MISSES:
The
Fall, Imperial Wax Solvent
Wire,
Object 47
DeVotchKa,
A Mad And Faithful Telling
Nick
Cave, Dig Lazarus Dig
Why?,
Alopecia
Hercules
And Love Affair, Hercules
And Love Affair
Delta
Spirit, Ode To Sunshine
M83,
Saturdays = Youth
Atlas
Sound, Let The Blind Lead Those Who Can See But Cannot Feel
The
Childballads, Cheekbone Hollows
Mt.
Eerie, Lost Wisdom
Cool
Kids, The Bake Sale
The
Dears, Missiles
The
Kills, Midnight Boom
White
Denim, Exposion
The
Black And White Years, The
Black And White Years
Re-Up
Gang, Clipse Presents: Re-Up Gang
Hello
Lovers, Gone With The Wind
Crystal
Stilts, Alight Of Night
The
Physics Of Meaning, Snake Charmer And Destiny At The Stroke Of Midnight
Abe
Vigoda, Skeleton
31Knots,
Worried Well
Blood
On The Wall, Liferz
GOOD SONGS FROM ALBUMS NOT ON THE LIST
MGMT,
"Time To Pretend"
R.E.M.,
"Living Well Is The Best Revenge"
Kanye
West, "Welcome To Heartbreak"
Cold
War Kids, "Something Is Not Right With Me"
Antony
And The Johnsons, "Shake That Devil"
The
Cure, "This. Here And Now. With You"
Duffy,
"Mercy"
Facing
New York, "Cops On Bikes"
GZA,
"Life Is A Movie"
The
Lemurs, "Yours Mine And Ours"
Cadence
Weapon, "House Music"
David
Byrne/Brian Eno, "Strange Overtones"
Subtle,
"The Crow"
School
Of Seven Bells, "Wired For Light"
Dead
Confederate, "The Rat"
Does
It Offend You, Yeah?, "With A Heavy Heart (I Regret To Inform You)"
MOST IRRITATING SONG OF THE YEAR
TIE: Katy Perry, "I Kissed A Girl" / Lil Wayne, "A Milli" / Yael Naïm, "New Soul"
BEST REISSUE/REDISCOVERY
Arthur Russell, Love Is Overtaking Me
BIGGEST DISAPPOINTMENT
TIE: The Streets, Everything Is Borrowed / Of Montreal, Skeletal Lamping
ALBUM THAT DIDN'T MAKE THE LIST OUT OF PRINCIPLE, BUT WHICH IS NEVERTHELESS A LOT OF FUN TO LISTEN TO:
Girl Talk, Feed The Animals
THE ROGER MURTAUGH "I'M TOO OLD FOR THIS SHIT" AWARD:
The Death Set (and anything else from "Wham City")
The Ballots
Amanda Petrusich, freelancer

Nouns
(10 pts)

Fleet Foxes
(10 pts)

In Ear Park
(8 pts)

Lie Down In The Light
(8 pts)

For Emma, Forever Ago
(8 pts)

Shallow Grave
(8 pts)

Como Now: The Voices Of Panolo Co., Mississippi
(7 pts)

At Mount Zoomer
(6 pts)

Roamin' And Ramblin'
(5 pts)

In The Future
(5 pts)

New Amerykah, Part 1
(5 pts)

Dear Science
(5 pts)

Youth Novels
(5 pts)

Hercules And Love Affair
(5 pts)

Skeleton
(5 pts)
The Ballots
Keith Phipps, editor

Hold On Now Youngster
(15 pts)

Re-Arrange Us
(14 pts)

You & Me
(13 pts)

Dear Science
(12 pts)

Third
(11 pts)

Accelerate
(7 pts)

Keep Your Eyes Ahead
(7 pts)

Lucky
(7 pts)

Vampire Weekend
(7 pts)

808s & Heartbreak
(7 pts)
The Ballots
Nathan Rabin, head writer

What Does It All Mean?
(10 pts)

The Bake Sale
(10 pts)

Man In The Mirror
(10 pts)

Untitled
(10 pts)

Dropping Science Fiction
(10 pts)

Feed The Animals
(10 pts)

The In Crowd
(10 pts)

The Cool
(10 pts)

Yancey Boys
(10 pts)

Beat Konducta Volume 5-6
(10 pts)
HONORABLE MENTIONS
Jake One, White Van Music
J-Zone featuring Chief
Chinchilla, Live @ The Liqua Store
The Ballots
Vadim Rizov, freelancer

You & Me
(10 pts)

Everything That Happens Will Happen Today
(10 pts)

The Seldom Seen Kid
(10 pts)

Vampire Weekend
(10 pts)

Devotion
(10 pts)

The Carter III
(10 pts)

Dear Science
(10 pts)

Stainless Style
(10 pts)

Exotic Creatures Of The Deep
(10 pts)

A Mouthful
(10 pts)
10 GREAT SONGS FROM NON-TOP-10 ALBUMS
No Kids, "Great Escape"
Rivers Cuomo, "Can't Stop Partying"
Grand Archives, "Sleepdriving"
T.I. featuring Rihanna, "Live Your Life"
The Donkeys, "Nice Train"
Tindersticks, "The Organist Entertains"
Radar Brothers, "When Cold Air Goes To Sleep"
The Dodos, "Park Song"
Margot & The Nuclear So & So's, "I Am A Lightning Rod"
Dominique Leone, "Duyen"
The Ballots
Kyle Ryan, associate editor/Decider editor

Re-Arrange Us
(10 pts)

Narrow Stairs
(10 pts)

Stay Positive
(9 pts)

Flight Of The Conchords
(9 pts)

The '59 Sound
(9 pts)

Appeal To Reason
(9 pts)

Receivers
(8 pts)

Dear Science
(8 pts)

Rising Down
(8 pts)

Forfeit/Fortune
(7 pts)

Lose Big
(7 pts)

The Cool
(3 pts)

Devils In My Details
(2 pts)

