Say Anything: In Defense Of The Genre

A.V. Club Most Read

Say Anything: In Defense Of The Genre


Say Anything

Album: In Defense Of The Genre
Label: J

Community Grade (5 Users)

  • A
  • A-
  • B+
  • B
  • B-
  • C+
  • C
  • C-
  • D+
  • D
  • D-
  • F

Your Grade


"Baby Girl, I'm A Blur," the first single from Say Anything's new In Defense Of The Genre, is a lousy song—worse than that, it's misleading, considering that the album as a whole is far more intriguing. The two-disc set is an eclectic eruption of Max Bemis' teeming brain, a roiling stew of bile and hemorrhaged hearts that pits loops, scratches, metal riffs, and even showtune pop against nü-punk songcraft. The flashpoint is the title track: Although the word "emo" is absent, it's obvious which genre Bemis is referencing. But—as in the controversy-baiting "Died A Jew" and its incendiary line, "My people were slaves before yours invented hip-hop"—his stance is so wrapped in sarcasm, it's tough to pinpoint whether he's being straight, satirical, or both. Regardless, Bemis has concocted a deliciously confounding album that transcends emo more than defends it.

Content continues below