carolinesiede
Caroline Siede
carolinesiede
Contributor, The A.V. Club. Caroline Siede is a pop culture critic in Chicago, where the cold never bothers her anyway. She loves sci-fi, Jane Austen, and co-hosting the movie podcast, Role Calling.
6/09/21 11:04AM
77

Can we just give another shout out to Natalie Holt and her amazing score for this. We get spooky theremin sci-fi music mixed with more mournful tones, and it just works so well.

6/04/21 8:05AM
11

Thank you for writing pieces like these. I love rom coms and always love getting to discover new ones through your column. I'll be looking for this film now so that I can watch it this weekend. I appreciate being exposed to something new to me!

4/09/21 11:11AM
2

People singing every line of dialogue is far from the most unrealistic thing in this movie. Read more

3/24/21 2:43AM
6

I’m an “armchair astrologer” at best so take what I say with a grain of salt. Jack definitely seems more like a Virgo to me (typical traits: hard-working, reliable, patient, kind; on the negative side: critical and stubborn). However, a person’s astrology chart is so much more than their sun (aka birth date) sign. Read more

2/13/21 2:45PM
1

The film’s framing was a bit clunky, but it’s heart was all there. The soundtrack is absolute FIRE. I love all three Brown Sugar songs on it. Like Romeo Must Die, I sometimes feel that the soundtrack was better than the film. Seeing spouses Nicole Ari Parker and Boris Kodjoe both in the film playing potential spouses Read more

12/18/20 3:25PM
4

Thanks so much for writing this, Caroline! I grew up watching this movie every year on VHS. It’s a favorite of my mom’s, and she always put it on while we decorated the tree. Read more

12/18/20 7:43AM
30

Thanks, Caroline, for a great piece on a wonderful, now somewhat forgotten film. I watch it every Christmas and it is a real gem on multiple levels and beautifully made. It’s worth mentioning how Warner Brothers went against the Hollywood tide of black stereotypes with both this movie and “Casablanca” and while Read more

12/10/20 11:54AM
21

But the greedy exec didn’t think, in his plan,
That the A.V Club’s grinch would deliver a pan!
“Those monsters! Those devils!” he said with a shout.
“How can English majors have so much damn clout?”

12/10/20 2:39AM
68

Why, for 54 years I’ve put up with them now!
I must stop these Grinch adaptations from coming! But how?

11/23/20 9:43AM
24

At the very least, I hope this episode sent people to dig up Billy Joel’s music video of UPTOWN GIRL. It’s the most fun, 80s thing you will ever see with Joel strutting and dancing like the lead in a regional theater production of GREASE and Christie Brinkley looking impossibly beautiful and sassy, a projection I

10/12/20 12:54PM
1

I am ride or die for Dirty Dancing and will forever champion it. I still remember the first time I watched it (my 8th birthday party - hilariously my mom watched it beforehand to make sure it was appropriate for kids and was like, “yeah, seems fine.”) and I’ve probably seen it at least 50 times since. (As well as the Read more

10/09/20 11:02AM
36

The way you describe the character arcs of Baby and Johnny makes me think it’s a bit of a gender swap, in that Johnny is the one who’s a bit in need of rescuing, while Baby is more of the white knight.   Read more