B

Dig reunites Amy Poehler and Mike Schur for a show with Parks And Rec’s charm and heart, if not its laughs

Like any archaeological excavation, Dig takes some time to sift through the dirt to get to the pivotal stuff.

Dig reunites Amy Poehler and Mike Schur for a show with Parks And Rec’s charm and heart, if not its laughs

Less than five minutes into Dig‘s series premiere, archaeologist Elise (Amy Poehler) tells a subordinate, “You know my motto: Work hard and never have fun.” Sounds a little like her Parks And Recreation character Leslie Knope, doesn’t it? (Though go-getter civil servant Leslie would be likelier to fall in the “Hard work is fun” camp.) Comparisons to that beloved NBC sitcom are inevitable; Dig once again finds her playing a workaholic boss with incredibly supportive gal pals in a comedy co-created by Mike Schur. An empty pit even factors into the plot— and quite a few physical gags. But that, plus a tendency to wear its heart on its sleeve, are where any superficial similarities between Parks And Rec and Dig end. In their latest TV team-up, Poehler and Schur make a gentler, more grounded series that isn’t as remotely laugh-out-loud funny as their seven seasons in Pawnee, IN.

Based on Kate Myers’ 2023 novel Excavations, Dig centers on four women who stumble into a wildly goofy opportunity to solve a mystery and further their careers in the process. Elise has spent the past 15 summers returning to a dig site in Greece to work under her “nice guy” mentor, Neville (Hugh Laurie), who keeps failing to fulfill his promise to retire so she can take over. Luckily, Elise strikes gold—or rather, precious marble—when she finds a 2,000-year old artifact inside that aforementioned pit. She works in secret with their colleagues Claire (Antonia Thomas), Patty (Fina Strazza), and Dylan (Geraldine Viswanathan) to dig up this big statue of the Greek goddess Hera without reporting to the authorities, lest Neville take the credit for their hard work. Elise hopes this discovery will bring her the visibility and promotion she deserves. But just how long can they keep it a secret? The tension of a covert operation brings the characters closer, which is when Dig‘s true premise comes alive. 

The comedy unevenly explores the personal and professional hardships that Elise, Dylan, Claire, and Patty face individually. But the series shines when they start to build a genuine connection despite their many differences—Leslie Knope would indeed be proud of how a disciplinarian like Elise opens up to the trio and recognizes that, without them, she couldn’t complete her mission.

But like any excavation process, Dig takes some time to sift through the dirt to get to the pivotal stuff. The show gets off to a rough, unfunny start; the first few of the 10 half-hour episodes serve as straightforward setup. Schur and Poehler struggle to smoothly establish Dig‘s novel setting and introduce its disparate characters or their history with each other. Disappointingly, they rely on some hackneyed fat jokes that are out of place in the otherwise relatively feel-good agenda.

Once the dust settles, Dig starts polishing its comedic sweet spot. It’s tonally akin to Schur’s other streaming comedy, Netflix’s A Man On The Inside, because here, too, the protagonist unexpectedly rediscovers herself and makes new friends amid lies and the danger of getting caught and fired. Dig reinforces that Schur (along with Poehler and the writers’ room) deftly balances lighthearted humor with the tougher, resonant topics of loneliness, feeling like an outsider, and finding human connection at any age or in any place. It’s a particularly effective comedy about the value of female friendships. Zeroing in on this theme gives Dig its strength, but the show demands patience as it gets to its point. 

In her late 40s and reeling from a bad divorce, Elise is unmoored in the job she loves. So it’s a joy to watch her let loose as she reconnects with the unruly 29-year-old Dylan, who returns to the dig site after she abruptly left five years ago due to a bad breakup. Poehler and Viswanathan are a hilarious yin-and-yang duo, with Dylan as the chaos agent to Elise’s cool, calm demeanor. A similar dynamic takes shape between Dylan and the uppity, wealthy Claire, who is now engaged to Dylan’s ex-boyfriend, Gary (Jon Pointing). It’s a welcome change that instead of pitting the two women against each other, Dig lets Dylan and Claire bond and find common ground. They may all appear one-note at first, but the writers find ways for them to flourish as multi-dimensional women. 

It does take a while to do this for Patty, though. A naive 19-year-old farm girl, Patty joins the team from a small Maine town as Neville’s inexperienced, clumsy assistant—she still uses Yahoo and routinely talks to animals as if they were people. But it sure feels like Dig doesn’t know how much to turn her into a caricature, whether through Patty’s heightened vocal fry or by making her a frequent punching bag. Thankfully, Patty (and, therefore, Strazza’s performance) finds focus as the season progresses and Patty becomes part of the main group, helping Elise, Dylan, and Claire keep the Hera excavation project a top secret, at least until their plans go awry. 

Dig brings in elements of a comedic thriller when the women are spied upon and realize they’re in danger. The potential culprits vary from local looters (featuring, what else, an accent-heavy Jason Mantzoukas appearance) to the neighboring town’s mayor, Stavros (Kayvan Novak), who has an unrequited crush on Elise. Casting the What We Do In The Shadows actor as Poehler’s hot, messy love interest proves to be one of Dig‘s most inspired choices, along with Viswanathan’s, since she’s the scene-stealer with comic timing as sharp as a knife. 

Thanks to an impressive team on- and off-camera, Dig has the potential to become one of Peacock’s signature originals. The platform needs it, given a comedy slate that has struggled with cancellations or shows left in limbo. But with last year’s The Office spin-off, The Paper, and now a sweet but subdued Schur and Poehler collaboration, the powers-that-be are relying on familiar faces to elevate its lineup. Dig evolves slowly, but eventually finds the momentum to become the wholesome, quirky comedy it wants to be. 

Saloni Gajjar is The A.V. Club‘s TV critic. 

Dig premieres November 23 on Peacock.

 
Join the discussion...
Keep scrolling for more great stories.