The “movie star” is a deliberately nebulous, “I’ll know it when I see it” sort of concept—distinct, and sometimes even actively opposed, to the idea of being a great actor, romantic lead, or comedian. (Indeed, you could argue that continuing to be massively famous and pulling people into theaters despite not giving all that “good” of a performance is one of the hallmarks of the whole idea.) It is, in other words, the sort of thing tailor-made for people to get into extremely granular and specific-to-their-perspectives arguments about—something Variety went ahead and proved today by dropping a ranked list of the 100 “Greatest” movie stars of all time on the internet’s head.
As with any definitive ranking of anything so subjective, it’s an absurd result to an absurd exercise. In situations like this, we like to imagine the arguments that produce, say, the decision to name Matt Damon and Jack Lemmon at positions 71 and 70, respectively; obviously, there’s a sense that Lemmon should be ahead of Damon—but only by one space, and, somewhere near the back of the list. The idea that Damon and Lemmon are somehow almost the same amount of movie star—and significantly ahead of, say, Philip Seymour Hoffman, Lillian Gish, or Divine, is part of what turns this whole thing into a Rorschach test with pictures of famous people. (Oh, and Ben Affleck didn’t rate at all—a continuing data point in how we, as a society, get a little kick out of treating him just a smidge worse than we treat Damon.)
Like any such test, the most interesting thing about the list winds up being its various attempts to correct for, and sometimes just to steer into, generational, cultural, national, and other biases. Nobody born this century made the cut, for instance, while the youngest person in the Top 10, Tom Cruise, is a spritely 64. There are a few efforts to break out of the Hollywood mold, bringing in Italian actor Marcello Mastroianni and Bollywood star Shah Rukh Khan; nevertheless, it’s hard not to notice how aggressively white the overall rankings are, with just a handful of women of color (including Whoopi Goldberg, Zendaya, and Dorothy Dandridge) interspersed within the crowds.
Anyway, it’s a decent way to give yourself a headache imagining the thought process behind it, if nothing else. (Really? Nicolas Cage at 89th?!) You can view the full list here. Keep the aspirin handy.