James Frey: Bright Shiny Morning
It's against the rules to
judge a book by its cover, but in the case of James Frey's debut novel, Bright
Shiny Morning,
it might be worth making an exception. The blurb on the inside cover struggles
to exploit Frey's fame without explicitly referencing the uproar surrounding
his debunked "memoir," A Million Little Pieces; the phrases "strikingly
powerful" and "tour de force" are thrown around with wild abandon, and Frey is
described as "one of the most celebrated and controversial authors in America."
Obviously criticizing a novel or its author because of an overzealous
copywriter is unfair, but the desperate push for literary greatness mirrors the
central flaw of Morning's well-intentioned but top-heavy core: Its modest charms
collapse under the weight of its pretensions.