C-

Yellowjackets' final season is a total and complete mess

Paramount+'s once-acclaimed and inventive psychological thriller derails itself by the end.

Yellowjackets' final season is a total and complete mess

The pressure to deliver a satisfying final season is intense for any modern TV series, but even more so for a puzzle box like Yellowjackets, with its numerous loose ends, lingering questions, and large ensemble. The psychological thriller has teased intriguing mysteries about the horrors that befell a high school soccer team after their plane crashed in the Canadian wilderness in 1996—a burned cabin! A man with no eyes! Strange symbols! Cruel hunting games! Cannibalism!—and portrayed the survivors’ persisting anguish as they reunited 25 years later. But what was once a compelling, gory saga about complex female friendships, adolescence, rage, and an allegory for society itself à la Lord Of The Flies devolved into a soapy drama over the course of seasons two and three. Season four starts out in a rut, and based on the first eight of its 10 episodes, it doesn’t appear that Yellowjackets will escape it. 

Even as it nears its bitter end, Yellowjackets can’t figure out if it wants to be a campy drama about young girls who survived by unhinged means and are now haunted by their actions, or if it’s a supernatural thriller about the sinister woods forced them to revert to primal and violent urges during their 19-month ordeal. Are the high-schoolers among the many victims of It (their nickname for the malevolent force—not to be confused with the ancient evil that haunts Derry, ME), or are they simply making up stories to soothe their collective trauma? Season four rolls out answers a little too late. And even then, Yellowjackets is afraid to commit. It dangles truths in front of us like a tempting treat, then irritatingly pulls them away because there’s not enough time (or inclination) left to go all in. With disparate thematic ideas, a confounding pace, weak writing, and half-hearted performances, the show whimpers to a disappointing end.

Yellowjackets had already lost sight of its compelling suspense and characters in favor of inane plot twists and abandoned or inconsequential arcs like the hasty deaths of adult Natalie (Juliette Lewis) and Lottie (Simone Kessell), or the dead-end addition of Walter (Elijah Wood), a citizen detective love interest for Misty’s (Cristina Ricci). Even the romance between Taissa (Tawny Cypress) and Van (Lauren Ambrose) concluded haphazardly because of Van’s unceremonious death at the hands of Melissa (Hilary Swank) in the third-season finale. As season four picks up the pieces, it doesn’t hone in on a defining arc, plot and character-wise, for the Yellowjackets’ swan song. Instead, the show splits into three timelines that are dull to varying degrees. 

Pre-rescue, as the teens wait to be saved after Nat (Sophie Thatcher) signals for help using a satellite phone, they come up with the lies they need to tell when they go home. If only Lottie (Courtney Eaton) and Shauna (Sophie Nelisse)—or is it some paranormal entity?—would let them do it in peace. That rote arc gets dragged out in favor of a far more interesting timeline: the one where the girls return as heroes to Wiskayok, NJ.

As the Yellowjackets deal with the intense media attention, scrutiny from family members, and the daunting task of catching up on everything they’ve missed—X-Files episodes, the rise of the internet—each one adjusts to their homecoming differently. Season four is at its most interesting when diving into the girls’ troubled states of mind as they go back to school, face off bullies, reconnect with exes, attend pool parties, and make new friends. Unfortunately, these scenes have to share oxygen with the flashbacks and the flash-forwards, and they grow disjointed and incoherent in their struggle to breathe. The girls and Travis (Kevin Alves) are rediscovering themselves in their new new normal, but these layers go underexplored. 

When previewing the season last month, co-creators Ashley Lyle and Bart Nickerson said they wanted to show viewers a “full loop” of how the teens grew into the adult versions we met in the pilot. But this is executed by speed-running through their individual arcs upon their return: Tai’s immediate pivot to politics, Shauna’s ongoing relationship with Jeff (Samuel Braun), and Nat and Travis’ addiction issues. At least the romantic crisis between Tai and Van remains a strong emotional core. 

The guest casting remains on-point as well: Season four adds to the show’s roster of ’80s and ’90s teen stars with Molly Ringwald playing Van’s alcoholic mom and Devon Sawa as a potential mentor to Nat. Ken Marino  and June Squibb give particularly evocative performances in the respective roles of Melissa’s brother and Misty’s patient a the senior care facility. But their roles feel shoehorned in. It’s like Yellowjackets forgot that, in its final season, every minute counts.

The most unrepentant offender in this time-wasting spree is, yet again, the present-day timeline. It’s almost impressive that these arcs keep getting clunkier and more excruciating to sit through. This time, adult Tai and Misty plot against Shauna; a calculating Melissa makes a twisted reintegration into the friend group, which immediately kicks off a juvenile war among them; and another Callie (Sarah Desjardins) storyline plays out with the agony of a chronic toothache that the show itself keeps forgetting about. Worst of all, the show defangs its most complicated, fully realized character—The ever-reliable Melanie Lynskey remains a solid onscreen presence, but not even she can elevate the messy material thrown at Shauna this season. It speaks volumes that the most entertaining part of the 2026 timeline is the fling between Shauna’s estranged husband, Jeff Sadecki (Warren Kole), and a new character played by Arrow‘s Emily Bett Rickards. 

All of the spoiled ingredients in the Yellowjackets stew would be slightly easier to digest if the show weren’t hurtling toward an end point. (Lyle and Nickerson initially had a five-season plan, although who knows how that would’ve helped). But with the clock ticking away, this final hoorah doesn’t strive to answer burning questions or give the Yellowjackets more gravitas or depth (not in its first eight episodes, at least). As they navigate their reality in each timeline, Yellowjackets struggles to retain its debut season’s strengths. The music’s still good, though. The pop and alternative hits of the ’90s are as good a soundtrack as any for this type of slow-motion car crash. 

Saloni Gajjar is The A.V. Club‘s TV critic. 

Yellowjackets season four premieres November 20 on Paramount+. New episodes will stream Fridays on Paramount+ with encore presentations Sundays at 9 p.m. ET on Showtime.

 

 
Join the discussion...
Keep scrolling for more great stories.