Stone compulsively keeps the camera moving to a distracting degree, but Scott’s best scenes are in quiet moments he shares between Ian and his friends. Even on stage, the actual scenes of Hamlet are sharply edited and truncated, which is perhaps a comment on the interruption of Ian’s life by AIDS, but it just feels like a choppy montage distracting from Scott’s performance. Cinematographer Mike Eley’s visual style is more of a study of contrasts, draining the color out of 1980s London and casting a gray pall over the events, to emphasize the sickly makeup given to Scott and fellow AIDS patients in Dr. Johnson’s ward. The film’s aesthetic also plays up the differences between Ian’s dual reality. The National Theatre, a famously brutalist building along the Thames, appears foreboding, like a fortress to be conquered. Its shadowy backstages offer Ian a cover to hide his illness from others. However, Dr. Johnson’s hospital wing is blindingly white and antiseptic, made hospitable only by its temporary residents, who rally to enjoy their shared time together. It’s where doctors and patients can speak plainly about their health and this deadly illness, and where hiding anything can jeopardize their health.
Not as unpolished as Stone’s rough direction, Stephen Beresford’s script similarly juggles the dual storylines of Charleson’s life and the general stigma against AIDS patients and the LGBTQ community during the Thatcher era. Sometimes, the latter works organically into Ian’s story, such as when his failing health forces the actor to tell his castmates about his condition, after which they rally around him so he can survive the grueling schedule and the play’s physical demands. Then there’s an ongoing debate between Ian and independent filmmaker Derek Jarman (David Dawson). Jarman was an outspoken gay activist while Charleson kept his private life private out of fear the industry would reject him. While this concern was very much real, the in-film conversation itself feels oddly didactic in a performance that otherwise comes across as so genuine. Yet, Beresford (who reunites with Scott after their previous film Pride), is no stranger to navigating England’s thorny history with the gay community, and sets up more understated moments for Ian, whether that’s learning more about his illness from other patients or leaning on them for support as their worlds get smaller and smaller the worse their health fails.
But Scott is the sole reason Elsinore works so unbelievably well. It’s almost as if he’s redirecting the camera to look at his physical performance, at the cost of what this role meant to Charleson. Like Charleson, Scott has played Hamlet before, and knows well what it’s like to run through thousands of lines night after night, speaking of death and ghosts. In Elsinore, he’s layering in what Charleson might have been going through when reprising the role he knew so well, and it’s remarkable to observe the differences Scott makes to his performance to reflect Ian’s lived experience. Off-stage, Scott finds a warm screen partner in Piper—whose bubbly and supportive Patsy is a representation of the number of friends who stepped up to care for Ian in his final months—and a combative foil in Colman. Although their characters spend much of their time together at odds, Scott and Colman come to share a warm, unspoken rapport with one another, their characters begrudgingly coming around to respect each other’s expertise.
Although Elsinore becomes something of a melodrama as it builds to Charleson’s death, Scott’s performance is much more subdued than the rest of the film, allowing the audience to fill in the breaks with their own stirred emotions. Scott’s focus is more on little gestures of touch and deeply held gazes, only occasionally a full-body sob, which tell Charleson’s story better than any theoretical conversations or busybody directing. He embodies the passion and pain without saying it aloud. While the stage on which Scott gives one of his best performances isn’t perfect, he’s still acting for every seat in the house, more than earning his round of applause.
Director: Simon Stone
Writer: Stephen Beresford
Starring: Andrew Scott, Olivia Colman, Billie Piper, Derek Dawson
Release Date: November 20, 2026