D+

A disastrous doink, incoherent biopic Madden is just bad sketch comedy

Nicolas Cage's caricature of the broadcast legend is confusing, but it's not even the worst part of the movie.

A disastrous doink, incoherent biopic Madden is just bad sketch comedy

John Madden was a man of titanic accomplishments: a Super Bowl-winning coach; a beloved, jolly sportscaster; a video game mogul. A Hall Of Famer, Oakland Raiders royalty, and the biggest personality in any room. Filmmaker David O. Russell tries to capture all of that in Madden, his direct-to-Prime-Video biodramedy, but it’s a disaster. It’s not like Russell fumbles on the goal line—he muffs the opening kickoff, blows his ACL, and gets carted off the field. Though a divisive figure, Russell’s acclaimed works like The Fighter and Silver Linings Playbook prove that he at least understands the basics of filmic language and narrative coherence. Madden‘s playbook stinks of indecision and blind instincts gone wrong. Russell has lost his MVP touch.

In a perplexing, marble-mouthed caricature of America’s favorite football personality, Nicolas Cage transforms into the heavyset John Madden for the film. Christian Bale’s portrayal of Raiders owner Al Davis is more inspired—John’s business-minded best friend who’s always chasing a ring. Russell and co-writer Cambron Clark assume anyone watching is already a John Madden fan, so they start with his first Super Bowl win and build toward his partnership with Electronic Arts founder Trip Hawkins (John Mulaney). It’s a story of workaholics, casualties of gridiron warfare, like John’s too-patient wife Virginia (Kathryn Hahn), and what constitutes a happy life—themes that all slip through Russell’s fingers.

Off the rip, Cage’s take on Madden feels oafish, inarticulate, and delusional, all antithetical to John’s real-life presence. Russell directs Cage as if Madden were sketch comedy, raising the question as to whether he actually knows anything about his film’s subject. John’s constantly the punchline to Cage’s patented brand of giant expressions; the fat suit and prosthetic chin only props for the gag. John’s brilliance in the booth stemmed from his out-of-pocket, jovial sports explanations, with an iconic intonation that Cage doesn’t even attempt. Russell’s direction of Cage plops an absurd turn into Madden that throws the entire film into discombobulation, making one wish that MADtv‘s Frank Caliendo (the master Madden impersonator) could step in as a substitute.

None of this is to say that biopics can’t embellish details or poke fun at their subjects. But while Jon S. Baird’s Tetris successfully upgrades a legal-rights battle with some thrilling car chases (that didn’t happen), Madden isn’t even half-conceptualized as a total package. Russell’s film wants to be a loving satire but incompetently bumbles through Madden’s career highlights and personal lowlights without laying any groundwork. The timeline jumps, cued by Bale’s and Cage’s wig swaps, have zero sensible flow, while John and Virginia’s marital issues lack even the shallowest emotional stakes, given Russell’s inability to take anything seriously—poor Kathryn Hahn, drowning on screen without any life preserver from Russell.

What’s even more bizarre is how lazily Russell establishes John Madden’s backstory. He doesn’t trust the audience to follow the clearest plot advancements, so characters break the fourth wall to tell us what’s happening in an example of streaming-first dialogue, first with a jump scare from Shane Gillis’ beer-breathed Oakland superfan. Virginia’s dialogue is frequently head-scratching, commenting on obvious story beats like John handing his legendary playbook to Trip: “Ah, I remember that book!” Of course you do! You spent multiple talking-head scenes holding it like your baby in a movie that’s absolutely not a mockumentary. It’s just one more indication that Russell’s vision is rudderless, steered in retrospect by atrocious edits and unbalanced needledrop fades.

And still, Madden lucks into a few entertaining sequences. Mulaney’s laughable nerd-does-football schtick fits the comedian’s wheelhouse, especially with two popular NFL veterans “disguised” as his codemonkeys. Bale is a fantastic Al Davis, with Joel Murray’s Pat Summerall is close behind. And when Cage embraces John’s marker usage in the booth and starts philosophizing about seagulls or mentions barbecuing on a player’s bald head, you can see why the actor was cast. As an unfocused sports-media curio, complete with turducken explainers, jokes about Mark Davis’ haircut, and an old-school depiction of athletes chain-smoking and drunk-driving in the ’70s, there’s almost something here, left to languish by Russell.

Instead, Madden is laughable for all the wrong reasons. Whatever pleasure you might get from treating Madden as a so-goofy-it’s-good experiment has a low ceiling because it is bafflingly badly made. Just wait until YouTubers add their favorite scenes to their “Nicolas Cage losing his mind” compilations—that’ll be the best way to digest this 20-yards-too-short Hail Mary.

Director: David O. Russell
Writers: Cambron Clark, David O. Russell
Starring: Nicolas Cage, Christian Bale, Kathryn Hahn, John Mulaney, Sienna Miller, Shane Gillis
Release Date: November 18, 2026 (Prime Video)

 
Join the discussion...
Keep scrolling for more great stories.