B

A new love interest scatters Reggie Dinkins' world to some amusingly silly places

Boris Kodjoe makes Reggie jealous, Arthur greedy for drama, and Rusty question his sexuality.

A new love interest scatters Reggie Dinkins' world to some amusingly silly places

One of the chief reasons The Fall And Rise Of Reggie Dinkins got picked up, apart from its Tina Fey laugh factory pedigree, was undoubtedly the odd couple pairing of Tracy Morgan and Daniel Radcliffe. As borne out by their every promo appearance for the show, the two actors’ mismatched vibes and obvious affection for each other mirror Reggie and Arthur’s dynamic with hardly a funhouse bend necessary. The clipped, diminutive British former child star and the singular Black American wild card make a truly terrific comedy team, Arthur and Reggie’s symbiotic neediness overcoming their cultural mismatch (and the inevitably shaky mercenary foundation of their relationship).

“Hulk Want Candy” doesn’t quite come together, but the Reggie-Arthur dynamic at its core reinforces how these two very different performers taste improbably great together. The inciting sitcom development here is Monica’s new love interest Leslie Pervis, a former prodigy/nerd Rutgers classmate of Reggie and Monica’s who’s grown up to be not just a novelty snack food mogul but also The Last Man On Earth‘s Boris Kodjoe in the impossibly dapper and elegant flesh. There’s a delirious whiplash in watching the comic baton pass from Tracy Morgan to Daniel Radcliffe to Boris Kodjoe throughout the episode, where the very fact that three such different temperaments and body types are occupying the same reality feels like part of the joke. 

A jealousy subplot is hardly unique, but Reggie Dinkins (and Reggie Dinkins) so exists on Tracy Morgan’s stripped-bare emotional level that the predictable plot is oddly fascinating in practice. Reggie, like literally every member of the house, is immediately thrilled when Monica hesitantly gathers them to explain that she’s met someone. When Reggie joins the congratulatory chorus by shouting, “Good for you!,” there’s unquestioned joy and goodwill in it. There’s plenty to be explored about why Reggie and Monica’s relationship didn’t work out, but the show refreshingly never suggests the two childhood ride-or-dies stopped loving each other. So the turn (or “twist” as the eternally pretentious Arthur hilariously lectures us through his camera) of Reggie deciding that there’s something wrong with the seemingly perfect LP (as he prefers, over Reggie’s college nickname for him, Les Perv) is a little jarring. 

Tracy Morgan, Boris Kodjoe, Erika Alexander

With the skeptical Arthur finally agreeing that LP is not who he says he is due to his keen director’s eye (young Les Perv and adult LP write with opposite hands), the Reggie and Arthur show is on. Radcliffe and Morgan are never funnier than when their characters’ obsessions mesh, and even if their motivations aren’t completely aligned (Reggie is equal parts jealous, defensive, and protective, while Arthur spots another juicy opportunity for award-worthy drama), the way Arthur and Reggie’s eyes gleam with the same sort of loopy eagerness is deeply infectious stuff. Monica, naturally, is unswayed, brushing off the duo’s tandem attempt to warn her about LP with understandable brusqueness. (Arthur’s “Monica, if it helps, I agree with Reggie,” elicits Monica’s firm, “It doesn’t!”) 

The Fall And Rise Of Reggie Dinkins is invariably going to follow its title’s upward trajectory. Reggie is going to find, if not the Hall of Fame, at least a more complete understanding of his own faults and blessings. Arthur’s going to ultimately pick friendship over the lucrative comeback trail. Monica will forge a life finally separate from her former husband’s career. It’s a resolutely aspirational yet cozy tone that smooths over some lurking narrative pitfalls. Arthur and Reggie do the old, “You know what this means, don’t you?” speak-at-once gag partway through the episode, and if Reggie’s “Monica’s dating a murderer!” clashes with Arthur’s “I’m gonna win an award!,” they’re both united by their chaos-eyed neediness. (Morgan and Radcliffe do a doorway lean-out in response to LP’s oddly menacing advice to Brina that only Shaggy and Scooby could match.) 

Brina needs advice because she’s found out that the text she got from Young Thug was not to sing a killer hook on his new track but to be a mere “video girl” in his new video (alongside Chloe Troast’s returning frenemy diva Jynnysyz.) As subplots go, this is abrupt, and not all that necessary. But Precious Way continues to imbue Brina with more facets than her role as pretty young fiancée/aspiring influencer suggests. The show has worked to fashion Brina’s love for her rich older man as both genuine and mutually beneficial, and her humiliation here allows Way to make Brina’s dreams feel worth investing in. (If her affronted, “I got my hair done, my nails did, and my brows done-did,” sounds like white writers goofing on urban speech, Way makes the real feeling behind the lines authentically funny.) 

I’m puzzled at how the show uses Jason Mantzoukas’ serenely agreeable mega-producer Peter Za—if you hire ‘Zouks and don’t unleash his manic brilliance on an unsuspecting comedy landscape, it seems like a missed opportunity. (Still, his Zen approach to dealing with his eccentric music clients seems like it’d be pretty effective, as he explains to the flustered Brina that it just doesn’t matter if Young Thug’s message that he’s “in Paris” means he’s in France, in Texas, having sex with a woman named Paris, or just lying.)

Precious Way, Chloe Troast

The three resolutions that end “Hulk Want Candy” fail to properly cohere in the way Reggie Dinkins craftily often manages. Arthur and Reggie “follow the money” to a Pennsylvania pig farm, where their certainty that LP is actually his dead, ne’er-do-well twin pulling a life swap unravels rather anticlimactically. Kodjoe plays the very much alive twin, who’s been in witness protection ever since LP convinced him to testify against his crime bosses, the “Garbanzo Brothers,” thus allowing Monica and the seemingly as-good-as-he-seems LP to keep dating. Brina commandeers Young Thug’s abandoned video set to film her own amusingly promising track with Jynnysyz. And Rusty, in the episode’s one actual, Arthur-defined twist, turns out to have been subtly encouraging everyone’s growth throughout the episode so he and Reggie can have the run of the mansion to themselves. Bobby Moynihan’s Usual Suspects-style flashbacks to all his sneaky moves collapse into terror once he realizes they might actually be effective.”Oh God, I don’t want them to leave,” Rusty cries to Arthur’s cameras, “I love them all so much!”

And that’s the heart of Reggie Dinkins. For all the crossed purposes and conflicting motivations and inspired shenanigans, everybody involved just wants everybody around them not to leave. Reggie can beam in unalloyed happiness at Monica’s chance for love while letting his fear of abandonment lead him to a secret pig farm out of state. Arthur’s self-defining quest to return to Oscar glory and artistic esteem is imperilled most by the fact that he’s found the most unlikely and welcoming of chosen families. Even Rusty can want all the cake to himself but realizes in a panic that cake’s no fun without people you love sharing it. (Yes, Reggie’s the cake in that metaphor, and if you know Rusty, it makes sense.) 

When Reggie, confronted by a momentarily angry LP (over that whole “accidentally forcing his brother to flee from the Mob” thing), almost immediately crumbles into tearful confessions about losing everybody he loves, it is—in signature Tracy Morgan fashion—as ridiculous as it is funny, and affecting. This New Jersey mansion full of weirdos is an environment it’s tough to leave, even if narrative and creative necessity demands it. Similarly, we might wish that The Fall And Rise Of Reggie Dinkins invested a bit more in its characters’ growth (and looming conflicts), even though it’s so fun just to hang out and watch.

Stray observations

• Jalyn Hall keeps getting sixth-banana status on the show, even if the bright Carmelo’s contradictions remain fresh and amusing. I love his reversion to calling Monica “mommy” when confronting the idea of Monica dating again. After all, as he explains, “second base changes a man.”

• It doesn’t help when Monica pauses in an aside to her son in her dating reveal: ” As you know, I’ve been putting myself back out there. Shaking what my momma—your nana—gave me.”

• As with most Fey-verse shows, absurdity leaks through the cracks of Reggie Dinkins‘ reality like laughing gas. LP has invested in “a real Jurassic Park” and culls invasive monkeys at his Wyoming ranch thanks to global warming. Brina raps about the fact that a raven keeps bringing her jewelry. Young Thug has a “personal anti-robot Iron Man suit” (codename P.A.R.I.S.). LP is the one who actually owns that one-of-a-kind Wu-Tang album (on which they predicted COVID-19). Japan has cherry blossom and eel flavored Uncrustables, which Monica has to keep in water so the eels don’t die. The too-perfect LP was “Jet Pack Ken” in Barbie because he once saved Greta Gerwig’s life.

• Peter Za’s reaction to Arthur’s film crew: “Are these your cameras or ours? Actually it makes no difference. We live in a surveillance state.”

• “He was looking at life! And I ain’t talking about that Martin Lawrence movie. But that was a movie about life in prison. Which is what I’m talking about!”

• Reggie, after Arthur says that LP and his brother grew up in the bad part of Atlantic City: “There’s a worse part?!”

• Reggie is just about to explain the real reason he’s upset about Monica dating before Arthur shushes him. Personal growth is nice, but there are shenanigans afoot. 

• Monica deserves a nice guy in her life. We’ve already seen a flirtatious guy drop dead in front of her, and tonight she confesses to having dated one guy way too into Fight Club and another who called sex “breeding.” 

• Arthur and Rusty both muse that the impossibly attractive LP might have awakened something in them. I get it, even if Rusty assures Arthur’s cameras, “Oh, by the way, I tried a thing earlier and I’m not bi-.”

 
Join the discussion...
Keep scrolling for more great stories.