C+

There's not enough time to get on a first-name basis with Steve

Cillian Murphy follows Oppenheimer with a similarly weary, dissimilarly forgettable snapshot of an alternative school in crisis.

There's not enough time to get on a first-name basis with Steve

Everyone knows the old yarn about bad movies always being too long and good movies never being long enough, but that leaves out the hazy middle ground, where subpar movies either tease the possibility of getting much better or much worse depending on the moment. Films like Steve awaken the mental remote control in their audience, where viewers yearn to slow down the time they spend with the charismatic lead and fast-forward through the already shorthanded drama. The snapshot of a put-upon alternative school headmaster suffers because it has been so obviously arranged and composed as one. Rather than capturing the elegant whole of a complex world in a brief moment, Steve is a generic abbreviation—just like its title.

The worst part (of the film, not its instantly forgettable name), is that Steve is truncating a range of compelling performances, led by Cillian Murphy as the bone-weary leader trying to wrangle young charges on their third societal strike. Murphy, through his production company Big Things Films, is the obvious and passionate architect of this project: The actor previously starred in director Tim Mielants’ Small Things Like These and led the stage adaptation of writer Max Porter’s Grief Is The Thing With Feathers. Now, assembled in the wake of Murphy’s Oscar-winning turn as the exhausted and dissociating Oppenheimer, Porter swaps his own novella’s youthful point of view for that of Murphy’s exhausted and dissociating lead, whom Mielants sets in the center of a frantic drama.

As the rowdy teen boys and leering local news crew attempting to profile them swirl around Steve in the halls of Stanton Wood Manor, the trajectory of the film clarifies with the bluntness of the kids’ profanity. Things are falling apart here, within and without. Set in 1996, seemingly only to justify the bulky cameras hauled around by the exploitative documentarians and the hard drum ‘n’ bass blasting over young Shy’s (Jay Lycurgo) headphones, Steve could be happening at any time, as long as that time felt like the end. Kids on their last chance, teachers on their last buck, a community on its last nerve. But because Porter’s book Shy has become the movie Steve, this miniature apocalypse takes place in the harried professional life of a middle-aged man rather than in the depressed mindscape of a troubled teen—the latter now just one more element crumbling on the fringes.

That’s not necessarily a damning problem, because Murphy is completely magnetic as Steve. A little slumped and frazzled, his big heart not well disguised under a sarcasm that meets the kids where they’re at, Murphy convincingly elevates the hoary trope of the cool teacher. He wanders the halls (and offices, basements, laundry facilities, and classrooms) of the school, pinballing off of the lightly sketched ensemble around him, his personal demons and the institutional shortcomings of a facility held together with string and chewing gum competing for time during the film’s truncated office hours. Though Steve is a capable conduit for the myriad familiar dramas of juvenile delinquent storytelling, there’s just not enough time in the day (or the film’s wishy-washy 24-hours-in-hell structure) to give anything the attention it deserves.

That this reflects one of the main challenges for Stanton Wood’s insufficient staff is more of a disappointing irony than a fitting resonance. Similarly straddling the line between appropriate and ill-conceived is the film’s mess of visual styles. That camera crew collects expository confessional interviews from staff and students alike, but they’re interspersed between handheld tracking shots that have nothing to do with the news team. Add in more traditionally framed moments and one ridiculous scene of go-for-broke stylization, and Steve‘s frantic, cluttered aesthetic is just as spread-thin as the story it wishes to tell.

Steve strains to connect the deteriorating mindsets of its headmaster and one student in the crowd. There just aren’t enough hours in the day to suitably capture Steve’s brief encounters with a supporting cast that includes his deputy Amanda (Tracey Ullman), school counselor Jenny (Emily Watson), and countless charming yet shortchanged kids. The small moments each are given have the desperation of a TV pilot going down a checklist. Gotta set these characters up for something! But they fade from the frame as the film returns to Steve’s close-up suffering, or (less frequently) Shy’s close-up suffering. And then the credits roll, and the limits of its 90-minute runtime and its split attention set in. Only partially disguised by the showboating and the surface-level chaos, Steve always returns to its Murphy-centric norm: A character study that didn’t study at all, but instead tries to cram everything in an hour before the exam.

Director: Tim Mielants
Writer: Max Porter
Starring: Cillian Murphy, Tracey Ullman, Jay Lycurgo, Simbi Ajikawo, Emily Watson
Release Date: September 19, 2025; October 3, 2025 (Netflix)

 
Join the discussion...