The Woman King found something radical not in its history, but in the history of its genre
Gina Prince-Bythewood's epic offered up an ensemble of Black women and old-fashioned earnestness for a totally original blockbuster.
Photo: Sony
With Women Of Action, Caroline Siede digs into the history of women-driven action movies to explore what these stories say about gender and how depictions of female action heroes have evolved over time.
Forget stunts and pyro, the hardest thing to pull off in an action move is earnestness. It’s a genre of quippy one-liners, sarcastic heroes, cynical plot twists, and questionable morals. The films that break that pattern stand out because they’re so few and far between. These are films like Ridley Scott’s Gladiator, Peter Jackson’s Lord Of The Rings trilogy, Joe Johnston’s Captain America: The First Avenger, and Gina Prince-Bythewood’s The Woman King—the 2022 historical epic that asked why Viola Davis couldn’t have Tom Cruise’s career.
That earnestness surprised a lot of critics, who were expecting a more highbrow history lesson about the Agojie, a group of highly trained female warriors in the West African kingdom of Dahomey. But it was no surprise for those steeped in Prince-Bythewood’s work. The college-athlete-turned-director began her career bringing old-fashioned earnestness to romantic dramas like Love & Basketball and Beyond The Lights before expanding to the action genre with her sneakily great adaptation of The Old Guard. Prince-Bythewood’s specialty is putting Black women at the center of classic genres that haven’t always made space for them.
In a lot of ways, The Woman King is an example of why “representation matters”—a trite but true rallying cry of the 2010s. The Woman King actually first began as an idea from actor Maria Bello, of all people, who learned about the Agojie on a 2015 trip to Benin and thought it would make a great idea for a movie. She spent years pitching the project around Hollywood, occasionally getting offered a small $5 million budget by a studio, but mostly getting told that the idea was too unprofitable to work. Then the one-two punch of Patty Jenkins’ Wonder Woman in 2017 and Ryan Coogler’s blockbuster Black Panther in 2018 turned Hollywood’s calculus on its head. Suddenly the real-life story of the “Dahomey Amazons” who inspired Black Panther‘s Dora Milaje was a red-hot prospect. Sony TriStar greenlit the film with a $50 million budget. It opened to glowing reviews and went on to gross $97.6 million. “Representation matters” in the sense that the success of Black Panther literally got The Woman King made, and also in the sense that The Woman King gave an ensemble of Black women the spotlight in a way the action genre never really had before.
It’s worth acknowledging that the actual history in The Woman King is largely fictionalized. Though the film depicts the Agojie as purely heroic figures who fought to end Dahomey’s limited practice of slavery, in real-life Dahomey had a much bigger role in the Atlantic slave trade and the Agojie sometimes led raids to acquire those slaves. This was enough to spark a bit of controversy when the film was released—and to get original star Lupita Nyong’o to leave the project because she was uncomfortable with “the tribe’s legacy of violence.” (The Underground Railroad star Thuso Mbedu stepped into her role instead.)
But, to me at least, the historical simplification is on par with what I expect from a glossy Hollywood action epic. The Woman King is entertainment-first spectacle, with a message designed to speak more to our current moment than to accurately reflect the past. Even its relatively bloodless approach to PG-13 violence marks it as a movie not especially grounded in reality. Where it feels revolutionary is not how it engages with early 19th-century history, but how it engages with the history of the action genre.
Since women-led action movies first evolved from the rape-revenge genre in the 1970s, Hollywood has loved stories of women who experience a trauma that drives them to become badass avengers. From Kill Bill to Terminator 2 to Red Sonja to most of Pam Grier‘s early Blaxploitation films, it’s one of the most common story archetypes out there. What’s remarkable about The Woman King is how it manages to acknowledge the physical and sexual traumas that so many women experience without using it as motivation for its characters’ heroism—a subtle but meaningful storytelling shift.
When we meet Viola Davis’ General Nanisca, she’s a fearless warrior dedicated to liberating captives and pushing for King Ghezo (John Boyega) to end Dahomey’s ties to European exploitation. She’s also, as we’ll later learn, a woman who, early into her time with the Agojie was kidnapped, repeatedly raped, and bore a child she gave away. It’s an experience that haunts and shapes her, but not the sole thing that drives her, which is an important distinction. While Nanisca does wind up getting revenge on her rapist, her arc is about making internal peace with herself—about coming to realize she doesn’t have to lock away her memories of the past to have a future as a powerful leader.
It’s one of many places in which you can tell that The Woman King is a movie written, directed, and produced by women interested in the actual nuances of women’s lives, not just the action tropes they can fill. The 135-minute film tracks at least seven major interpersonal dynamics between its main female cast, on top of giving Nanisca and new recruit Nawi (Mbedu) male characters to interact with as well. It’s hard to think of any other action movie that does that; even something like Wonder Woman used its Amazons more as set dressing than as characters.