The Hunting Wives' May Cobb on her first sequel novel and favorite soapy thrillers

The author digs into a personal fascination with East Texas, and the cultural obsession with liars.

The Hunting Wives' May Cobb on her first sequel novel and favorite soapy thrillers

With Reading List, The A.V. Club asks one of our favorite pop-culture creators to describe a list of reading materials that are tied together by a singular theme.

Many people probably know the name May Cobb because of the popular Netflix series The Hunting Wives, a deliciously soapy drama about an East Coast transplant who gets drawn into a clique of wealthy Texas women and a murder investigation. The show is based on Cobb’s second novel, which hit shelves in 2021. Since then, she’s written five more books and firmly established herself as a must-read author of female-focused domestic thrillers. Her seventh novel, All The Little Secrets, debuted this week, a sequel to her earlier 2026 release, All The Little Houses, and continues the first’s story of murder, infidelity, and sharp social sniping. 

The A.V. Club sat down with Cobb to talk about her just-released new novel, writing her first sequel, and some of her favorite soapy thrillers. 


The A.V. Club: Tell our readers a little bit about All The Little Secrets, which is a first for you—it’s a sequel.

May Cobb: It is a duology, and All The Little Secrets is the second book in the series. All The Little Houses was the first, and the cliffhanger was a murder, and the plot engine of Secrets is: Is the guilty person going to get away with the murder? Is the innocent person going to go down for the murder? That’s the thrust of it. Layer in all the other East Texas wildness and banana daiquiris and margaritas and everything, it’s a lot. 

AVC: Was it strange doing a sequel or harder for you as a writer? Did the story just feel too big for one book? I didn’t know it was a duology when I read the first one, and I was shocked.

MC: Yeah, you and everybody else. [Laughs.] I feel like it should have come with a warning. But when I got to about the halfway point of writing All The Little Houses, I was like, “Oh Jesus, this is way too much for one book.” 

I knew at that point what the ending was going to be. So I did try to engineer it so that readers were left on a cliffhanger because, damn it, those books are inspired by 1980s nighttime soaps like Dynasty and Dallas. I wanted to have that “Who Shot J.R.?” vibe. And then, thank God, Sourcebooks, in their wisdom, decided to put the sequel out this year, so we’re not leaving readers hanging for too long to find out the answer to what happens.

AVC: Let’s talk about East Texas, because I think all of your books except for The Hollywood Assistant are set there. And I think people kind of have a better feel for what that vibe is now that they’ve seen The Hunting Wives and all that entails. But what is it about this location that just keeps you coming back to it as a storyteller?

MC: It’s really interesting, this place. And I feel like it’s a little bit of an underrepresented region of Texas. It’s in the northeast corner. It’s almost Louisiana. My hometown is 30 miles from the border of Louisiana, so it kind of feels like True Blood country. There’s a deep pine forest, and we do have some Spanish moss, and there’s a party, lots-of-drinking kind of vibe. Attica Locke and Joe Lansdale and Nick Wade have all portrayed it in this beautiful way, so I’m just trying to coast behind them in this kind of East Texas noir lane. 

It’s a creepy place. It’s very eerie, and it’s very isolated. It’s two hours east of Dallas, an hour west of Shreveport. So it really is tucked into, we call it, the Pine Curtain. Growing up there, it felt like a 1980s Stephen King novel in a lot of ways. Longview had an oil boom in the 1920s, so there is still a lot of enormous oil wealth. You have these old guard generational wealth type families, and then you have the rest of us milling around the town. And I would get invited to the rich girl slumber parties and stuff, and it was just really interesting. 

AVC: Now that this duology’s done, what are you working on next? I know there’s another TV show happening.

MC: Yes, it’s super exciting. All The Little Houses is at Apple, and I’m working with an incredible team. So that’s in the works and chugging along. And then I’m on deadline right now for my eighth book, which feels so weird to even say, but I’ll be handing that in soon. It’s a Dallas set soapy thriller, which, you know, is new territory for me. [Laughs.]

AVC: What do you think are the key ingredients for a really good soapy thriller? Obviously, everyone responds to them in different ways and for different reasons, but I think we all read them for certain similar elements. 

MC: I feel like having an ensemble cast is one of those ingredients. Twisty family dynamics are important. Definitely people having secrets and lying and backstabbing. A dead body is always terrific. I think sometimes, too, it’s fun to have an aspirational setting. It’s not always necessary, but I think I do sort of skew towards the rich people behaving badly.

AVC: We love “a rich people behaving badly” story. Let’s face it, we all watched Succession. 

MC: That’s true—and they were pretty awful! I think, on some level, we want to see them taken down a bit. 

Girls And Their Horses by Eliza Jane Brazier

AVC: All right, let’s get into your recommendations. And I have to say that I love that you brought notes. 

MC: I had to! So, my favorite, if I have to pick one favorite, is Eliza Jane Brazier’s Girls And Their Horses.

AVC: I love that book! I read a lot of The Saddle Club as a kid, and that one really does feel like a Saddle Club for grown-ups, just with a lot more adult behavior. 

MC: A thousand percent! I just love that it’s set in the cutthroat world of the horse world. Mean girls and their meaner moms. A rich enclave in Southern California. And Brazier, I find, just has this very strong grasp of black comedy. She has me just cackling in places with her lines. 

They’re so razor-sharp and skewering. And talk about skewering rich people! She’s the queen of it in my mind. I loved her complicated female characters. I love the setting. I love the mystery in it and the teens that felt so realistic. I felt like it delivered on all the levels.

AVC: Another thing I think is really unique about these sorts of books is that it’s not just rich people behaving badly, it’s often rich people in some sort of bizarre bubble. Horse people are such a unique circle, and it’s a group that can feel kind of alien and weird if you’re unfamiliar with it. There’s something really delicious about that. 

MC: Absolutely! It kind of transports you into something, a world that we don’t know much about. It’s extra exotic if you will. 

The War Of The Roses by Warren Adler

AVC: What’s your second pick?

MC: The OG. The War Of The Roses. And just go ahead and put me in the earth because I got to do a blurb for it when they re-released it with the latest movie. I’ve never been so honored.

AVC: That feels like a strong recommendation. What did your blurb say? 

MC: “One of the OG classics of domestic noir remains as sharp as a thorn and as deliciously dark as when it first arrived decades ago.”

AVC: So true!

MC: So that’s definitely number two for me: the Roses going at it and swinging from the chandelier and all the other antics they got up to. It’s so good. 

The Magnificent Ruins by Nayantara Roy 

MC: I am cheating a little with the third one. The Magnificent Ruins by Nayantara Roy. It’s technically not a true thriller. But it does have a body drop in it. So I’m putting it on this list because it reads propulsively like a thriller. And it’s got all the family soapiness that you could ever want.

So our main character, she’s an editor in New York, and she gets the call that the family patriarch back in Calcutta has passed away, and she is the one who inherits the estate. So she has to go back home and deal with all the family drama that surrounds an inheritance. It is just glittering, sumptuous, propulsive. I mean, it truly does read like a thriller, and it’s just so good.

AVC: I’m going to take your word for it, and I’m going to put it on my Goodreads right now.

MC: You’re going to love it! And I don’t. 

Perfect Wives, Perfect Lies: A Novel by Jennifer Anne Gordon

MC: This one is definitely a thriller, and technically I’m cheating a little again here because I haven’t read it yet, but it’s at the very top of my TBR pile, and I wanted to give it a shoutout. 

I don’t want to spoil anything about it, but the tagline is “A woman in mourning finds renewed purpose in her fake persona for an online mom group, but membership comes at a killer cost.”

AVC: I have to admit I love this new trend in publishing that’s all about people and their weird internet fixations. They’re scammers or trad wives or catfishing someone. 

MC: That’s a whole genre. And I can’t wait to read them all.

Party Of Liars And Pretty Dead Things by Kelsey Cox

AVC: Anything with “liars” in the title is almost always a huge win. 

MC: It is. It’s set in the Texas Hill Country; it’s got rich people, and it’s centered around a 16th birthday party that’s happening that turns into a  [locked room] murder mystery. 

AVC: Oh! Now I remember the name of the Kelsey Cox book I read: Pretty Dead Things!

MC: I read that just a month ago, and honestly it could also be a pick for this. So I’ll say both, maybe. The pageant world is so crazy. Pretty Dead Things, I couldn’t put it down. It’s so messy, and Kelsey so brilliantly gets in there and just really makes hay with it all. 

AVC: One of the things I think is really interesting in a lot of these books is the commentary on—and you see this a lot in The Hunting Wives for those who’ve watched the show—the complex relationships between the women in them. Because these kinds of stories usually are about women to some degree or another, and I wonder what it is about them that speaks to us as readers. 

MC: I love that question. I feel like for me, and maybe this is just [having experienced] middle school, I’m very attuned to and interested in complex female friendship dynamics and also family dynamics. But particularly female, because I feel like women, I don’t know, by design, I just feel like they’re more cutthroat in many ways, and there can be a level of manipulation that men don’t [engage in]. Their drama is their fantasy football team drama; it’s very different than what women can get up to. And there’s the social hierarchy and the getting on top, and it can get wild, especially in the South. 

But the thriller crime fiction genre is endlessly expansive, expanding into new worlds, new voices, new twists. And I’m constantly fascinated by how it continues to grow. And yeah, it’s one of those genres where, I don’t know, I think it’s going to live until the robots come and take it away from us.

This interview has been edited for length and clarity.

 
Join the discussion...
Keep scrolling for more great stories.