Mixed martial arts are the rage among those who
take pleasure in all things gladiatorial, but there's still some fight left in
pro wrestling. Total Nonstop Action has weathered its awkward early years as a
scrappy upstart league and made it to the big time, with weekly airings on
Spike TV. Now, following in the WWE's footsteps, TNA has unleashed the first of
what will likely be many videogames. TNA Impact! isn't likely to change the
mind of anyone who thinks pro wrestling feels like a throwback to the late
'90s. Sure, next-gen consoles allow for startlingly realistic recreations of
the brawling stars. Each fighter's signature style is recreated in fluid
animation based on motion-capture sessions, making every body slam and Irish
whip appear lifelike.
But the game beneath the gorgeous veneer is the
same one we've been playing for a decade. Players punch, kick, and grab their
opponents, eventually building up enough power to unleash a lethal special
attack. Granted, the game's brawling is polished: The wrestlers' moves feel
satisfying, especially when an incoming drop-kick or punch is successfully
countered. But in spite of tons of multiplayer options, rules variations, and
playable celebrities, TNA Impact! feels staid. Conservative, even. It's a shame to
squander such a colorful cast of characters on such an uninspired game.