Nicholas Brendon, so often the sober voice of reason on Buffy The Vampire Slayer, was arrested Friday after causing a drunken disturbance in Boise, Idaho, where he was attending the Tree City Comic Con. The 43-year-old, erstwhile Xander reportedly got into an argument with staff at the hotel where he was staying, prompting a police response. Officers say Brendon refused their commands to stay seated while they talked to witnesses and eventually tried to walk away, so they took him into custody for resisting arrest. Brendon also faces charges of “malicious injury to property” for reportedly breaking a “decorative dish.” (It’s unknown whether this is the dish in question, which may justify his actions.)