Home Alone director Chris Columbus put a nail through the foot of the Home Alone reboot/legacy sequel/thing minutes before finding out about it. Variety reportedly spoke to Columbus just before it reported on Macaulay Culkin’s return to the red sweater and told the outlet that a Home Alone sequel with Culkin and not Catherine O’Hara, who died earlier this year, wouldn’t work. “Catherine, as I’ve always said, is 50% of Home Alone,” Columbus says. “There’s the yin and yang of Home Alone: Catherine O’Hara and Macaulay Culkin. Without those two in the film, there is no film, because they create the emotional epicenter of that film.” He continues, “It was really about Catherine and Macaulay. If anyone ever wanted to do a sequel, unfortunately that can’t happen.”
Earlier today, news broke that Culkin had signed on to reprise cinema’s most famous abandoned child and home security expert in a new Home Alone movie, in which Kevin endangers his children for a change. The movie will reportedly be written and produced by Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg. The rest of the cast’s participation is still unknown. John Heard died in 2017, and Joe Pesci rarely acts for anyone other than Martin Scorsese and Pete Davidson, so that really leaves Daniel Stern, who was fired from an ABC sitcom by Home Alone rights holders Disney earlier this year. Without them, Columbus doesn’t hold out much hope for success. “I think you potentially could still entertain the idea of doing another Home Alone with the cast,” Columbus explains. “Not any of these ridiculous follow-ups to the first. And I only say ridiculous because it’s weird with filmmakers. They don’t understand why that cast works so well. It’s always about the cast. It’s like The Goonies. It’s about the cast.” Nevertheless, he did say he hoped to work with Culkin “on something” again. “Maybe it’ll be Home Alone-related, maybe it won’t.” It sounds like he’s saying he’d be willing to make the movie if asked, but also that it wouldn’t work because O’Hara is no longer with us. But this is also the man who’s making a new Gremlins without Joe Dante because he didn’t like what Dante did with Gremlins 2: The New Batch.