When Godfrey came into the A.V. Club studio, we knew we were in for a fun time. The comedian, actor, and all-around good dude kept us endlessly entertained with his thoughts about everything from his love of red velvet cake to his hatred of mayonnaise, even sticking around after the shoot for about an hour to talk about his fascination with evangelist preachers. He was a goddamn joy, and that’s something you’ll see reflected in the above video. Godfrey, you’re welcome back anytime.

Brought to you by Nature Valley

Late-Night Pantry Talk Show is sponsored by Nature Valley Granola Cups. You can learn more about them here.