Jennifer Jason Leigh is a boozy mess in this underrated ’90s drama

That family principally includes her sister, Georgia (an Oscar-nominated Mare Winningham), and Georgia’s husband, Jake (Ted Levine). In a welcome twist, the stable, rational, glasses-wearing Georgia is the through-the-roof folk celebrity, while the rough, punkish Sadie has to perform back-up vocals in random settings (bowling alleys, Jewish weddings) to support herself. (She often can’t even handle this second-tier work: Her gig at the wedding is cut short after a bathroom swig of NyQuil leaves her nauseous and unfocused.) Collectively, the bundle of accessories Sadie wears—bracelets, necklaces, rings, gobs of eyeliner—probably weighs as much as she does, and while this image might possess a bad-girl allure if Sadie were famous, watching her perform this role with Georgia and Jake as her only remaining audience is miserable. In a pair of early kitchen scenes, Georgia and Jake both use their time alone with Sadie to show her some comfort, but their concern and even bitterness toward her can’t help but seep through, whether through startlingly frank declarations (“You can’t feel what I’m feeling. You aren’t me,” says Georgia) or defensive body language.

Grosbard, who died in 2012, racked up some serious credentials as a theater director in his lifetime, but his movies have been perennially underrated. Given his background, it’s no surprise that one of his greatest traits is his sensitivity with actors—True Confessions and Falling In Love contain two of the softest performances Robert De Niro has ever given—and Georgia is no exception, with Leigh, Winningham, and Levine all sliding into their roles with complex compassion and unforced warmth. Leigh, working from a screenplay written by her mother (Barbara Turner), invests Sadie with constant, unrelenting fits of physical motion: When she’s not performing or frantically scurrying around a room, she’s curled up on the couch smoking a cigarette and fidgeting with a glass. Leigh’s turn climaxes with a desperate, quivering rendition of Van Morrison’s “Take Me Back”—her arms flying around, her hazel eyes succumbing to tears—that illustrates Sadie in one painful, unforgettable nutshell.

Availability: Georgia is available on DVD from Amazon or possibly your local video store/library. It is also currently streaming on Netflix and can be rented or purchased through the major digital services.