Nick Offerman is just trying to make television a nicer place with Making It
Making It host Nick Offerman: “I prefer to be on the side of life that is creating and blossoming rather than the side of life that is destroying or consuming”

For reality junkies missing the good-natured conviviality that shows like The Great British-Baking Show can offer, might we suggest Making It? The Nick Offerman and Amy Poehler produced and hosted crafting series is in its third season on NBC and routinely provides some of the summer’s most inspiring and heart-warming moments of human connection. Though it’s ostensibly a show for makers and creators, it’s also a show about friendship, potential, and—thanks to Offerman and Poehler—the truly transformative power of a good pun.
The third season of Making It kicked off last week with a surprise twist ending that (spoiler ahead if you haven’t seen it) found the show not only not eliminating a contestant but adding two more makers to the mix. We talked to Offerman about his dislike of “mean television,” which he calls “gross,” as well as why he thinks of himself as sort of a Hollywood shovel.
The A.V. Club: Making It has such a supportive, encouraging vibe. Why is that important to you? You even found a way to double down on that vibe this season, choosing not to eliminate anyone in episode one and instead adding two new contestants. How did that come about?
Nick Offerman: I don’t like mean television. I especially don’t like it when it involves real people, like reality shows that are designed to make people cry or cause them pain and we’re supposed to revel in that [as viewers]. It feels gross. I’d like to see that person get a hug right now. And so when Amy pitched [Making It] to me, it literally sounded like it was a show that would do just that. It would encourage people to make things with their own hands and sink or swim. The show would kind of throw their arms around the people and the audience and say, “Look at this amazing thing we humans can do. We can make it! There’s no there’s no limit to the things we can make with our imaginations and our creativity.”
Life is hard and it’s full of pitfalls, especially in the last couple of years. It’s gotten pretty bleak. To be able to say, “If you have a bunch of popsicle sticks and a hot glue gun and a ball of string, look at how much fun you can have. Look at how much mirth and affection you can you can shower upon yourself, but also those around you” and so forth and so on—I prefer to be on the side of life that is creating and blossoming rather than the side of life that is destroying or consuming.
As to the second part of your question, Amy [Poehler] and I, that’s been our strategy from the get-go. “How can we trick the network into letting us not eliminate anyone from this competition show?” That’s the ultimate goal. I hope we don’t rest until we succeed and are only adding a person every episode until the finale has like 20 contestants. Until we arrive at that, I think that we have failed.
We’ve definitely scored our first victory. So it’s NBC: two, Nick and Amy: one.
AVC: This is the third season of the show. How much pressure is there to innovate every season?