Oscars 2026: The good, the bad, and the ugly

Droughts ended, glass ceilings shattered, and sound engineers were asleep at the wheel at the 2026 Oscars.

Oscars 2026: The good, the bad, and the ugly

The 98th Academy Awards at least listened to one piece of feedback we had for last year’s ceremony, as the show brought back host Conan O’Brien to inject at least a little strangeness into the proceedings, especially with those bookends. That said, the production was nowhere near as entertaining as his first oddball show, with plenty of technical foibles and painful jokes getting in the way of the winners. But what a group of winners they were! 

One Battle After Another and Sinners went back and forth like the juggernauts they are, reminding us of how good we had it and how this last year felt a bit like a last hurrah for all things original that were getting traction at a pre-sale Warner Bros. This lovefest between the films, which counted 10 wins between them (WB boasted 11 wins total thanks to the movies and Weapons—tying the record for a single studio’s haul in a night.), not only got Paul Thomas Anderson and the first-ever woman cinematographer their Oscars, but bled over to Best Casting. This was a new category without a real precedent, which means its winner will presumably help define what the competitors will look like going forward. Actually, let’s hope more movies in general look like One Battle After Another in the future.

And, speaking of the future, let’s not ignore the prognosticating powers of your Film Editor, whose Oscar predictions were only matched by those of Weird Al Yankovic. If you missed the 2026 Oscars, here’s our breakdown of the best moments, the most garbled audio, and the boneheaded decisions that always color Hollywood’s main event.


The Good

An In Memoriam segment actually worthy of the year’s losses

This was a tough year in all corners, and the film world didn’t get off easy. With deaths including Robert Redford, Diane Keaton, Rob Reiner, Béla Tarr, Frederick Wiseman, Val Kilmer, Diane Ladd, Catherine O’Hara, Isiah Whitlock Jr., and Udo Kier, it felt like every week offered another blow to the foundation of living masters. Instead of rushing through them all in a slapdash montage, the Oscars slowed down and gave these giants the weight they deserved. A song from Barbra Streisand, a heartfelt remembrance from Billy Crystal (and many more), and Rachel McAdams’ loving tribute to the actresses we lost—this was worth taking a moment for, and was the classiest moment of the production. 

An extremely cool orchestral mash-up of the Best Score nominees

Why would you ever pipe in this exceptional music if you could’ve been doing this all along? Easily flowing between the different nominees as they were announced, this was one of the best introductions of the night, all because we actually got to hear some of the artistry at work. Endless respect to lead arranger Chris Walden, who proved how connected and fluid these soundscapes can be in the right hands, despite their disparate tones and genres.

A glass ceiling shattered

Autumn Durald Arkapaw, with her win for Sinners, became the first woman, and Black person, to ever win Best Cinematography. The long-standing stain on the Academy finally got scrubbed a little thanks to the DP’s evocative work defining the warm look of her film while also navigating the technical hurdles necessary to alternate between IMAX and Ultra Panavision 70 cameras. And her speech was worthy of the groundbreaking moment: Her call for all the women in the room to stand together was goosebump-inducing, and shone a spotlight on the industry’s continued solidarity and collaboration. 

Mr. Nobody stands tall

While both Documentary winners gave moving speeches, the Feature winner, Mr. Nobody Against Putin, allowed its director David Borenstein and its subject-cinematographer Pavel Talankin to draw connections between the Russian regime and that of our own—and the small acts of complicity that help ensure their continued power. Borenstein set Talankin up with aplomb, firing at censorial oligarchs and murderous governments as he made it very clear that his film isn’t just about Russia. When Talankin, the teacher who secretly filmed the movie as his school was forced to deploy propaganda in the classroom, got the mic, his message was simpler, and one echoed more specifically by Javier Bardem later in the show: no more war.

The Bad

The things we couldn’t hear

Why did the presenters all sound like they were in space? Why did they compress Matt Berry’s velvet pipes? Why were the playing-off cues so aggressive? The Academy is lucky the Sound nominees couldn’t hear the live broadcast or they’d have been leaping up to fix it like all of us when we have to turn the motion smoothing off of our parents’ television sets. That said, even the Sound winner got muted, so maybe they couldn’t have helped things.

The comedy we could hear

This year’s Oscars were plagued by some hellishly interminable bits (the stiff note-reading audience gag with the cast of Bridesmaids) and terrible banter from the presenters, including but not limited to The Pullmen (Bill and Lewis), who all seemed equally intoxicated by some kind of sinister sedative agent. This is what you were playing off winners to get to?

The Ugly

Ah, Disney

While the move to YouTube will certainly come along with its own host of problems, ABC’s Oscars have had a throughline of product placement and brand alignment unmatched in Academy history, and Grogu’s cameo (not to mention all that Avengers nonsense) reminded us all of the advertisements that we should really all be thinking about during Hollywood’s biggest night.

Saving “Golden” until late in the show

This is just speculation, but if you play the hit, Oscar-winning, fandom-frothing song from Kpop Demon Hunters early in the ceremony, kicking things off in style, maybe you could’ve actually reached some of the young people Conan joked about being unable to reach with his lingo-dumping gag. Maybe then they would’ve watched further on and gotten interested in some other cool movies. Alas, the performance got stuck deep in the ceremony, where no kid except those held hostage by their cinephile parents would ever find it. At least it’s easy to fire up Netflix for one more stream.

 
Join the discussion...
Keep scrolling for more great stories.