Members of the press were recently treated to precisely 28 minutes of footage from Rogue One: A Star Wars Story. Well, George Lucas has seen the full thing, and his reaction was apparently positive. Now, we’re only hearing Lucas’ take secondhand from the spin-off’s director Gareth Edwards, and, presumably, it’s in Edwards’ best interest that Lucas is on board with the film. After all, Lucas created the universe in which Rogue One takes place. That being said, Edwards likely wouldn’t want to risk pissing anyone off by saying Lucas enjoyed the adventures of Jyn Erso and company when he actually hated them.