September TV preview: Charles Dickens, Lizzie Borden, and a trip back to Hillman College

Plus, Reacher gets a spin-off, while Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson play themselves (sort of).

September TV preview: Charles Dickens, Lizzie Borden, and a trip back to Hillman College

Once upon a time not so very long ago, September marked the start of the new fall TV season, full of heavy-hitting premieres and big-name series returns. The rise of the streaming era means that the TV season is now eternal, but the arrival of fall does still herald a glut of programs new and old. Known properties are hot this month, with the arrival of Netflix’s A Different World sequel, Paramount+’s Martin spin-off The Varnell Hill Show, FX’s The Drop: A Snowfall Saga, and Prime Video’s Reacher follow-up Neagley. Elsewhere, new series see Ella Beatty playing Lizzie Borden for Ryan Murphy, Colin From Accounts’ star Patrick Brammall in an Apple TV+ crime thriller, and Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson as themselves.Here’s The A.V. Club‘s guide for what to watch on TV this September:

The Varnell Hill Show (Paramount+, September 1) 

Martin Lawrence and Tommy Davidson (Photo: Paramount+)

Everything old really is new again.  Almost 30 years after the end of Martin, Tommy Davidson returns to the series’ universe as WZUP DJ-turned-late-night host Varnell Hill. Martin Lawrence himself will make special appearances on the show, which sees Varnell trying to stay afloat amid the shifting tides and constant head winds of 21st-century media, a topic The A.V. Club would know nothing about… 

A Tale Of Two Cities (MGM+, September 6) 

The BBC’s fourth TV adaptation of Charles Dickens’ perennial bestseller finds the British broadcaster teaming with the cable channel formerly known as Epix. (Speaking of transformation.) Kit Harington, Mirren Mack, and Francois Civil make for an appealing love triangle at the center of Dickens’ saga of romance, sacrifice, transformation, and justice in the best of times and the worst of times 

The Drop: A Snowfall Saga (FX, September 8) 

 

Gail Bean and Isaiah John reprise their roles as fan-favorite Snowfall characters Wanda Bell and Leon Simmons, who are now attempting to reinvent themselves in 1990s Los Angeles. The rise of West Coast rap serves as the backdrop to The Drop’s complicated story about ambition, loyalty, survival, and the clash between street politics and hip-hop culture. 

Dang! (Netflix, September 8) 

 

Andrew Law and Matt Murray’s new adult animated series follows the adventures of a pair of misfit siblings in New York City whose lives are turned upside down when their high-achieving older sister arrives and wants to hang out with them. Complex relationship dynamics and sibling rivalry ensue. Law is also part of the voice cast alongside Everything Everywhere All At Once’s Stephanie Hsu and Hacks’ Poppy Liu.

Last Seen (Apple TV, September 9) 

September’s a big month for fans of the Australian rom-com Colin From Accounts: The show’s third season hits Paramount+ on the 10th; the day before, Apple TV subscribers can see Colin co-creator and co-star Patrick Brammall play a role that’s decidedly different from adorable brewpub owner Gordon. Based on Ryan David Jahn’s book The Dispatcher, Last Seen follows Brammall as a grieving former police investigator who receives a mysterious dispatch call from a disoriented young woman he believes could be his missing daughter Maggie, who was kidnapped over a decade ago. 

Neagley (Prime Video, September 16) 

In the world of Prime Video’s Reacher, Frances Neagley is Jack Reacher’s former military protégé and closest confidante. Now, the Chicago PI is getting the chance to tell her own story in the eight-part spin-off series Neagley, which sees her on the hunt for justice after a close friend from her past dies under suspicious circumstances. Yes, before anyone asks, our favorite big man Alan Ritchson is set to make guest appearances. 

Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story (Netflix, September 17)

The first female-led installment in Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan’s gory true-crime anthology series, Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story tackles a historical case that most of us only know via a nursery rhyme. But given that Dahmer, The Lyle And Erik Menendez Story, and The Ed Gein Story weren’t all that interested in historically accurate depictions of the killers at their centers, maybe that’s actually for the best. Ella Beatty stars as the infamous Lizzie, alongside Charlie Hunnam and Rebecca Hall, who play her doomed father and stepmother.

Line Of Fire (NBC, September 21) 

 

Peter Krause swaps the 9-1-1 firehouse for the White House in Line Of Fire, a family drama that’s partially inspired by executive producer Jenna Bush Hager’s real-life experiences of growing up around the U.S. Secret Service. The series follows the Hollingsworth family, who have spent their lives protecting other people—be they government officials or civillians—but may now be the ones in an assassin’s crosshairs. Hope Davis, Kat Cunning, Tommy O’Brien, Taylor Bloom, and Charlie Barnett also star.

Brothers (Apple TV, September 23) 

Woody Harrelson and Matthew McConaughey (Photo: Apple TV)

Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson play fictionalized versions of themselves in this intriguing but admittedly weird comedy from Apple that kind of reads like True Detective fanfiction—if there were less separating Rust and Marty from the actors who played them, and also if they were, like McConaughey and Harrelson, potentially related by blood. On the plus side, the duo’s chemistry is unstoppable, and no one should turn up their nose at a series that casts the always awesome Holland Taylor as McConaughey’s mom. 

A Different World (Netflix, September 24) 

 

Class is back in session at Hillman College for a whole new generation in A Different World, Netflix’s follow-up to the popular NBC sitcom whose own creative lineage we’re sure the streamer would prefer you not mention. Maleah Joi Moon stars as Deborah, the youngest child of the original series’ Whitley (Jasmine Guy) and Dwayne (Kadeem Hardison), who’s starting her freshman year of college at her parents’ alma mater and facing all the standard coming-of-age problems that go with it. Multiple legacy characters and familiar faces are taking part in the sequel, including Guy, Hardison, Darryl M. Bell, and Cree Summer. 

More September premieres

September 3

The Gentlemen season two (Netflix) 

Chad Powers season two (Hulu) 

September 9

The Paper season two (Peacock) 

September 10

Colin From Accounts season three (Paramount+) 

Crew Girl (Netflix) 

September 13

High Value Target: The Hunt For Saddam (TNT) 

September 15

Agatha Christie’s Tommy & Tuppence (BritBox) 

R.J. Decker season two (ABC)

September 16

Slow Horses season six (Apple TV)

South Park season 29 (Comedy Central) 

September 17

The Traitors: New Blood (NBC)

September 18

MobLand season two (Paramount+)

Outlander: Blood Of My Blood season two (Starz) 

September 22

Doc season two (Fox)

Best Medicine season two (Fox)

September 24

American Horror Story season 13 (FX)

September 25

S.W.A.T. Exiles (Starz) 

September 26

Saturday Night Live season 52 (NBC)

September 27

Animal Control season five (Fox)

Grimsburg season three (Fox)

The Simpsons season 38 (Fox)

Universal Basic Guys season three (Fox)

September 30

Scrubs season two (ABC)

 
Join the discussion...
Keep scrolling for more great stories.