B

Yellowjackets’ final season is pressed for time—but at least the premiere’s good

The final season gets off to a bloody start, with old grudges, new enemies, and one infuriating baseball cap.

Yellowjackets’ final season is pressed for time—but at least the premiere’s good

“Previously on Yellowjackets” is less a recap than a reminder of just how many murders, mutilations, and acts of cannibalism this show has normalized. It’s all a whirl of child deaths, adult knife fights, and the demise of Coach Ben, which remains the grimmest thing this brutal show ever concocted. There’s Shauna going full nightmare fuel during the hunt for Mari, Natalie scaling a snowy peak to save her fellow survivors, and Hilary Swank appearing in a backwards cap in the hope we’ll believe she’s a teenage Melissa grown up. The latter remains Yellowjackets‘ greatest demand on our suspension of disbelief.

But first, our dear, sweet himbo Jeff, swoop-haired and getting stoned on a plaid sofa outside a suburban furniture warehouse, is being prototypical 1998 in 1998. It’s been 19 months since the disappearance of his high-school sweetheart and pregnant side piece, so he’s understandably moved on. Unfortunately, before he can secure a date with a hot customer, a nearby wall of televisions delivers some inconvenient news. The Yellowjackets have been found.

This raises pressing questions about the timeline. We know Nat, Shauna, Van, Lottie, Tai, Misty, and Travis survive, but when Natalie contacts rescue, there are considerably more people still breathing. The inclusion of “last one standing” in the recap montage will encourage the Reddit theory that, Highlander-style, there can be only one. What in the fast-paced bloodbath are we about to witness during rescue week? Forensic science wasn’t quite what it is today in 1998, but surely the authorities will have questions about the litany of fresh corpses. Even poor Coach Ben can only have been dead a week or so.

In the present, Melissa has considerably more immediate problems, chief among them being that she’s played by Hilary Swank. An actress of considerable pedigree, Swank has arrived in Yellowjackets with all the congruity of a surprise cameo on SNL, her performance seemingly consisting of wearing a backwards cap regardless of the weather. She begins by explaining her murderous past to her wife, raising the question of what exactly this long-married couple have been discussing all these years. You can practically hear the writers’ room giving up on deciding what these two might reasonably know about one another. Are we seriously expected to believe that “the Yellowjackets were in the Rockies with my mom when she was researching frogs just before she died” never came up over dinner?

Her wife is understandably unimpressed, although not enough to wisely flee the cheap motel, leaving a Kool-Aid Man-shaped hole in the wall. Introduced at the 11th hour and retroactively woven into the show’s mythology, Melissa feels less like a long-lost Yellowjacket than an act of desperation. It’s particularly galling when the series has spent years carefully establishing its survivors, only to plonk a conspicuous Hollywood star into their midst and expect wardrobe to compensate for three seasons of character development.

Elsewhere, Taissa and Misty are dealing with the aftermath of Van’s death. Her terminal cancer diagnosis has conveniently precluded an investigation or autopsy, leaving Tai in possession of her remains. Misty, meanwhile, reveals that her million-dollar business ideas include “Uber for bathrooms” and trousers with refrigerated pockets for chocolate bars. If Christina Ricci’s delightful sociopath doesn’t survive until the finale, I will personally march upon Paramount+.

Ricci’s demonic doll of a character is also imagining violent solutions involving Shauna, Jeff, or both. Whether these are serious plans or simply how Misty habitually approaches problem-solving is unclear. The latter would certainly explain why she’s so good in a crisis. One can only hope her twin flame Walter returns soon enough to appreciate her ingenuity.

Back in 1998, a quick scan of the survivors’ hospital room offers a pointed glimpse of Akilah, whose fate I’d somehow convinced myself was already sealed. If this is creative retconning, it’s welcome, given how compelling the character became last season. Her presence also adds another name to the increasingly complicated arithmetic of who gets rescued and who doesn’t.

The girls are handed their first “real food”, plastic-wrapped sandwiches that predictably provoke memories of cannibalism. It’s a slightly heavy-handed bit of narrative shorthand, but the reunion with their families is far more affecting. Yellowjackets, always quick to snatch devastation from the jaws of joy, interrupts the celebrations with Natalie’s realization that nobody has come to collect her.

Sophie Thatcher, arguably the show’s biggest breakout star, communicates the enormity of this rejection by taking a long drag on a cigarette, coughing violently and immediately taking another. It’s a beautifully economical piece of acting, conveying the self-destructive impulses that will define her adult life. After 19 months of surviving against impossible odds, Nat’s first instinct upon returning to civilization is to poison herself with whatever toxic substance is available.

Shauna’s trauma manifests differently. In the hospital she refuses to acknowledge to her doctor that she’s given birth, burying her grief beneath rage. In the present she’s threatening a private investigator who has failed to locate Melissa and, to Jeff’s considerable dismay, has Mean Girls-ed all his shirts. This is the moment Shauna may become irredeemable. Has this sweet, dumb man, whose own criminal enterprises look positively wholesome alongside his wife’s, not suffered enough?

One of the great strengths of Yellowjackets is how its timelines allow us to witness the same psychological damage at different stages of development. The teenage survivors are only beginning to discover how impossible it will be to return to their former lives, while their adult counterparts have spent decades demonstrating precisely how poorly that experiment went.

This makes Lottie’s scenes particularly uncomfortable. Knowing what awaits her—brutal psychiatric treatments, failed cult leadership, and a spectacularly underwhelming death—makes it difficult not to wish her a better future. Courtney Eaton has been so consistently brilliant in the role that the knowledge of how little dignity lies ahead feels particularly cruel.

In the present, Taissa’s ill-advised shrine and spooky prayer suggest that Van’s death has done nothing to loosen the wilderness’ grip. It’s brief but deeply ominous, particularly given how thoroughly Tai has spent her adult life attempting to reconcile her respectable public identity with the considerably less respectable activities of her other self.

Meanwhile, Melissa has moved in next door to Shauna, which, given that this is a woman who married her murder victim’s daughter, represents roughly the level of sophisticated forward planning we’ve come to expect from her. Whether it’s the incongruity of Swank’s celebrity or the clumsiness with which Melissa has been inserted into an already crowded mythology, every appearance feels like an interruption from a different, considerably worse, television program.

Far more satisfying is the episode’s final jolt, courtesy of Sophie Nélisse, whose simple, “What the fuck?” is a shot of adrenaline straight to the heart.

The question hanging over this premiere is one of pacing. Originally conceived as a five-season story, Yellowjackets now has just 10 episodes to resolve its sprawling mythology, competing timelines and ever-expanding body count. That’s a formidable challenge, particularly with a fandom as detail-oriented, bloodthirsty, and spectacularly unforgiving as this show’s.

Yellowjackets is at its finest when it has the unrelenting, methodical momentum and lightly chaotic edge of its first season. This premiere is a promising return to form, not lingering on the inconsequential while finding room for genuine tenderness and the occasional Jeff-related punchline. How everything will be resolved remains anybody’s guess. And while Hilary Swank is like water for the chocolate that was Juliette Lewis, there’s enough here to inspire faith that, after four seasons of spectacular turbulence, Yellowjackets might just land the hell out of this plane.

Stray observations

  • • Hello everyone! I’m Leila Latif and I am thrilled to be recapping Yellowjackets’ final season. Those of you with long memories may recall that I covered season one too. Many thanks to the wonderful Jen Lennon for enduring the highs and lows of season three, that was truly some brilliant writing on some questionable plot developments.
  • • RIP Van I will never forgive or forget.

 
Join the discussion...
Keep scrolling for more great stories.