An American Tail captured something universal about the immigration experience

40 years ago, the family-friendly animation depicted the somber realities of moving to a new country.

An American Tail captured something universal about the immigration experience

Ahead of Thanksgiving week in 1986, an original animated movie opened in theaters alongside the latest Star Trek sequel and a Disney re-release of Song Of The South. An American Tail may have starred talking mice, but the story it told was vastly different from any Mickey Mouse adventures or that summer’s earlier mystery, The Great Mouse Detective. It was a dark and gripping account about how many immigrants came to call the United States home, following a family of cute, talking mice as they fled persecution and made the treacherous journey overseas to New York City, where they found the cat-free promises of “streets paved with cheese” had been greatly exaggerated. It was grim, it was gritty, but at its core, the movie was a heartwarming tale about a foreign family finding community in a new world. 

An American Tail is something like a kid-friendly answer to Martin Scorsese’s Gangs Of New York or James Gray’s The Immigrant. Set in the late 1800s, the story opens on the Mousekewitz family, living underfoot in Russia until their peace is disturbed by antisemitic pogroms. They flee for their lives, following the dream of a safer home for their family to the United States. During a storm on the ship, Fievel Mouskewitz (Phillip Glasser) is separated from the group and must make his way back to his family, who thinks he’s gone for good. Once the remaining Mousekewitzes make it to port, their new home in New York leaves much to be desired. It’s dirty, it’s cramped, and it’s plagued with cats and swindlers making a meal out of the unsuspecting newcomers. In short, it was not the American Dream they sang about. But it is theirs now, and Fievel gets involved with his fellow mice to figure out how to protect their new home. 

Steven Spielberg, who executive produced the project, drew inspiration from his grandfather’s experience, even giving the main mouse his grandfather’s Yiddish name, Fievel. Spielberg commissioned former Disney animator Don Bluth to make the film, and Bluth brought the moody palettes and somber themes of his earlier feature, The Secret Of NIMH, to late 19th-century NYC. Bluth’s vision of the past is not a romantic one, and while yes, moments in An American Tail may be cheesy, it certainly isn’t soft. Tragedy is a real possibility in this world. The mice may be cute and amusing, but their parallel world to humans bears many uncomfortable resemblances, like discrimination and poverty. 

Bluth and his team paid copious attention to the historical period, featuring the most-represented immigrant groups at the time—Jewish, Irish, and Italian newcomers—and including corrupt politicians that could fit in with the Tammany Hall crowd, an awareness of uptown-versus-downtown class dynamics, and the efforts of labor organizers to combat dangerous working conditions in response to incidents like the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire. 

As a kid, most of that historical and religious context flew over my head, but it gave me the understanding that this was no ordinary adventure movie. An American Tail is like few other animated features in the way it features an immigrant family’s story. Like Spielberg (and this is one of the very few times I can say that), I too grew up hearing stories of my family’s journey to the United States, their dramatic escape, and the shocking realization that America wasn’t the safe haven they thought it would be. To watch An American Tail is to get a sense of what that experience might have been like for my family, leaving under the cover of night to some unknown destination, getting thrown around on a boat until they docked (thankfully, no children were tossed overboard), and struggling to fit in a world quite different from the one they knew before. Spielberg and Bluth depicted Fievel’s sense of displacement in a blistering way rarely seen in other kids’ movies, but one that felt real while maintaining its optimism: Eventually, Fievel finds new friends in the neighborhood who help welcome him to his new home. 

Forty years after its box office success with holiday audiences, An American Tail has taken on a new poignancy. In the era of deadly ICE raids and deportations without due process, revisiting a film that celebrates the immigrant experience now tastes bittersweet. Immigrants are the heroes in An American Tail, the way Superman is, because they add to the new communities they come to call home. Their differences are key to their strength, not a weakness. They bring new ideas and help others, they make the community safer, and move towards a kinder and more just society. 

Compared to the shifting rhetoric about immigrants and the spike in antisemitism over the past decade, An American Tail now sadly seems like it came from a much more progressive era. By making Fievel the hero, showing his family’s realistic struggle, and the harsh details of coming to the U.S., Spielberg and Bluth show the immigrant experience in a sympathetic light, one many people today refuse to shine on their fellow human beings (perhaps because they’re not cute anthropomorphized mice). In making a story rooted in Spielberg’s family history, Bluth found universal truths about the fear and uncertainty of immigration, displacement, and refugee crises—one whose message is just as important today as it was in 1986.

 
Join the discussion...
Keep scrolling for more great stories.