After a couple years away, America’s favorite fake-psychic investigative duo is back in the form of Psych: The Movie, and early reviews indicate Gus and Shawn’s on-screen chemistry is as palpable as ever. But what about their off-screen chemistry? We quizzed stars James Roday and Dulé Hill with a game we call “How Well Do You Know Your Psych Co-Star?” to see if they’re as inseparable off screen as they are on it.