The best movies of 2006

Our retrospective includes auteurs aplenty, a high school noir, and the final film from David Lynch.

The best movies of 2006

Over the mid-decade hump, 2006 offered audiences a cinema whose superheroes were winding down, not ramping up; where digital was growing in dominance; where the uneasy balance between auteurs making interesting films and a box office topped by a live-action theme park ride wasn’t yet completely lopsided. Yet the polarizing shifts were in motion. The juggernauts were getting bigger (Disney bought Pixar) while the indies were getting smaller (mumblecore movies became a fixture at SXSW). Daniel Craig introduced his gritty James Bond and filmmakers decided that enough time had passed to make movies about 9/11. Returning to this tumultuous time in film, The A.V. Club once again looks back 20 years (check out our lists for 2004 and 2005), to find a country processing darkness and leaning into escapism.

This wasn’t just a year when Martin Scorsese’s vicious take on Infernal Affairs finally won him a Best Director Oscar, or a year when Clint Eastwood processed war trauma through a perspective-bending double feature, or a year where both Guillermo del Toro and Alfonso Cuarón pushed their larger anxieties through a genre filter. It was a year when troubled audiences found comfort through the confrontational silliness of Borat, the normcore conspiracy theories of The Da Vinci Code, and the newly solidified “torture porn” subgenre of Hostel and a new Saw. (And a new Jackass, which is exactly in between Saw and Borat.)

Tellingly, the year’s most successful documentary was a feature-length warning. An Inconvenient Truth defined Al Gore’s place in history and struggled to adjust the world’s perception of climate change. It also stood out as the more palatable option among a slate filled with stories of America’s occupation of Iraq. 

Yet, even this prickly atmosphere still allowed room for consistently interesting filmmakers like Sofia Coppola, Christopher Nolan, Spike Lee, Kelly Reichardt, David Lynch, Michael Mann, and Pedro Almodóvar. Rian Johnson made his directorial debut with Brick, the Romanian New Wave hit America with its stiff combination of sadness and black humor, and Will Ferrell had the best year of his career with both Talladega Nights and Stranger Than Fiction. There was a lot to choose from among the movies of 2006, though it would still be a year before DVD-by-mail company Netflix further shook up the options for cinephiles when launching its streaming service.

To keep the selection consistent, we followed our typical parameters when compiling this list, limiting ourselves to films released in America sometime over the year in question. (Or, in one case, a film that was released abroad but never made it to U.S. theaters.) This means that a few holdovers from the prior years’ festival circuits (like Sundance hit Brick) were deemed eligible—as were some that premiered earlier in their home countries but eventually screened stateside in 2006—while others, like Palme d’Or winner The Wind That Shakes The Barley, were disqualified because they didn’t escape from fests until 2007. The list below reflects the current taste of our voting contributors, and would probably be different if you asked us about it next year.


25. The Death Of Mr. Lazarescu

The breakout feature film from director Cristi Puiu, who’d kicked off the Romanian New Wave with his debut Stuff And Dough in 2001, was also the last feature that Radu Jude (the modern face of that movement) would work on as an assistant director. The Death Of Mr. Lazarescu goes off like an invigorating starting gun, even if the content of the film is, ironically, a slow Kafkaesque slide into bureaucratic hell. There’s just something electric about its handheld realism, its wry black-hearted comedy, and its relentless criticism of Romanian society—it’s like watching a language be invented in front of your eyes, one that perfectly fits the needs of its speakers. As retiree Dante Remus Lăzărescu (Ioan Fiscuteanu) dies over 153 minutes, going from a stomachache to full blown cognitive failure, he’s shuffled around from understaffed hospital to understaffed hospital, asked the same questions a million times, shown bursts of momentary humanity, and (far more often) is given relentless shit for his alcoholism. It’s agonizing and, at times, agonizingly funny—a fitting combination for Puiu’s epic condemnation. [Jacob Oller]

24. Hard Candy

It’s intriguing, to say the least, that Elliot Page’s breakout film was a pointed critique of the pervasive evil of sadomasochistic males. Page plays a 14-year-old who has been trading salacious messages with an older man online. The latter clearly displays a fetish for underage girls—going so far as to decorate his home with photographs he’s taken of scantily-clad teens—so it’s evident early on that he’s asking for whatever’s coming to him. Of course, the role of predator and prey violently shifts between the two parties, and Hard Candy‘s most culturally enduring element involves Page’s character seemingly performing a castration on the man, who she claims is an at-large serial rapist and murderer. But there’s much more to the film than the aforementioned scene, which occurs far earlier in the runtime than one might expect based solely on its reputation. As far as social commentaries go, Hard Candy doesn’t exactly offer up anything revelatory—men are evil and in our hyper-violent society, their would-be “victims” can (and maybe should) inflict just as much pain upon them—but its sheer edginess has got to be appreciated, particularly as David Slade’s debut film feels like a bygone product of its time. [Natalia Keogan]

23. Dreamgirls

Alongside Chicago and Hairspray, Dreamgirls was one of the breakout movie musicals of the early 2000s, making it all the way to the Oscars and showcasing Jennifer Hudson’s talent beyond American Idol. Bill Condon’s adaptation of the 1981 Broadway musical brought together a catchy soundtrack and stellar cast—including Jamie Foxx, Beyoncé Knowles, Eddie Murphy, and Danny Glover—as they tell a tale loosely inspired by the legacy of Motown, The Supremes’ rise to fame, and their seemingly endless closet of glittering costumes. Following a girl group called The Dreamettes as they go from Detroit to the national spotlight, Dreamgirls centers on the behind-the-scenes drama that occurs when the group’s manager and dream schemer, Curtis (Foxx), promotes the conventionally pretty member of the group, Deena (Beyoncé), over the ensemble’s best singer, Effie (Hudson). The high-stakes personal and professional drama plays out between showstoppers like “One Night Only” and “And I Am Telling You I’m Not Going,” both of which helped Hudson win an Oscar for Best Supporting Actress in her feature debut. [Monica Castillo]

22. Army Of Shadows

It’s only a little unfair to include Jean-Pierre Melville’s heartbreaking French Resistance epic, Army Of Shadows, in our best of 2006 list. Yet, it was the first time most audiences could see this nearly lost masterpiece. Following a decades-long banishment, Army Of Shadows was released in the U.S. at the height of the Iraq War, with Melville’s knack for clever and stylish crime films, Le Cercle Rouge and Le Samouraï, coming down to earth in a brilliantly staged but ultimately bleak story of uncelebrated heroism. Based on Joseph Kessel’s 1943 book, which tracks both real-life and fictitious French Resistance fighters as they attempt to topple the Nazis from below, Army Of Shadows takes a John le Carré approach to guerrilla warfare, portraying the tragedy of doing the right thing unromantically. The complicated narrative follows several fighters in and out of Nazi captivity as each set piece pits stars Lino Ventura, Paul Meurisse, Jean-Pierre Cassel, and Simone Signoret against impossible decisions, shifting allegiances, and judgement calls they preemptively regret. Army Of Shadows expresses the tragedy of being the one who’s gotta do the dirty job, doing so with nail-biting tension and unrestrained humanity. [Matt Schimkowitz]

21. Retribution

Because Retribution, an unfairly slept-on entry into Kiyoshi Kurosawa’s nightmarish oeuvre of modern ghost stories, never played U.S. theaters (and came out before films got streaming releases), we’re bending the rules to let its Chicago festival premiere count towards the 2006 list. It’s just that good. Another collaboration between Kurosawa and his hangdog muse Kōji Yakusho, Retribution once again stars the perfectly scruffy star as a detective on the cusp of going cuckoo—and he’s investigating a series of Gothic murders that all point to him as the prime suspect. A sharply unsettling series of appearances by a ghostly woman in red solidifies Kurosawa as the premier cinematic conjurer of spirits, while also tying his detective’s mental state to his unwieldy and ethereal past. These repressed, compartmentalized memories are almost as threatening as the undead, and bubble up through Kurosawa’s urban-rot aesthetic like suspicious bubbles in a street puddle. Not as groundbreaking as Cure or Pulse, Retribution is a pulpier but no less effective look at social corrosion.  [JO]

20. The Holiday

Released back when movies like these were still called “chick flicks,” The Holiday has stood the test of time as a perennial Christmas favorite. There’s a reason it still hits so powerfully for rom-com fans. Nancy Meyers’ whimsical cross-cultural romance doesn’t just star four incredibly likable protagonists, it’s a tribute to two entirely different styles of romantic comedies in one. Cameron Diaz and Jude Law get a classic opposites-attract, love-at-first-sight tale, while Kate Winslet works her way through the kind of self-actualizing “and-a-man” arc that’s always been a cornerstone of the romance genre. Those parallel journeys showcase the breadth of women-centric storytelling that has long found a haven within rom-coms. Add in an eclectic mix of cozy British cottage aesthetics and glamorous L.A. vibes, never-more-charming turns from Jack Black and Eli Wallach, and a lovely score from Hans Zimmer, and The Holiday feels like a movie made from only the good notes. [Caroline Siede]

19. The Science Of Sleep

On the heels of the Oscar-winning success of Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind, Michel Gondry went even more whimsical in The Science Of Sleep—a film that attempts to translate the feeling of dreaming into cinematic language. Gael García Bernal stars as Stéphane Miroux, a shy, childlike creative who moves to Paris following the death of his father and who soon finds himself infatuated with his neighbor Stéphanie (Charlotte Gainsbourg). As Stéphane’s waking life begins to blend with his dreams, Gondry serves up memorably gonzo images like a TV talk show set made of cardboard, a man with a pair of giant puppet hands, and a miniature stop-motion city. Yet Stéphane’s eccentricity also hides a darker, more antagonistic side that’s not nearly as charming as the romantic protagonist he imagines himself to be. With a plot that also follows the logic of a dream, The Science Of Sleep evokes a unique mix of romance and grief that’s ultimately more challenging (if less cohesive) than Eternal Sunshine. Anchored by Bernal’s stellar performance, it’s a film that both captures and subverts a certain mid-aughts twee sensibility. [CS]

18. Crank

Few films embrace their title like Crank. Written and directed by Mark Neveldine and Brian Taylor, whose collaboration would collapse after a couple of major franchise plays, Crank matches its frenetic energy with a deliriously silly screenplay, following Chev Chelios (Jason Statham, never better), an assassin, stuck in a version of Speed that trades a bus bomb for a human heart. Poisoned with a toxin that will kill him if his adrenaline drops, Chelios electrocutes himself and the audience with a dizzying take on a Donald Westlake-style L.A. crime story. With a dark sense of humor to ground the video-game-inspired violence, Crank never ceases to find new ludicrous obstacles for Chelios to overcome, and with the ticking clock running out inside his body, he doesn’t want to. Statham’s frustrated stoicism makes for a hilarious foil to the premise, as he degrades himself to keep his heart thumping and the movie running. Crank features some of the most original and visceral American action of the decade, a feat only topped by its even-better and more surreal sequel, Crank: High Voltage. [MS]

17. Jackass Number Two

For all its revolutionary on-screen stupidity, Jackass: The Movie never fully embraced its subtitle, outside of some too-gross-for-TV stunts and a larger shopping cart. But Jackass Number Two sees director Jeff Tremaine and leading Ass Johnny Knoxville attempting to live up to its medium, doing so with foolhardy flair, more ambitious death-defiance, and, in what would become a tradition, an elaborate musical sequence, complete with a Buster Keaton shoutout. It’s also the first time Jackass revealed its own fucked-up humanity, forcing Bam Margera to tears through increasingly abusive snake-based pranks. But it’s the elaborate and wildly racist “Terror Taxi” that pushes Number Two into the history books. The rollicking act of comeuppance against Ehren McGhehey, who’s a little too eager to don brownface and a cringe-inducing Apu accent, doles out one ingenious reversal after another as McGhehey’s palpable fear meets the catharsis of watching a supremely offensive sketch get turned on its ear with the help of a winning Jay Chandrasekhar. Number Two still stands tall with some of the series’ best stunts, character moments, and ingenuity, some of which, three Jackass movies later, have yet to be topped. Ironically, Number Two might be number one. [MS]

16. Old Joy

Though Kelly Reichardt’s debut film River Of Grass was a Sundance darling in 1994, it still took her over a decade to raise money for a second feature at a time when Hollywood wasn’t particularly interested in investing in female directors. She finally returned with the hyper-minimalist road movie Old Joy, about two thirtysomething pals who have drifted apart over the years and who try to recapture the magic of their friendship on an overnight camping trip to the Bagby Hot Springs in the mountains of Oregon. Like most of Reichardt’s work, it’s a film that’s small and hushed on the surface, but bursting with melancholic depth underneath. Will Oldham’s insecurities as lost soul Kurt butt up against Daniel London’s timid normality as soon-to-be-father Mark. Their wistful nostalgia for the past soon turns into something thornier and more ambiguous. Old Joy is the sort of film that leaves you in suspense as to whether something or nothing is going to happen on this overnight trip. Yet it’s in that very tension that the film’s aching humanity springs to life. [CS]

15. The Fountain

With the fullness of time—one the trippy sci-fi drama The Fountain‘s many subjects—it seems like Darren Aronofsky peaked with his highest-profile flop. After this ambitious and alienating movie lost so much money, Aronofsky scaled back for a pair of arresting dramas about performers at odds with their bodies (The Wrestler and Black Swan), yet in retrospect there’s something just as special about sending Hugh Jackman hurtling through time and space. It’s not that simple in The Fountain, where Jackman plays a scientist attempting to cure his wife (Rachel Weisz) of brain cancer and finds that his efforts are refracted through the intercut stories of a conquistador in service of Queen Isabella and a far-future space traveler (Jackman and Weisz star in all three timelines). But whether the non-contemporary threads are “real” or in-movie fictions that the doctor and his wife are telling each other, they build off of each other into a multi-level parable about one of life’s greatest difficulties: accepting death. Aronofsky, ably assisted by Jackman at his most open and vulnerable, consciously reaches beyond the bodily concerns (and punishments) that inform so much of his work, but doesn’t leave them behind entirely, either. He depicts transcendence as a hard-won battle with an ending both uncertain and inevitable. [Jesse Hassenger]

14. An Inconvenient Truth

What was once unfairly dismissed as a movie about a PowerPoint presentation has become one of the major documentaries explaining global warming. After losing a hotly contested election, former Vice President Al Gore returned to the national spotlight with a cause: Educate and motivate people against the common enemy of climate change. In Davis Guggenheim’s filmed version of Gore’s well-rehearsed presentation, the politician bobs and weaves between personal anecdotes and scientific data to convey the severity of the existential threat to humanity while reflecting on some of the more difficult moments in his family’s story. Breaking down what it means if the ice caps melted, glaciers collapsed, wildfire season became a year-round phenomenon, and coral reefs died out—all in terms everyone could understand—Gore sums things up: It’s not going well. But not one to leave the room on a downer, Gore ends with actionable steps for his audience to do more about climate change. Today, severe storms and near-constant weather warnings are part of our daily life, and we see just how many of Gore’s predictions have come to pass. [MC]

13. Volver

Pedro Almodóvar has regularly reflected on his relationship with his mother in his work, but never has she quite literally haunted the storyline as she does in Volver. Filmed in the same region in La Mancha where the director grew up, the film is part rape-revenger, part crime thriller, and mostly a meditation on the unique strength of intergenerational bonds between women. This is to say that there are a lot of threads deftly woven together here—which also include a film shoot and an elderly dementia patient—but arguably the most care is given to constructing an unconventional ghost story, in which the presence of a family’s long-deceased mother (Almodóvar stalwart Carmen Maura) is discovered by her children (Penélope Cruz and Lola Dueñas) when they begin to smell the unmistakable scent of her farts. It’s apt that Cruz, the first Spanish woman to be nominated for the Academy Award for Best Actress on the strength of her performance as a complex matriarch in Volver, went on to portray Almodóvar’s mother in his 2019 memoir-flecked masterpiece Pain And Glory. [NK]

12. Casino Royale

Martin Campbell and Daniel Craig gave 007 a much-needed whack in the nuts for their dark-and-gritty pivot of James Bond. The hyper-digital, product-filled, loud-and-proud Die Another Day caused Casino Royale to sprint in the other direction—straight up a towering crane. Just like its exceptionally muscular set pieces, Casino Royale ran through its Bond basics with a grim physicality, rebooting not just the franchise, but providing a suitably sour origin for the troubled character. Craig showed the world just how suave a chiseled hunk of limestone could be, especially with a riveting, slinking femme fatale like Eva Green to drape over him. Add in a world-class villain in a blood-weeping Mads Mikkelsen, some climactic poker, and the crushing revelation that this version of James Bond (unfortunately for him) has a soul, and you’ve got one of the best 007 movies ever made. [JO]

11. Miami Vice

Released on the heels of Todd Phillips’ Starsky & Hutch, Michael Mann’s War On Terror update to Miami Vice sidestepped broad appeal for a digital makeover that upgraded the series with an original and influential look. In 2006, no major studio release would dare look like Miami Vice, with digital photography tipping into the uncanny with sweaty intimacy and awe-inspiring clarity. For all its abstraction and emotion, from its theatrical cut’s media-res opening, which includes the platonic ideal Linkin Park needle drop, Miami Vice is immensely quotable (“I’m a fiend for mojitos), funny (“Why is this happening to me?”), and romantic. Mapped by Mann’s process-oriented filmmaking and organizational realism, Miami Vice‘s plot is obfuscated by jargon and shifting motives. Crockett (Colin Farrell) and Tubbs (Jamie Foxx) are under such deep cover that who they are and what they’re doing remains uncomfortably opaque at first, though the film’s alluring sensuality and overwhelming action remain intoxicating. Like Inland Empire, the film sees an auteur embracing the abstraction of their own fixations and relying on pure id. The results are transcendent. [MS]

10. The Devil Wears Prada

Based on Lauren Weisberger’s novel, The Devil Wears Prada took on a life of its own as soon as it hit theaters. Andy (Anne Hathaway) is an aspiring journalist with little fashion sense who finds herself in the posh publishing realm of Runway magazine. She must survive a crash course on the complex art and business of fashion from her prickly boss, Miranda Priestly (Meryl Streep), as well as navigate thorny inter-office politics if she wants to advance her budding media career. Inspired by Vogue editor Anna Wintour, Priestly became an on-screen icon with cutting bon mots and a brutally chilly demeanor. Stanley Tucci as Miranda’s right-hand man and Emily Blunt as Andy’s frenemy rounded out the movie’s fab four stars with pithy retorts and punchlines. While the 2026 sequel didn’t quite capture the magic of the original, it paid heavy tribute to the fans that made this movie the comic sensation it remains today. [MC]

9. Pan’s Labyrinth

Guillermo del Toro’s nightmare fantasy Pan’s Labyrinth follows a young girl named Ofelia who escapes to a fairy-tale world filled with fauns, monsters, and fantastical creatures at the height of 1940s Francoist Spain. Danger lives both in and out of the realm of make-believe as soldiers and generals battle for what they believe and a little girl watches as her world falls apart. Meanwhile, Ofelia must complete a magical faun’s three tasks in order to ascend to her rightful throne among the magical beings. Pan’s Labyrinth marked del Toro’s return to Spanish-language cinema after spending some time with Hollywood superheroes. The film built on many of del Toro’s signature fascinations, like detailed practical effects, striking character designs, and maximalist worlds that whisk audiences away from the ordinary. Pan’s Labyrinth made a splash at Cannes and went on to win numerous awards, including many of the craft Oscars, heralding del Toro as a major director to watch. [MC]

8. Talladega Nights: The Ballad Of Ricky Bobby

Will Ferrell and Adam McKay are better together. Talladega Nights, their second film, went bigger than Anchorman: a stacked cast, racecar action, and more contemporary satirical targets in the form of NASCAR and the entire American value system as it looked well into the second George W. Bush term. Ferrell didn’t need to do an actual Bush impression to spoof our love affair with cocksure, rapaciously capitalistic pseudo-champions like the fictional title character, a sponsor-happy driver who believes “if you ain’t first, you’re last.” The movie’s rise-and-fall-and-rise structure—a sports-narrative framework Ferrell is obviously fond of, but has never executed this well—gives it scaffolding on which to build both big-ticket slapstick and bespoke dialogue nonsense, leveled up by cast-wide improvisations. The satire and absurdist riffing come together perfectly in the movie’s extended jam of a family dinner-table sequence, wherein Ricky Bobby and his faithful second banana Cal (John C. Reilly) lead a digressive grace involving a feast of fast food, entitled monster-children, and an insistent preference for the baby version of Jesus. 20 years later, the only thing that doesn’t ring true about Talladega Nights is that Ricky Bobby does become a better person in the end. Maybe McKay stopped making funny comedies around the time he realized how accidentally optimistic his satires had been. [JH]

7. Inside Man

A real “yeah, I can do this too” of a movie, Inside Man is filmmaker Spike Lee at his most commercial and confident, a studio genre exercise that shows the same deference to pulpy film history (and flavors it with the same kinds of auteurist predilections) as his Kurosawa remake Highest 2 Lowest. The twisty New York bank heist/hostage thriller certainly has hints of Dog Day Afternoon, the 1975 classic Lee was inspired by when he got the script, but it also has plenty of Spike: The line between cops and robbers is drawn not depending on the legality of their actions, but how they align with the larger powers that be; it’s overrun by Real New York Characters; and Denzel Washington is killing it at every moment. It’s not just Washington and his swagger either. Lee attracted a ridiculous cast for his big studio-backed reckoning with post-9/11 anxiety in NYC (following his much more somber version, 25th Hour), which means Clive Owen, Chiwetel Ejiofor, Willem Dafoe, and Jodie Foster are all stuffed into a movie that still manages to tick and tock forward with unmatched precision and subtle insight. [JO]

6. Inland Empire

David Lynch’s final film (setting aside the debate over Twin Peaks season three) and a multi-year collaboration with longtime leading lady Laura Dern, Inland Empire is easily the scariest film of 2006. Once again meditating on the La La Land nightmares that powered his masterpiece Mulholland Drive, Lynch grabbed a camcorder for an on-the-fly shoot, recording a stream-of-consciousness odyssey into the relationship between actor and audience. The fourth wall crumbles as Hollywood actress Nikki (Dern, in a career-best performance that inspired an all-time great FYC campaign) disappears into the role of Sue Blue, literally, as years of Lynchian micro-projects, such as the whatsit sitcom Rabbits, and a mysterious Polish Lost Girl (Karolina Gruszka), react to a frequently shifting narrative that’s as elusive as it is effective. Inland Empire remains one of Lynch’s most difficult, emotional, and terrifying works, challenging the viewer with a web-like structure and a deliberately unglamorous lead turn. 20 years later, there’s still nothing quite like Inland Empire. Two decades from now, there still won’t be. [MS]

5. Brick

Fittingly, Brick comes on like a school assignment, completed with smartass confidence: Write a high-school-set mystery as a hard-edged noir, complete with a detective, femme fatales, menacing underworld figures, and enough slang to choke a Dashiell Hammett character. But it doesn’t take long to realize that despite writer-director Rian Johnson’s ample wit, the movie isn’t joking around. As scrappy teenage sleuth Brendan Frye, Joseph Gordon-Levitt skulks around the parking lots and sun-streaked outdoor hallways of California, his fists jammed into his pockets like a description straight out of YA fiction, looking to solve a very adult murder case. Brick works less because of its allegiance to noir conventions—though it does have that, with a well-plotted and visually rich mystery that presages much of Johnson’s subsequent career as an expert practitioner of the whodunit—than because of its success as a teen movie. Johnson drills into the core of why displacing classic stories into high school, whether Shakespeare or noir, can be so effective: It’s a milieu where it makes sense for every character to feel deeply (and/or hormonally) invested in the outcome. As funny and thrilling as Brick can be, it’s ultimately about nursing a tough yet broken heart. [JH]

4. Children Of Men

Alfonso Cuarón’s dystopian sci-fi thriller is one of cinema’s bleakest views of the future, where immigration detention centers capture countless souls and an infertility crisis has driven the world mad with desperation. Set in 2027 after decades of infertility has left humanity without a next generation, Theo (Clive Owen) is a bureaucrat caught in the middle of a bid for the cure to infertility. He’s kidnapped by militants, including his ex-wife (Julianne Moore), to help smuggle a refugee who’s hiding humanity’s first pregnancy in years. The fight to survive and escape from humanity’s cruelty is harder than it looks, as Theo strives to save both mother and child from danger. Cuarón’s bleak portrait of the future has now haunted multiple generations of moviegoers, and his innovative camera work with cinematographer Emmanuel Lubezki—capturing the sheer intensity of Theo’s journey—has stood the test of time. [MC]

3. The Prestige

Edging out 2006’s magical also-ran, The Illusionist, The Prestige was the superior sleight-of-hand blockbuster and then some. Christopher Nolan, coming off his superhero-legitimizing Batman reboot, reteamed with Christian Bale and Michael Caine for a story of competition, showmanship, and con-man artistry, making magic as compelling as any Caped Crusader. Bale and Hugh Jackman, the latter rebounding from his own superhero stint in X-Men: The Last Stand, play competing magicians each attempting a variation of the White Whale trick “The Transported Man.” Co-written with Nolan’s brother, Jonathan, The Prestige is structured like a magic trick: There’s the pledge, the turn, and the prestige, all of which is unveiled with their unique, secretly sci-fi and class-conscious approach to create a bloodthirsty magic war in 1890s London. Frequently showing the audience that there’s nothing up its sleeve, all while wowing them with intrigue, pathos, and David Bowie as Nikola Tesla, Nolan offered a glimpse of what his own future held. The key to Nolan’s artistry is lurking somewhere in The Prestige, but a good magician never reveals his tricks. [MS]

2. Marie Antoinette

Allegedly booed during previews ahead of its Cannes premiere (though Roger Ebert claimed this anecdote was wildly overblown), Sofia Coppola’s candy-colored mishmash of rococo and early aughts aesthetics remains in a class all its own. Kirsten Dunst’s embodiment of the ill-fated French ruler is deliciously anachronistic, her twentysomething American affect perfectly reflecting the self-centered hedonism that has come to define the queen in popular culture. Yet there is also something deeply tragic and sympathetic about her through the gaze of Coppola, who has built a career on dissecting bitter feminine realities. It’s easy to criticize vanity, debauchery, and superfluity, particularly in a figure who came to symbolize the frustrations of the French underclass. But it takes much more work to understand that these flights of fancy are coping mechanisms for the ennui experienced by women who have little control over their actions and image. Marie Antionette and the American teenage girl have a lot in common. Whether one soundtracks their lives with Scarlatti and The Strokes or, in 2026, Olivia Rodrigo, they all have relatively little autonomy under the patriarchy. At least unlike the film’s strikingly rebellious wardrobe of period-inspired couture and Converse—which earned Milena Canonero an Oscar for Costume Design—facing the guillotine for crimes of public scrutiny has fallen out of style. [NK]

1. The Departed

Fackin’ right Mahty is at the tahp of tha list! Finally winning a Best Director Oscar for submerging the suave and tormented cops-and-crooks tale Infernal Affairs in the Boston Harbor, Martin Scorsese returned squarely to his comfort zone for The Departed, a violent, nihilistic, profane, hilarious crime drama about men stuck in their ways and headed to hell. That these men are on opposite sides of the law doesn’t really matter; undercover cop Billy Costigan (Leonardo DiCaprio) and Colin Sullivan (Matt Damon), the mob’s man on the inside, find themselves blurring into one another, their loyalties and resolve tested only by the limits of how much suffering they can personally endure. Both suffer for selfish reasons, Billy so he can prove his upbringing wrong and Colin so he can milk his deception for all it’s worth. Behind them are powerful patriarchs (Jack Nicholson’s slimy gangster, Martin Sheen’s noble police captain, Catholicism’s angry God), Scorsese’s looming and ominous imagery, and a police psychiatrist (Vera Farmiga) drawn in by both leads’ imperfections. It’s a grim duality that peaks during the movie’s most gripping moments of tension, and is one pervasive enough that it critiques America at large—which was clearly Scorsese’s down-and-dirty intent from the film’s start, which opens with footage from the ’70s Boston race riots. It all just happened to be entertaining and virtuosic enough that, like so many of Scorsese’s gangster movies, mainstream audiences gobbled it up. [JO]

 
Join the discussion...
Keep scrolling for more great stories.