Emmys 2023: Top 16 contenders for Lead Actor nominations

The stars of Succession, The Bear, Ted Lasso, and Better Call Saul are all in the mix for top acting prizes

By Saloni Gajjar  |  June 28, 2023 | 2:00pm
TV Features Emmys
Emmys 2023: Top 16 contenders for Lead Actor nominations
Clockwise from bottom left: Jason Sudeikis in Ted Lasso (Photo: Apple TV+); Kieran Culkin in Succession (Photo: Macall Polay); Kayvan Novak in What We Do In The Shadows (Photo: Russ Martin/FX); Antony Starr in The Boys (Photo: Prime Video)

With the 2023 Primetime Emmy nominations just around the corner—they’ll be announced on July 12, and the show takes place on September 18—The A.V Club is breaking down this year’s contenders in some key races. After tackling dramas and comedies, we turn our attention to two more big categories: Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series and Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series.

These races are more competitive this year, with six nominees in the drama category and only five in the comedy field, thanks to the Emmys sliding scale rules. On the drama side, three Succession stars are in the hunt, while it’s Bob Odenkirk’s final chance for a Better Call Saul win. As for Comedy, Jason Sudeikis could take home the award for a third consecutive time for Ted Lasso—that is, unless The Bear’s Jeremy Allen White steals it. To help narrow all the contenders down for both categories, The A.V. Club has picked out the strong possibilities, wild cards, and actors who should (but sadly won’t) be nominated. And be sure to check back in next week, when we’ll dissect potential Outstanding Lead Actress nods.

Top contender (drama): Paddy Considine, House Of The Dragon
King Viserys Targaryen’s Speech | House of the Dragon S1E8

Paddy Considine all but secured an Emmy nomination with his wrenching monologue in , which also marked the end of his time with the prequel. King Viserys may have had a relatively short run on screen, but Considine left an indelible mark with his performance. While there’s a chance he could get overlooked in favor of a more famous franchise or star (like Andor’s Diego Luna or 1923’s Harrison Ford), HOTD has enough Emmy goodwill because of its predecessor, and Considine himself has been delivering strong performances for more than two decades, so this might be his year.

Top contender (drama): Brian Cox, Succession
Logan Roy Apologizes | Succession | HBO

, who appeared only in two full episodes of Succession’s fourth season, race. But can you imagine slotting the patriarch elsewhere? Of course you can’t. Although Cox is worthy of an Emmy anytime, it’s unlikely he’ll beat his fellow nominees (and castmates Jeremy Strong and Kieran Culkin) with such limited screen time.

Top contender (drama): Kieran Culkin, Succession
Roman’s Speech - Logan’s Funeral | Succession S4E9

moves up from the Supporting Actor race to the Lead Actor category for this year’s Emmys. It’s a well-earned upgrade since ’s final season focused heavily on Roman Roy in the post-Logan era, . Culkin’s shift certainly lifts the chances of Matthew Macfadyen to win his second Supporting Actor Emmy, but will this Culkin be able edge out Cox and former winner Strong? The competition for this most perfect of shows is … stiff.

Top contender (drama): Bob Odenkirk, Better Call Saul
Jimmy’s New Life as Saul Goodman | Better Call Saul S6 E9 “Fun and Games”

It’s the last shot for Bob Odenkirk to win an Emmy for his fantastic performance. The actor has been nominated for every season on the show—and will undoubtedly score another one for BCS’s final batch of episodes. He could pull off a W similar to , who finally nabbed the trophy for ’s final season. BCS predecessor also won big for its closing season, so that could bode well for Odenkirk’s chances. Fortunately, the voters tend to favor shows that have bid farewell. Unfortunately, BCS is also up against the final round of Succession.

Top contender (drama): Pedro Pascal, The Last Of Us
The Last of Us HBO: S1E6 - Ellie x Joel Confrontation scene, “You have no idea what loss is”

is having a very good year. After starring in both and season three of The Mandalorian in the past year, Pascal is most likely to get his first Emmy nomination for the former. (At least his face isn’t covered by a helmet in TLOU.) HBO’s video-game adaptation allowed Pascal to showcase his impressive range. And if he gets a nom, he’ll become only the second Latino (after Jimmy Smits) to be recognized in the Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series category. Pascal is also looking at a for Guest Actor in a Comedy, thanks to his fan-favorite .

Top contender (drama): Jeremy Strong, Succession
Shiv Betrays Kendall - Succession Finale

Succession’s number one boy is rightfully coming for his crown again. ’s powerhouse performance as Kendall Roy already scored him an and nothing will stop him from getting another nomination. But will he win the trophy? He’ll have to get past both Culkin and Cox. Or will split voting between three Succession actors allow someone else to walk away with the award? There are so many questions, people.

Should but won’t be nominated (drama): Antony Starr, The Boys
the boys season 3: Homelander puts Starlight in her place scene

Antony Starr has always been a scene-stealer in . And it’s a shame that he hasn’t already won for his performance. because of Homelander’s even-scarier-than-usual turn—that is, slowly embracing his outright, murderous narcissism in front of the public and gaining their love anyway. Starr is brilliant at showcasing his character’s menacing downfall. Hopefully, Emmy voters realize this, too, instead of leaving The Boys out in the cold.

Top contender (comedy): Bill Hader, Barry
Barry & Gene Final Scene | Barry 04x08 wow

is not a comedy, per se, especially not in its grim final season, which rarely elicited laughs. But it does have a damn fine performance from (who also directed all eight episodes) that deserves recognition. Hader won the best actor comedy award for the first two seasons of Barry, but the show’s fourth season might be a little too bleak for Emmy voters. While a win might be unlikely, that doesn’t mean Hader can’t nab a nomination for taking Barry out on a high note.

Top contender (comedy): Steve Martin, Only Murders In The Building
Charles Reveals Another Secret - Only Murders In The Building Season 2

If the Emmys knew what they were doing,’s trio of stars would host the show. But don’t worry, voters will still recognize at least two of the three cast members in another way. Steve Martin is looking good to secure his second nomination for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy along with co-star Martin Short. ( as well.)

Top contender (comedy): Martin Short, Only Murders In The Building
Best Moments From Season 2 | Only Murders in the Building | Hulu

Martin Short is gunning for his second nomination in this category … and he’ll likely receive it, right alongside his Only Murders In The Building costar Steve Martin. Short and Martin are crushing it in OMITB as rookie sleuths/podcast hosts. Plus, both stars have been Hollywood mainstays for decades, and the Academy will want to honor that.

Top contender (comedy): Jason Sudeikis, Ted Lasso
Ted Lasso — Thank You and F*ck You | Apple TV+

Will Emmy voters suddenly decided not to nominate for ? That’s a hard no. The two-time winner is a shoo-in once more. If he wins, he’ll be the fifth actor to grab three consecutive trophies after Don Adams for Get Smart, Carroll O’Connor for All In The Family, for Family Ties, and Dick Van Dyke for The Dick Van Dyke Show. Ted Lasso is a cherished show, and despite mixed reviews for the show’s season, Sudeikis has a strong enough pull to win this race.

Top contender (comedy): Jeremy Allen White, The Bear
Carmy’s 7-Minute Monologue | The Bear | FX

is the strongest competitor to Sudeikis for top honors in this year’s race for Outstanding Actor in a Comedy Series. ’s first season enjoyed the kind of word-of-mouth rise that powered Ted Lasso during that show’s initial run. And White’s poignant performance as Chef Carmy is more than worthy of a win. Plus, crucially, was released during the nomination period, which means the show is fresh in the minds of Television Academy members. White has already won a Golden Globe, a SAG award, and a Critics’ Choice award this year, which bodes well for his Emmy chances.

Wild card (comedy): Nicholas Hoult, The Great
The Great: S3 Catherine & Peter | HD Opening Scene

After scoring a surprise nomination last year, could find his way into the top five again this year for his performance in . Hulu hasn’t renewed the show yet, but it marked Hoult’s final turn as Peter III. (His lookalike Pugachev is alive and well, at least). Hoult is hilarious in a way that may connect with voters more than, say, Jason Segel in his grief comedy Shrinking, so he could make the cut again.

Wild card (comedy): Jason Segel, Shrinking
Shrinking S01 E03 Sneak Peek | ‘I Cried 4 Times Today’

Jason Segel has been part of acclaimed TV shows (, ) but hasn’t scored an Emmy nomination yet. That could change with Shrinking. He co-created the Apple TV+ comedy with Ted Lasso’s Bill Lawrence and Brett Goldstein, which means he has goodwill by association already.

Should but won’t be nominated (comedy): Kayvan Novak, What We Do In The Shadows
Inside Look: Kavyan Novak & Harvey Guillen Share Truth About ‘Nandermo’ | What We Do in the Shadows

It’s challenging to sustain and evolve a performance over four seasons when your character is an undying vampire. But Kayvan Novak makes it look easy in . Granted, the ensemble of this FX comedy (especially and Natasia Demetriou) also deserves honors, but in season four Novak toed the line between emotional vulnerability and dry hilarity as Nandor began craving a relationship. If there was any Emmy justice, voters would take WWDITS far more seriously than Nandor took his marriage to Marwa.

 
Join the discussion...