BSeason 3Actually, Supergirl’s about ethics in superhero secret identitiesCaroline SiedeMonday 11:00pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalink It’s almost hard to remember now, but back in Supergirl’s first season we used to spend almost as…
B+Season 3Let the Reign fall down, Supergirl is coming cleanCaroline Siede5/14/18 10:20pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalinkThe tricky thing about reviewing a show like Supergirl in its third season is that it can be hard to come up with new…
BSeason 3Supergirl unleashes an unholy trinity Caroline Siede5/07/18 11:15pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalink“We’re in the endgame now.” That’s a line that’s knowingly delivered in the latter half of the superhero extravaganza …
B-Season 3Supergirl finally introduces its third WorldkillerCaroline Siede4/30/18 10:25pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalink After a standalone story about Winn’s mom and an episode that mostly felt like it was stalling for…
CSeason 3Supergirl stretches for time with cape tricks and mind tricksCaroline Siede4/23/18 10:00pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalinkDenial: It’s not just a river in Egypt, it’s also a plot device that allows Supergirl to stretch 10 minutes of story…
BSeason 3Supergirl returns from hiatus to give us Laurie Metcalf yelling at a flying monkeyCaroline Siede4/16/18 8:00pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalinkBetween the big Arrowverse crossover episode, its normal winter hiatus, and its more abnormal late winter hiatus,…
B-Season 3A talky Supergirl doesn’t actually have much to sayCaroline Siede2/05/18 11:10pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalinkSupergirl’s third season has had its ups and downs, but so far its weaker episodes have been the ones that seemed…
B-Season 3A scattered Supergirl checks in on all the storylines it forgot aboutCaroline Siede1/29/18 10:45pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalinkI have to imagine the pitch meeting for “For Good” involved the writers sitting in a room, trying to remember all the…
BSeason 3An impressively female-centric Supergirl goes where no man has gone beforeCaroline Siede1/22/18 11:00pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalinkGiven that it features multiple characters heading off into space like it’s the most casual thing in the world, “Fort…
B+Season 3Supergirl’s return is stylish, confident, and full of new superheroesCaroline Siede1/15/18 8:00pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalinkIt’s always a joy to watch a TV show hit its stride and it really feels like Supergirl is doing that in its third…
BSeason 3Christmas comes early as Supergirl’s mid-season finale delivers a great final fightCaroline Siede12/04/17 10:30pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalinkAs a rule, Supergirl mid-season finales tend not to be my favorite thing in the world. They have to touch on the…
B+Season 3Supergirl hops Earths, punches Nazis as The CW’s crossover extravaganza beginsCaroline Siede11/27/17 8:00pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalinkTV crossovers are strange beasts. At their best, they recapture the childlike joy of throwing all your toys into the…
BSeason 3Mon-El’s return to Supergirl comes with a timey wimey twistCaroline Siede11/20/17 10:35pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalink“Wake Up” feels different than your average episode of Supergirl. There’s very little in the way of action and there…
C+Season 3A flashback-heavy Supergirl heads back to Riverdale… er, MidvaleCaroline Siede11/13/17 10:35pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalink“Midvale” plays like a backdoor pilot for a series about the teenage Danvers sisters solving murder mysteries in…
BSeason 3Supergirl says goodbye to a beloved coupleCaroline Siede11/06/17 10:35pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalinkOne of the trickiest things TV shows have to deal with is real-life scheduling issues. Whether an actor is shooting a…
B+Season 3Whoops, Supergirl accidentally started a cultCaroline Siede10/30/17 11:15pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalinkFor all its strengths, Supergirl isn’t usually a show that asks big philosophical questions. So partway through…
B+Season 3An ambitious Supergirl flies a convertible to MarsCaroline Siede10/23/17 8:00pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalinkSometimes I like to stop and take stock of just how far Supergirl has come in the past three seasons. Like all of the…
B-Season 3The only thing Supergirl has to fear is fear itself (and Jane The Virgin’s Yael Grobglas)Caroline Siede10/16/17 8:00pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalink“Triggers” answers the question of how Supergirl will approach Kara’s post-Mon-El funk going forward: No, her smile at…
B+Season 3How's Kara doing in Supergirl’s third season premiere? Not great, BobCaroline Siede10/09/17 8:00pmEditSend to EditorsPromoteGo to permalinkIf you’d told me early during Supergirl’s first season that I’d one day be crying because Alex Danvers asked Hank…
