C+

Tom Segura unleashes his Bad Thoughts in an insane sketch-comedy show

This is the comedian's most ambitious and unapologetic project to date.

Tom Segura unleashes his Bad Thoughts in an insane sketch-comedy show

Tom Segura is one of the most popular comedians of the podcast era. Joe Rogan is obviously the most successful in this department, but Robert Kelly, Andrew Santino and Bobby Lee, Bill Burr, and Theo Von, among many others, have used the form to reach fans they never could through touring alone. Segura has actually hit podcast peaks twice with Your Mom’s House (which he co-hosts with his wife, Christina Pazsitzky) and 2 Bears, 1 Cave (which he does with his longtime pal, Bert Kreischer). 

Segura, who has several Netflix specials, is now unveiling his most ambitious project to date, the truly insane Bad Thoughts, a sketch-comedy show that plays out like comedian’s most memorable nightmares brought to life. Think of the weirdest, darkest, grossest dream you’ve ever had—and now imagine that in sketch form. That’s the gist here. Tim Robinson’s I Think You Should Leave feels like the obvious comparison, but Segura’s approach is significantly more aggressive, with the comedian pushing the envelope in terms of good taste and problematic humor. And like a lot of sketch comedy, it’s a roller-coaster in terms of quality, but there are some undeniably clever beats.

To say that Bad Thoughts is messed up doesn’t really do it justice. A lot of TV comedies try to be edgy or dark without ever getting anywhere near the demented through-lines of these sketches. Each of the six short episodes (all of them are under 20 minutes) has a theme like “Jobs,” “Health,” and “Success,” although they could just as easily be named after bodily fluids or different words for genitalia. Bad Thoughts is almost overly invested in living up to its title, blending traditional sketch comedy with Twilight Zone-esque twists of fate, all of it filtered through an X-rated sense of humor. 

Of course, some skepticism is warranted here. There have been dozens of shows that promised dark humor and ended up about as edgy as an awkward open-mic night. The highest praise one can pay Segura and the comedy he employs like a weapon in Bad Thoughts is that it is fearlessly unapologetic. In one sketch, a man joins a gym only to discover that the supplement being given there makes everyone’s dick bigger—and bigger and bigger. And in another, a guy meets a beautiful woman in France and is told that in order to sleep with her, he must have sex with her “twin” first, which might result in the grossest sequence to hit a Netflix original.  

Segura and his writers take their ideas to surreal, grotesque places that other teams probably wouldn’t even consider much less try to get on TV. It’s always good for the comedy scene to have some fearless warriors, people willing to offend half the room to get a laugh from the other half. And while “you couldn’t release X today” sentiments and overblown cancel-culture fears make for the most tired conversations, there is some impressive needle-threading in Bad Thoughts, a show that isn’t afraid to make jokes that are going to piss some people off.

Now, being aggressively offensive just to be offensive can be the death of comedy too, and Bad Thoughts runs into this problem a few times. Segura and his team have a habit of lingering in a joke or punchline for longer than they need to. Sometimes the trick to a great sketch is knowing when to drop the mic and move on to the next idea. Not only does Bad Thoughts like to linger on gross concepts, it purposefully takes them way past their comedic breaking points. It’s a game of gross-out comedy chicken that asks, “You think this is gross? You’re not ready for what’s next.” And again, while that fearlessness is admirable, it’s not always funny. As inventive as it can be, Bad Thoughts falters in terms of pacing more than I Think You Should Leave or other sketch greats like Chappelle’s Show and Key & Peele. That said, this feels like something that could easily be refined in a second season.

There are a few inspired guest appearances, too. Pazsitzky gets maybe the best sketch of the season, one that revolves around a group of kids turning grandpa’s most horrific Vietnam War stories into a school play. And the series boasts the always-welcome Dan Stevens, a nice bit of dry humor from Shea Whigham, and a recurring bit from, of all people, Robert Iler, who hasn’t been on TV since 2009. He kills it, even if his final sketch is one of those aforementioned outings that goes on past its comedic breaking point.

If Bad Thoughts is big enough to warrant a renewal from Netflix—and it almost certainly will be given the meme-able insanity of some of its twisted ideas—all of the issues with season one could be refined and ultimately forgotten. Still, it’s going to take some time to wipe away the memory of that twin sketch—and maybe some therapy.

Bad Thoughts premieres May 13 on Netflix  

 
Join the discussion...