Spoiler Space: James Cameron keeps upending what Avatar means

With Fire And Ash, James Cameron puts humans back at the center of the story.

Spoiler Space: James Cameron keeps upending what Avatar means
Listen to this article

Spoiler Space offers thoughts on, and a place to discuss, the plot points we can’t disclose in our official review. Fair warning: This article features plot details of Avatar: Fire And Ash.

There’s a shot in Avatar: Fire And Ash, director James Cameron’s third holiday in Pandora in 16 years, that could qualify as an Easter egg. As one of the few remaining scientists on the planet who are still purely human, Dr. Norm Spellman (Joel David Moore), springs into action, the camera follows him into a beat-up tanning bed-like device. It lingers on the device as if to ask the audience, “Remember when these movies were about these things?” The “link unit” once connected the paraplegic marine Jake Sully (Sam Worthington) to his avatar body, and it was as integral to the first film as 3D glasses. As has been true in much of Cameron’s sci-fi work, the technology in Avatar was the key to human survival and evolution. However, since that first movie, Cameron has allowed the tech to recede into the background. With Fire And Ash, change comes from within.

When Avatar debuted in December 2009, Cameron hyped his groundbreaking digital effects as a sea change for the motion picture industry. He baked his vision of a techno-utopia into the script, which heralded a consciousness-altering device that could give people new lives, bodies, and perspectives. Like Dorothy stepping into Technicolor, Cameron pitched Jake Sully’s experience on Pandora as a stand-in for that of the audience, offering a new level of immersion through the director’s use of state-of-the-art 3D. The debate over whether he succeeded has raged for more than a decade, but the director has moved on, and he has since inverted, subverted, and upended the idea that technology was the answer to humanity’s problems. Lately, he seems less convinced than ever.

Cameron’s interest in technology has always been two-fold. Since The Terminator, he’s been at the forefront of visual effects, using them to tell grand stories of grander emotions. His characters often grapple with their relationship to technology and typically need to make peace with it before silencing an existential threat against the family. Aliens‘ Ripley must pilot a new mechanized body, the Powerloader, to defeat the Alien queen. In Terminator 2, a rebuttal to Cameron’s own fatalistic cyberpunk original, Sarah (Linda Hamilton) and John Connor (Edward Furlong) must form a nuclear family with her former predator, the T-800 (Arnold Schwarzenegger), to properly dispose of the T-1000 (Robert Patrick) and prevent a war with the machines. As if to put a point on his shifting attitudes, by the end of Avatar, a Na’vi, Neytiri (Zoe Saldaña), kills Miles Quaritch (Stephen Lang), the series’ sneering avatar of colonialism, decked out in a mech suit seemingly pillaged from Weaver’s old trailer.

By 2022’s Avatar: The Way Of Water, Cameron had further deemphasized the importance of tech on Pandora, focusing closer on the spiritual connection to his digital world. The avatar bodies are basically gone, replaced by hybrids of the natural and artificial. Jake Sully’s five-fingered children, the offspring of a natural Na’vi and an avatar body, become the focus, along with Kiri (Weaver), the immaculately conceived child of Dr. Grace’s (also Weaver) avatar. The late Colonel Quaritch, too, gets a transhumanist resurrection, with his memories permanently uploaded to an avatar he can’t escape. Most tellingly, the number of human characters is greatly reduced, mostly narrowing down to Quaritch’s son, Spider (Jack Champion), the boy raised by Na’vi—effectively, Cameron’s very own Mowgli.

In Fire And Ash, Cameron leaves the high-tech focus further behind, and goes even harder on both the spiritual and the human themes. Spider is the film’s MacGuffin, with his oxygen mask providing much of the first act’s tension. The film revolves around whether he’ll be welcomed into the Sully familial fortress, but first, he needs to learn how to breathe on Pandora. When his oxygen mask runs out of battery, technology can’t save him; only Kiri’s new powers can do that. Through a mix of prayer and botany, Kiri raises magical weeds from the forest floor, which enter Spider’s mouth and plant an endosymbiont deep inside his lungs. The nature of Pandora and the biology of humanity work together, giving him the ability to breathe again—as well as one of those magic dreadlocks that allows Spider to plug into Pandora’s flora and fauna. It’s this internal transformation that becomes the new unobtanium for the plot: If Quaritch gets to Spider first, and shows this scientific discovery to the military, it could be put to sinister use, supercharging humanity’s colonization efforts.

As Cameron devotes the rest of his natural life to these movies—one must assume there will be some Cameron-Bot making films long after he’s passed—he continues to indulge his cornier side as he’s aged. And this is the guy who ended Terminator 2 with, “I know now why you cry, but it is something I can never do.” With the Avatar movies, he’s added a spirituality that matches his crunchier beliefs, doing so through these CGI wonders. By deemphasizing the in-universe technology, Cameron removes the need for an audience surrogate who puts on his own 3D glasses. He doesn’t want the audience to think about jacking in and out of different bodies; he simply wants us to experience Pandora. Hence, in Fire And Ash, the idea of Na’vi getting a hold of advanced human weaponry becomes an existential threat, while the Sully kids seek help at the bottom of the ocean—a place Cameron has spent more time than almost any other person.

Cameron refutes his earlier films with these latest Avatar sequels, seeming less and less convinced by technology’s ability to bring people together. He wants Pandora and its films to be a unifier, a communal experience, one that’s welcoming to all people. He literalizes that with Spider—a human who’s literally becoming Na’vi on the inside—and by the end of Fire And Ash, he’s welcomed into the Na’vi’s spirit world not through technology, but his natural and spiritual evolution. It’s an arc that represents a full-circle moment for the filmmaker. “Because if a machine, a Terminator, can learn the value of human life,” Sarah Connor narrates at the end of Terminator 2, “maybe we can, too.” For all his incredible CGI, Cameron is finally investing in humanity first and foremost.

 
Join the discussion...