After one opening skit where Stewart and Colbert were seen toadying to current Daily Show host Trevor Noah’s Trump-esque whims, and another flashing back to Colbert’s last Daily Show day (complete with 2005-standard soul patch), Stewart took the first segment with Colbert alone, joking about his semi-retirement as a “gentleman farmer,” according to Colbert. (Referring to Stewart’s 2015 departure, Colbert joked, “You used to talk about bullshit but now you literally shovel it.”) The two took time to touch on Bill O’Reilly’s sexual harassment-related firing from Fox News (“The place was run by a guy who was doing the same thing. There was no accountability throughout the entire building,” said Stewart), and Colbert’s recent controversial “potty mouth,” as Stewart put it, which has come under some equally controversial FCC scrutiny. (Or not.)
But the vibe of the night was one of old comedy warriors sitting down to swap battle stories, something that only grew warmer as Bee, Corddry, Oliver, and Helms joined the pair for a nostalgic trip through their most harrowing moments as Daily Show correspondents. Showing clips from their first, uniformly and intentionally embarrassing field pieces (Corddry in a leotard in NYC traffic, Oliver bloodily busting his ample honker while ruining a Civil War reenactment), the old gang shared how their function as ironic instigators often led to some very dicey situations. Between Colbert getting menaced by the Klan in Tennessee and Bee finding out that a homophobic Florida politician had plans for himself and a friend to seduce her and her female producer simultaneously, the tales prompted Stewart to joke that the gathering was turning into a Dr. Phil-type intervention, even though he grinningly admitted that he “tried to heighten” their comic plight as much as possible.
While joking about Corddry and Helms’ movie careers in hot tubbing and hanging-over, respectively, Colbert pointed out how much influence The Daily Show and Stewart have had on political comedy, with Bee, Oliver, and Colbert all doing variations on the show’s satirical formula on television each week. And while the reunion of comic pundits was definitely more warm than cutting, it was clear that the old friends were drawing some strength for the continuing Trump-era comedy struggles ahead. In the flashback sketch, a frizz-wigged Bee joked about George W. Bush, “there’s never gonna be a president this good for comedy.” Well, here’s hoping that hugging it out tonight gives these comedians the strength to cope with the very mixed blessing of that statement being so, so, catastrophically wrong.
