Doubt binds (and bruises) a mother-son bond in the first trailer for God's Creatures

Come to find out, Aileen’s most prominent ghost comes in the form of her prodigal adult son, Brian (Normal People’s Paul Mescal), who returns to the village and his childhood bedroom after an extended absence. Aileen is gobsmacked to see him and quickly gets to mothering, even though her friends remark that Brian seems “different.” The comment takes on a very different meaning, however, when an officer appears at Aileen’s door one night asking about Brian; a young woman has made a “serious” accusation against him, and Brian’s alibi is a night in with Aileen. After a pause, she says yes—but as Sarah later knowingly remarks, “You know that’s a lie, right?”

So where was Brian? The thick, spiny tension the two-and-a-half minute trailer methodically heightens hinges on the fact that in her heart, Aileen has no idea. She knows she’s compromising her morality, and maybe her community, to protect him—she’s just not certain from what. The teaser finds success by limiting second-half plot details and avoiding specifics, never even revealing what exactly Brian has been accused of. In leaving the audience as out of the loop as Aileen herself, God’s Creatures seems to stay true to genre— after all, there are few narrative tools as useful in a rural gothic drama as a good thinly-veiled secret.

God’s Creatures is set to release in theaters on September 30.