The King Of Kong, continued: Donkey Kong champ Billy Mitchell calls The A.V. Club out of the blue

The King Of Kong, continued: Donkey Kong champ Billy Mitchell calls The A.V. Club out of the blue

The world-record Donkey Kong score hardly seems like
fuel for controversy, and in the larger world, it hasn't inspired any. But a
microscopic look at the competitive arcade-gaming scene reveals high levels of
anxiety, rivalry, and bad blood. The King Of Kong, a terrific documentary produced
by Ed Cunningham and directed by Seth Gordon, details the rivalry between Billy
Mitchell, an arcade-game legend since the early '80s, and Steve Wiebe, a nice
guy who came out of nowhere to challenge the champ. That may sound like niche
entertainment for nerds, but the story that develops—spurred partly by
Mitchell's outsized personality and partly by the filmmakers'
framing—becomes a hilariously universal story of good vs. evil, with
[necessary spoiler ahead] the challenger coming out victorious.

The King Of Kong trailer

The story didn't end with the movie, though: Billy
Mitchell, a successful restaurant owner and hot-sauce mogul in Florida,
unsurprisingly took umbrage at the way he was portrayed. Though the beginning
of the film paints him as a hard-working businessman who bettered himself via
the same principles that made him good at gaming, it quickly casts him as a man
who a) may have sent minions to examine his rival's game console, b) won't face
a worthy opponent in a live match, c) may have cheated to keep his title, and
d) is generally self-absorbed and awful. To what degree those things are true
is a matter of debate. While Mitchell claims to this day that he hasn't seen
the movie, he insists (in the few interviews he's given) that he was portrayed
unfairly, and that the film is inaccurate. That's where The A.V. Club was willing to leave
things—with an excellent documentary that, like all documentaries, can't
possibly paint a completely accurate picture. Until about a week before the DVD
release of The King Of Kong, when Billy Mitchell called our office.

He was ostensibly just thanking us for ordering
some of his hot sauce—and looking for our suite number for the shipment—but
after I'd chatted with him for about 10 minutes, I asked if he'd like to
continue our conversation, and make it an official interview. He agreed, and an
hour of sometimes-pointed, sometimes-rambling conversation followed. To his
credit, Mitchell is well aware that a Donkey Kong score isn't the most
important thing on earth, or even in his life. But he's at least slightly
bitter—and heartily determined to get his side of the story across. He
comes across as friendly but almost amazingly self-centered, and a good deal more
charming than Kong lets on. (Some of the DVD's bonus footage offers a better
glimpse into what may be the "real" Billy.) He had plenty to say about specific
points the movie raises—for instance, he says that in one key scene, the
filmmakers edited out several seconds to make it look like he snubbed his nice-guy
rival. In the interest of fairness, The A.V. Club tracked down Ed
Cunningham and Seth Gordon to respond to some of the allegations. And the saga
continues. What follows is two separate conversations that took place about a
week apart, the first with Mitchell, and the second with Cunningham and Gordon.
They're edited together for the purposes of clarity and flow.

On Billy Mitchell's patriotic neckwear:

Billy Mitchell: You see me in the movie,
and I'm wearing different types of patriotic ties. You saw the movie. What
impression did the movie give you? And then I'll tell you the real truth.

The A.V. Club: Well, the movie clearly makes
you out to be the bad guy. Or do you mean specifically about the ties?

BM: Did I come across like a staunch Republican, or
like a NRA guy or a 9/11 guy, or something like that? The truth is, I started
wearing those ties to competitions in 1999, because in the race for a perfect
game of Pac-Man,
there was another guy, a counterpart from Canada who's really good, and we were
in our race, in our quest for a perfect game. He called himself Captain Canada,
and he actually wore a Canadian cape, a flag. I just wasn't gonna be that
goofy. The American flag tie's about as goofy as I would go. Sometimes
interviews take a funny angle like that. Sometimes they want real serious
questions about truth and lies and deception. And sometimes they just want the
humor, the funny stories, and that's fine, too. And whatever you wanna do is

The filmmakers, on Billy's personality:

AVC: What's your honest assessment of Billy as
a person? Is he a bad guy? My feeling after speaking with him is that he's kind
of an egomaniac, but not a terrible person.

Ed Cunningham: My on-the-record comment
is "No comment." It's not our job to stamp someone and say that they're this or
they're that. All of us live in gray areas, so, depending on your point of view
of the film… Everyone's had different reactions to Billy in different ways.
It's not up to us to judge what's on the screen, that's for the audience to

AVC: Did the film do a good job humanizing him?
The extra footage on the DVD makes him out to be a nicer guy than the actual

EC: Here's what I'd ask you to do, and it's kind of a
ridiculous ask: Go back and watch the film again, because for whatever reason,
because of what happens at [arcade] Funspot and then what transpires at
Guinness, people kind of forget everything that was said at the beginning of
the film about Billy. We spend the first 20 minutes of the film talking about how
great Billy is, that he's got a great business, that he's used gaming to
influence the rest of his life, to seek perfection with his family, with his
business. That he bought and delivered a Q-Bert machine to [an elderly
gamer] and sent her to Funspot. All of that stuff is covered in the film. It's
almost like those things are forgotten as the story unfolds.

AVC: Did you make conscious editing choices to
set up a clearer good-guy/bad-guy dynamic, though?

EC: Our goal was to represent them as truthfully as we
witnessed them.

Seth Gordon: I would say to represent it as it unfolded
for us, in the sense that when we first met Billy, he was amazing, and everyone
talked about him like he was amazing and perfect, and this sort of gamer of the
century—there was a whole sort of rehearsed legend of Billy that we were
very persuaded by, and very excited by. And when we were putting the piece
together, we arced out our own experience of him, including, as time went on,
the sort of hypocrisy of his actions. Not because we were interested in
painting him in one way or another, just showing what we witnessed. Also, we
were part of an elaborate chess game that he's been playing for 20 years with
this group of guys, and we were uncovering stuff that I don't think he wanted uncovered.
That's a really interesting puzzle to pick apart as a documentarian.

On Mitchell's refusal to see the movie:

AVC: What if I sent you a copy of the movie,
and you watched it and then we could chat after that? And you could directly
address some things…

BM: You can't send me a copy of the
movie. Number one, it's not out on DVD [Editor's note: This interview was
conducted before the film's recent DVD release.], so what you got, you can't
send to me. I could have gotten it a long time ago illegally. And I'm not gonna
do that. But
I think you're gonna have a hard time believing the fact that I kinda know
everything about the movie, since every day I open my computer and reviews are
forwarded to me, including video clips and all that. Plus, I got a good memory.

On the controversial scene in Florida, in
which Billy and his wife enter Funspot and appear to snub Steve Wiebe: (In the
film, Wiebe says, "Hi Billy," and Mitchell ignores him, walks away, and tells his
wife, "There's certain people I don't wanna spend too much time with.")

AVC: Let me ask you about a specific scene in
the movie…

BM: Okay, I'm ready. You're gonna ask me about the
scene where I walk behind Steve.

AVC: Yeah.

BM: Do you believe that I actually told you the
question you were gonna ask me? So find humor in that, and go ahead and put it
in your review.

AVC: I'd guess this is a question you're
getting a lot.

BM: Either that, or I can read your mind, and you
should hang up the phone quickly. Recall the scene in your mind. I'm walking
with my wife—my trophy wife, which we'll talk about later. Um, what part
of the country are you in? Chicago? Is that where you were born? Or where you
grew up?

AVC: I grew up in Milwaukee.

BM: Very good. That plays a point later… We're on the
record here so, I'm gonna watch what I wanna tell you. Are we on the record?

AVC: Yes.

BM: After spending a night out with my family, and
dropping off one of the people who was participating in the contest there, I
went to drive away, and my wife said, "You don't wanna go inside?" And so we
walked in, and Ed Cunningham put the microphone on me. I didn't have any
objection to that. I wouldn't—I mean, I don't have anything negative,
period. Walking into the arcade, I went game to game, and at each game, I
reminded my wife who the person was that was playing. One of the very first
games—I don't know that it was the first, but it was one of the
first—was Steve playin' Donkey Kong. And as I walked past him… Now you've got
the movie in your mind, the camera is looking at me from behind or from the
front? As I'm walking toward him.

AVC: I don't recall.

BM: You've gotta watch this movie, man! I'm givin'
you these test questions! Okay, so the camera's watchin' us, and as we walk
past him, this guy in the movie [Sarcastically.] who I've never met and I've
never even said hello to, because I'm so nasty and arrogant… As I was just
about behind him, he turned and he said, "Hi, Billy." Okay. You don't
really—somebody you've never met—would you just say "Hi, Billy,"
that casually? Then it cuts from a perfectly good camera angle that's following
us to the opposite side, where me and my wife continue walking, and I say
something to the effect of, "Some people, I don't wanna spend too much time
talking to." Is that what you're talking about?

AVC: Yes.

BM: Okay. Now this is what you do for a living? I'm
only being funny here to drive a point home. I don't want you to put across
that I was mean to you, because I'm not, I'm happy here. But let's think of
this: This is what you do for a living? Now I'm gonna say it again, and you
tell me what this means: "Some people, I don't wanna spend too much time talking to."
You don't hear somethin' in that?

AVC: I'm not getting it. You'll have to let me
know what I'm missing.

BM: I obviously stood there and talked to him. "Some
people, I don't wanna spend too much time talking to." That's why they cut one
camera angle to the other, 'cause when I stood behind him, and I waited for the
precise moment, knowing Donkey Kong… You know where the monkey falls down on its
head? You've got like, maybe 10 seconds of little rhetoric that you can,
whatever, without disturbing somebody? And I reminded my wife, "This is Steve,
remember we met him? He's the guy from Seattle. He's the other Donkey Kong guy." She goes, "Oh,
yeah." I go, "How they treatin' ya?" That—my line to him is, "How they
treatin' you," or "How is it treatin' you?" And he said, "Not good." And I go,
"No?" He goes, "No, I just can't get it together," and he didn't get a good
score that weekend. And I said, "All right, well, hang in there." And I walked

AVC: And you're saying they cut that out,
right? None of that's actually in the movie.

BM: Right. So what they did was, he says, "Hi,
Billy," cut! And then it's: "Some people, I don't wanna spend too much time
talking to." If I stood there and talked to him and his guy died, [people would
say] "Look at this: He can't even let the guy play in peace." You can see that
angle, right? I didn't wanna stand there, I didn't want him to feel
intimidated, I didn't want anyone to think that I was stealin' his secrets.

AVC: So you didn't spend much time talking
because you didn't want to disturb him?

BM: Right. But why don't you ask the filmmakers if
you can see the raw footage? They won't show it to you. But I think it makes a
great movie, and really, if somebody loses sleep over it, give me a break, it's
a video game.

Ed Cunningham: Yeah, no, that didn't happen there. It
didn't. At that moment, what we show is exactly what happened.

AVC: With no time break?

EC: No. There are all these conspiracy theories…
Obviously, it was a small venue, and we had three or four cameras. And of
course, if Billy's walking in, we're gonna cover it from three or four
different angles, because that was the story. So that scene when he walks by is
just a multi-camera shot, where we cut between angles. I've read claims that we
had an actor dub in Bill saying, "I don't wanna spend too much time with
certain people here." Really? That's what you're claiming? But no. He didn't
stop. They did a whole lap, they were in there for like 20 or 30 minutes, he
and his wife, and then on their way by, his wife actually stopped, and she
engaged Steve in a conversation. She saw Billy's name up on the placard, and
said, "Hey, why aren't you playing?" And he made a quick comment to the effect
of, "Oh, that's a misprint." A friendly back-and-forth is not what happened.

AVC: He says that he was trying to not disturb
Steve, and that's what he meant by not spending "too much time," not wanting to
psych him out.

SG: That's very generous of him. [Laughs.] Not to
derail the game with his magnetic force. He absolutely did not talk to Steve in
any way.

EC: Our goal was just to represent the tension that
we felt in that room. I mean, the temperature in that room changed drastically,
and we just hoped that we could present it as such. What he said is what he
said. Does he want us to subtitle it and say, "This is what he meant"? I just
know that that's what he said. We tried to represent that moment, as we tried
to represent the whole thing, as truthfully as we witnessed it.


On the real-world consequences of being a
movie villain, and the relationship between rivals:

BM: Yesterday, I get a phone call. I'll give you the
phone number if you want; you can call the person. "Hi, is Billy there?" I'm on
the other line, but I go, "Sure, who's calling?" "Steve Wiebe." Well, first of
all, they said "WEE-be," which leads me to believe it's somebody who knows
something. [Laughs.] And I says, "Yeah, hi, Steve, how ya doin'?" He goes,
"Good." Click. He hung up on me. It wasn't him. This call was from Indiana.
I'll give you the phone number if you want. You can put it through the 411
reverse and see what you learn or whatever, I don't know.

AVC: But have you actually had conversations
with the real Steve?

BM: So if Seth Gordon once again in an interview
says, "Billy Mitchell and his minions have started a smear campaign against the
film…" I mean, where have I said anything negative about the film? I don't! I'm
sure it's entertaining. I guess that's the best thing that can be said. [Steve]
and I had three very friendly phone calls, um, each lasting more than an hour,
on three different occasions. Not recently. Not at all recently. This was
before he went to San Jose. I invited him to the Classic Gaming Expo, 2004. I
invited him there, and I went up to speak onstage, as I do at each expo there. When
I went up and spoke onstage, I called him to the stage, in order to honor him.
I unveiled the poster in his honor, honoring his accomplishments. I did that in
2004. He was onstage with me. And I'm sorry to tell you that you can't see that,
'cause they forgot to put that in the movie. The pictures of me onstage with
him, the posters, I think even film, are available, you're welcome to look at
'em. Do you really wanna go this deep? I mean, I can really shovel it at ya.
But the thing is, like, what'd make me unhappy is, I give you all this, and all
you do is state it in the paper. I mean, if you wanna know about it, then you
look at the pictures. Then it's not he-said-she-said. Then you could ask Steve
about it if you want. It's not "Billy Mitchell claims." It's "My research shows
me." You know what I mean? I don't wanna be foolish, and, ya know, entertain
you with this and then be made to look silly, you know? I read your reviews,
"These two guys who obviously hate each other." That's absurd! I don't know him
well enough to hate him. It's a video game. I wouldn't hate him over a video

The ins and outs of Donkey Kong

On Billy's reclamation of the throne,

BM: I last played Donkey Kong in July of last year,
when I got the world record. I did it as a favor to a friend who was
participating in the convention in Orlando. They asked me to go, and I said no.
That was in August. I said no in September, no in October, no in November. In
December, they said that if I go there and I play, that they'll send my family,
too, and we can have a vacation out of it. I said yes, but they had to donate $1,000
to a charity of my choice, which they agreed to. Sometime in January or
February, I actually bought a Donkey Kong off eBay because I don't own one. I don't
own any video games in my house. None. So in preparation for the convention, I
practiced, played a little bit just to be able to show off and be entertaining.
And things kinda came together really good, and about a week before I went
there, I thought, "Wow, man, this fell back together good." So I went to the
convention, and three weeks before the movie came out, I beat Steve's score,
which sort of debunked what they did. I think I aggravated 'em. Not Steve, I
think I aggravated the movie people. I guess they'd rather I didn't do that,
but I did it, and I haven't played since. Prior to playing that July, I hadn't
played since 2004, when I got to the kill screen and set what was thought to be
a new world record in Milwaukee. So the idea that I had played it intensely
since 1982… Gimme a break. I went 13 years without playing a video game at all,
from around '87 to '99.

AVC: How much of your day-to-day is taken up,
since the movie came out, with talking to people about it?

BM: Before the movie came out, there wasn't a day
would go by that I didn't have somebody say hi or recognize me from video games
as a whole. Matter of fact, if a day did go by, I'd say, "Phew, nobody said
anything to me." Now that the movie's out, it's the same thing. Before, it was
mostly, "That's the video-game guy," or "That's the Pac-Man guy," and it's still
dominantly, "That's the Pac-Man guy." But some of it is, "That's the Donkey

guy." As far as sayin' hi to people and things like that, it does happen on a
daily basis, sayin' hi to kids who come in the restaurant or play with my
children. Everything that's face-to-face is always very, very friendly. I get
e-mails and such that would turn your stomach. People, they surprise ya!
[Laughs.] With how strong their emotions are. I guess that's because it's an
entertaining movie. And some people, like yourself, find it entertaining, great
to watch and be humored, and some people take it as a whole lot more, I guess.

AVC: And you're interested in setting the
record straight wherever you can?

BM: No.

AVC: You're not interested?

BM: For every hundred interviews that I have the
opportunity to do, I just once in a while do it, 'cause somebody's polite on
the phone. Like you. The interviews I've done in a year, I can count on both
hands. It's just a video game, and it's brought me a lot of fun, the experience
as a whole from 1982 to now. I've been to 48 out of 50 states. I didn't get to
Hawaii yet, and for whatever reason, I haven't been to North Dakota. I've been
in Canada, I've been in Europe, I've been in Asia. How can it not be a great
experience? But every year that ticks on the calendar seems to deal me more and
more responsibility in the real world, and less and less available for

AVC: So if somebody beat your new record, would
that inspire you to go do it again?

BM: August 17, 2000, Tim Sczerby beat my score. I don't
know if you know that. I wasn't the world-record holder [as the movie implies].
That's just a big sham. He beat my world record, and I called him, I
congratulated him. I guess you could say we talked Donkey Kong on a higher level. And he
went back to his life, and I went back to mine. That was in the year 2000.
Steve Wiebe came along in 2004 or 2003, and he submitted a score of 947,000.
And when he submitted that, he had the record. During this time period, I had
never played or attempted to beat anybody's record. In the movie, when you show
[Steve] getting a million six, and the score is pulled down, and it goes back
down to 874,000—what happened to the 937,000 that Tim Sczerby had? And
what happened to the 947,000 that Steve Wiebe had? They just crossed that over,
but it made a better movie. If you really want the facts, I'll give 'em, but to
answer your question, no, it's not that important to me. I mean, it wasn't
important then. I did it for the charity, and I have done many scores at many
times that, had I chosen to videotape them or submit them, they would have been
a big deal. But as the years go on, the big deal is the wife and kids.

Steve Wiebe reaches the legendary "kill screen" at FunSpot, and Bill Mitchell's "spy."

On Billy Mitchell's heavily documented
current score:

AVC: You have the record now, correct? And you
achieved it live?

BM: You ask good questions, man. You been doing your
research? Considering all the controversy surrounding Steve's score and all the
fuss that was made about the score, I didn't wanna be a part of that. That's
why in the movie—search your memory banks or watch the movie
again—never, ever do I say a bad or negative word about Steve or anyone.
It's just not part of my nature. So I didn't wanna be a part of the
controversy, and I thought, "Well, how do I drive this point home?" And so I
bought a game, I sent the board to Nintendo—this is all documented—they
verified its authenticity, that it was a real board and had not been tampered
with. It was sent to the manager from GameWorks and a notary public, who were
there and plugged it in at the event in Orlando. So the notaries were there.
The game was locked up and the manager of GameWorks kept the key with him, and
the Twin Galaxies senior referee Todd Rogers was there. If you follow the
rules, you have a senior referee there, a senior referee witnesses it, period.
End of paragraph. Score verified.

AVC: But you did more than that.

BM: The game was videotaped, and then the overall
area of me playing was taped. Once the score was done, the GameWorks guy came
back with the key, opened the cabinet, then put it in a box and they sent it
back to Nintendo, who re-verified it as the same board, still authentic,
untampered with. Lastly, I took the videotape of the game and sent it to two
referees, the same referees that had viewed previous tapes, and they verified
the authenticity of the tapes. I can't really do a whole lot more than that.

AVC: You say it's just a video game, but you
took it pretty seriously.

BM: I didn't want to cause any rhetoric or any
heartache, and without kidding you, and this part is the touching part for me…
People in the movie, like Walter [Day, video-game scorekeeper], who are very
giving of their time, for a labor of love, people in the movie who are made to
look corrupt, incompetent, or manipulated, they take a lot of flack that they
don't deserve. They can't take any flack on this.

On the "break-in" at Steve Wiebe's house, in
which two gamers—friends of Mitchell's—examined Steve Wiebe's

BM: The two guys who went to Steve's house, they
called ahead of time, they were told when to be there. He was late getting
home. The grandmother opened the garage, they let 'em play. Nobody broke into
his house. And now Steve Wiebe says that. He says, "No, they were pleasant,"
and now when they do interviews, they don't say "the goons who broke in," like
the movie would have you believe. They just say "the two guys who visited
Steve." And I appreciate that, because I have it on my conscience that
otherwise good people are criminalized, and they shouldn't be. It was a fun
thing, and if you sensationalize something for the sake of Hollywood, I think
that's fine. I don't think it's a big deal. I think the interviews, afterwards,
they talked to Cunningham, and they talked to Seth Gordon, and they openly say
that these goons came in and broke into his garage, these two spies came in and
tore his machine apart. They didn't tear his machine apart. Steve opened it.
Now Steve says that, and I appreciate his character on that, and the fact of
the matter is, it's not necessary to say those things in an interview to
sensationalize the movie. The movie sensationalizes itself. They don't have to
do that. And it's better that they don't.

AVC: Have you spoken with Seth Gordon after
reading these sorts of interviews?

BM: Seth was behind the camera, and I obviously did
interact with him, but without kidding you, if Ed Cunningham came in and sat in
a restaurant and started eating and I walked past him, I'd know who he was. If
Seth Gordon did, I would not, and it's not a slight to Seth Gordon. He was not
the one that was steering the cart. It was Ed Cunningham, and Ed Cunningham was
the one who organized things, and all that kind of stuff. Seth Gordon does
these interviews and comes up with these things he says out of thin air, these
quotes he says I'm saying—they're beyond me. I have no idea. I haven't
had a conversation with him. You know, the idea that Billy Mitchell is bitter
about the movie… Says who? I think it's funny. I think it's humorous. The
closest thing to bitterness that I have is, I think it's lousy that they
criminalize people. You know, they're the ones who have to live with that. But
the fact that myself and others were duped, that's no fun. We were led to
believe something else about the movie, and, oh well.

Ed Cunningham: We could have spent 25
minutes dissecting how they got in [to Wiebe's garage], and how they were asked
not to come in. But the point is, two guys showed up at this guy's garage,
unannounced. They didn't call, and I don't care what anybody says, they went at
the behest of Bill Mitchell. Three people say that. The whole thing started,
honestly, when we just kind of, in editing, referred to it as "the break-in."
They didn't break into the garage, nor does the film say that they broke into
the garage. And everyone was upset, and I understand that it had come out that
we had said in a Q&A; or something online that it was a break-in. I get
that, and we've pulled back from that. We don't refer to it as the break-in any
more. But the overall fact is, two guys showed up at Steve Wiebe's garage
unannounced to look at his machine.


On the documentary itself, and controversial
video-gamer Roy "Mr. Awesome" Shildt:

AVC: You thought it was going to be a more direct
documentary about video gaming?

BM: The truth is, I never knew it was even going to
be about Donkey Kong, I thought it was competitive video gaming as a whole. But
the truth is, none of us are ever mean. None of us are ever vindictive, and
we've never had a mean-spirited movie or story or film done about us, so this
was a first. All of us, a couple of us in particular, for 22 years now, have
avoided interaction with Mr. Awesome, and it was clearly stated, "I'll do what
you need me to do, or we can talk about whatever you want me to talk about, I'm
not going to talk about him. And if you're going to include him, I'd just
rather not participate." And it was openly said, "No, we aren't going to," and
"Not a chance," and they did anyway. Oh, well. That's really the main crux as
to why I decided to distance myself from participating in any promotions or
anything like that. As far as the movie, it's a lot more fun to play the bad
guy, believe me. Are you married, or do you have a girlfriend?

AVC: Girlfriend, yeah.

BM: Well, let's pretend like she watches soap operas.
She'll tell you her favorite person is the really bad girl or bad boy. So, it's
kinda fun.

The incredible, unbelievable story of Mr.

Ed Cunningham: I met Steve four days
after the guys showed up at his house to check out his machine. So it was a
really opportune moment, but you know, Steve's just kind of a regular guy, and
we didn't know if we could hang a whole movie on him. And then we went down and
met Billy and I was like, "Oh my God, this guy's awesome." He's just an
amazing, amazing guy. We were chasing about four or five different stories,
there was a great story going on with Ms. Pac-Man, with this Jamaican
immigrant who worked for his dad's construction company in Queens. But every
time we showed up, something strange and fascinating was happening with Donkey

AVC: Billy says his greatest concern was the inclusion
of Mr. Awesome in the film. Presumably there's more to their history than the
movie goes into.

EC: The movie pretty clearly states that Roy is
jealous of Billy, has been since the mid-'80s, and will go to the ends of the
earth to try to hurt him. In a 35,000-foot statement, that's the story.

SG: Although not physically harm him.

Conspiracy theories and Mr. Awesome.

On the planned feature film:

AVC: Apparently, Seth Gordon and Ed Cunningham
are working on a feature-film version of the story. Did you know anything about

BM: The contract that I have with them says clearly:
No Mr. Awesome. After the movie released at Sundance, maybe like in February, I
began to know things about it. That's when I said, "Well, wait a minute. You
said he wasn't going to be in it." And, the theory is, "Oh, no. That contract's
not for the documentary. It's for the remake." So, yeah, I know there's a
remake, and supposedly the agreement I have with them says that I don't want to
be a part of anything that has to do with, um, different things…

AVC: So if they came to you and said, "We're
doing a remake. And we want to have a character named Billy Mitchell, and it's

BM: They already have the paperwork to do that. I
signed the paperwork to do that before the documentary came out, and I was
duped. I suppose they'll get away with it.

AVC: That's not something you'd have enough
interest to go to court about?

BM: Actually, I've had some very strong legal
opinions on directions that they feel will be very effective. And I suppose
eventually I'll sit down and give it serious thought. But for the moment, to be
honest, I don't really put my thoughts or time to it. Again, it's a fun part of
history. And unfortunately, there's about a half a percent of a tenth of the
population that somehow gets worked up over the movie. [Laughs.]

Ed Cunningham: Our goal would be to keep
[a feature-film version] in the same tone as the doc. That's one of the reasons
we were so excited to end up at New Line, because they have that same vision
for it, that it won't become this broad, kick-in-the-groin comedy. So that's our
goal. The ending in the doc is fairly complicated, and you have to consider
when you go to a scripted version, you have to be open to the idea that it may
change some. As far as Billy reclaiming the record, I don't know how that's
going to be dealt with.

AVC: And you already have permission to portray
Billy in a feature film, right?

EC: Yeah, we have his life rights. [Laughs.]
Complicates things, doesn't it?

AVC: Billy's understanding of this is that the
exclusion of Mr. Awesome applies to a feature film. Is that true?

EC: It's not our position to talk about the legal side
of things. That would be completely beyond our scope to comment on.

SG: But I think we can generally say, the degree to
which Billy wants to remove Mr. Awesome from the historical record, in every
form, is definitely true. [Laughs.] Is that fair, Ed?

EC: Totally fair.

On what the filmmakers learned:

Ed Cunningham: It's been an incredible
lesson on how, when people have a vested interest, the truth is always going to
be slanted toward their opinion. We've tried a couple of times to sit down and
hash out everything we learned through this process factually, and it's nearly
impossible. If you want to have some very intense reading, go on some of the
blogs and read any entry from [video-game referee and King Of Kong participant] Robert
Mruczek and his claims on what happened and how. It's so mind-boggling, the
level of detail that people have gone to, to try to say what the truth is or
isn't. It's really a fascinating study. There's truth everywhere.

Seth Gordon: Yeah, the Rashomon of it. What's fascinating
is how high the stakes are for such a thing. They put so much effort into
something that to most of us seems relatively inconsequential. What's worth
getting upset about, really?

Amazing 2003 MTV interview with Billy Mitchell.

A little more Billy being Billy:

BM: Hey, you didn't ask any real tough questions.

AVC: I didn't know we were doing an interview

BM: Well, you're not intimidated by the movie, are
you? You don't look over your shoulder and think that I'm there?

AVC: [Laughs.] Are you right behind me?

BM: No, but I will be. Again, I see the value of
Hollywood, I really do. I don't think it's necessary for—you can read the
interviews, you can be at the Q&As;—I don't see the necessity, when
the game is over, to do things they've done that are mean-spirited.

AVC: Are you selling more sauce since the movie
came out?

BM: Well, let's just say I haven't hit $50 a week
yet. I do talk to a lot of people, and when I have a review or something sent
to me, like when somebody sends me yours, sometimes you can just click on it
and send an e-mail. Sometimes there's a phone number. I never ever, not once,
miss contacting, saying thanks, saying "That was funny," or whatever the case
is. Sometimes the reviews are funny. Sometimes they're insightful, and I learn
things that I otherwise didn't know. Very often, I get responses back, and
they're usually: "Well, I didn't mean to offend you." You're not offending me,
you're reporting what's just on the screen. That's the way it is. More often
than not, it leads to a conversation without an interview. But I'm very
cautious, as you can hear in my voice, I do not speak ill of people. It would
come back to bite me, and in 25 years, I've never done a negative interview,
and I'm not going to do one.

AVC: Well, thanks for all the insight, I
appreciate it. And we're looking forward to the sauce as well.

BM: Well, ask some tough questions the next time!

AVC: If I'd known we were going to speak today,
I would have thought of some.

BM: Hang in there. If you're ever down here, you can
stop and say hi.

Join the discussion...