Youth Without Youth
In Hearts Of Darkness, a first-rate documentary about the making of Apocalypse Now, Francis Ford Coppola says that he comes into a movie with a question and that the process of making it will hopefully provide an answer. The idea of filmmaking as an inquiry rather than a statement isn't a common one, but Apocalypse Now wouldn't be the same movie had Coppola not gone upriver and allowed his experiences to leave a mark on the finished product. Coppola has brought that same high-wire aesthetic to Youth Without Youth, his first film in 10 years and easily his most radical, but his renewed sense of discovery comes with a fatal lack of clarity, as if he finished without successfully paddling his way through a sea of abstraction. It's somehow both incomprehensible and not experimental enough; the more Coppola hangs onto his stilted narrative, the less vibrant his free-wheeling ideas become.