Jeez, there were a lot of pot-boiler style thrillers throughout the ’90s—so many that it can often be hard to remember which one is which. The best way to keep them straight is by trying to remember the cast, and in the case of 1999’s Double Jeopardy, it includes Tommy Lee Jones, Ashley Judd, Bruce Greenwood, and Annabeth Gish. A bit of a murder mystery by way of legal procedural, Libby (Judd) is wrongfully accused of killing her husband Nick (Greenwood). After being found guilty and spending six years in prison, Libby gets out yet suspects her husband isn’t dead at all, thus giving her the idea that, since she was already convicted of killing him once, if she finds him and murders him, she can’t be tried due to, you guessed it, the double jeopardy law. In a 2.5-star review from 1999, Roger Ebert said, “This movie was made primarily in the hopes that it would gross millions and millions of dollars, which probably explains most of the things that are wrong with it.” Please note: the film made $177 million at the box office so, mission accomplished.