Surf's Up
Since the hugely profitable one-two punch of 2002's Ice Age and 2003's Finding Nemo, the "group of wacky animals voiced by celebrities" CGI kids' movie has become a massive cliché, as much a theater-clogging same-old same-old genre as romantic comedies about sad-sack emo boys who need someone quirky to perk them up. The latest CGI-animal genre outing, Surf's Up, seems to recognize the need for innovation, and its inexperienced four-man writing team (the one industry vet, Don Rhymer, mostly has lamentable credits like the Big Momma's House movies and The Santa Clause 2) found it in a new concept: the CGI mockumentary. Pitched as a documentary about wannabe surf-champ Cody Maverick (a rockhopper penguin voiced by Shia LaBeouf), Surf's Up spends as much time aping and mocking docs as it does telling its wispy wuss-to-winner sports story. The conceit sometimes works and sometimes doesn't, but at least it's a wee bit different.