Those sluggish, overstuffed first 25 minutes introduce us to Marius (Giovanni Ribisi), a con man who’s about to get out of prison and reconnect with his brother Eddie (Mr. Robot‘s Michael Drayer). However, after a phone call with Eddie reveals that a mobster named Vince (Bryan Cranston) still believes Marius owes him $100,000, heading back home suddenly isn’t an option. So, Marius does what any other con man would: he listens intently to his chatty cellmate in order to gather information about his life so that he can steal his identity. Sure enough, Marius gets out of prison and finds his way to a farmhouse in upstate New York.
The farmhouse is owned by the grandparents of his cellmate Pete, and since they haven’t seen their grandson in 20 years, Marius has no trouble sliding into his identity. He uses everything Pete told him to ingratiate himself to Audrey (Margo Martindale) and Otto (Peter Gerety), reminiscing about the apple tree that used to adorn the front lawn, and doing his best to keep up with the details of the family’s bail bonds business. For all the slackness in the earliest portions of “Pilot,” there’s great tension and a few laughs in these scenes, underscored by an engaging dynamic between the actors. Marius will certainly suffer the consequences of being Pete at some point, but “Pilot” is more interested in using the identity balancing act as a source of comedy. Watching Marius try to deflect from childhood memories brought up by Pete’s cousin Taylor is both nerve racking and hilarious, Ribisi’s signature puzzled facial expressions only hinting at the truth of who he is.
So while “Pilot” does struggle to bring some clarity and definition to its initial setup, it also presents a storytelling structure that’ll be interesting to watch unfold. “Pilot” is equal parts case-of-the-week procedural, family drama, and crime caper. Sneaky Pete does a good job of finding a balance amongst those elements. If there’s a weak link in the bunch it’s the procedural aspect, which comes in the form of Marius teaming up with Pete’s cousin Julia to take down a man skipping out on his court appearance. The hunt isn’t all that interesting, even as Marius comes to realize that the man they’re looking for is actually a well-connected mob boss who just might have a reason for hurting him, and never quite finds the proper balance between being dramatically compelling and also occasionally funny. There’s a bit of Chuck in there, but without the charm, and that could be a problem going forward.
With that said, “Pilot” builds a solid amount of mystery out of its other elements. Particularly, one gets the sense that there’s more to the story of the farmhouse and the bail bonds business than Otto and Audrey Bernhardt are letting on. They’re certainly not your typical rural family, but just how atypical they are is a question that “Pilot” leaves unanswered for now. One thing we do know is that Marius, by the end of the episode, finds himself falling for the family. In them he sees the comfort, stability, and love that he didn’t get from his own parents, as his upbringing was heavy on self-sufficiency and emotional trauma. It’s a bit of a cliché to have Marius develop a loving rapport with the very family he’s conning, but Sneaky Pete largely avoids anything too obvious or blunt, instead shooting for subtle nods to the way in which Marius might find some sense of himself amongst these people.
What’ll be interesting to watch play out over the season’s 10 episodes is how the show finds a balance between all of its different elements. It’s difficult to tell whether the pilot’s occasional messiness can be chalked up to the usual table-setting constraints of a pilot episode, or if the various genre influences are just too much to handle. That’s something that will become clearer as the season continues, but for now “Pilot” boasts enough good—particularly the performances—to warrant queuing up the next episode.
Stray observations
- Welcome to The A.V. Club’s reviews of Sneaky Pete! Because this is the age of constant consumption, we’ll be posting a new review every other day. As always, if you’ve watched ahead in the season, please keep the comments section spoiler-free, or at least clearly mark anything that’s a potential spoiler. Be kind to one another!
- Ribisi is such an inspired choice for Marius/Pete. He’s so naturally skeezy, which I swear is a compliment.
- We’ve all met that guy in the bar. I couldn’t help but cringe. “You hear that, Bobby? Gretzky!”
- I’ll be curious to see if Sneaky Pete spends some time on the relationship between Marius and his brother Eddie. If the aim is to make Marius feel conflicted about his allegiances, we’re going to need something more to connect to.
- Julia is in over her head when tracking down bail-skipper Abraham: “I have my own gun pointed at my head.”
- For as much as I didn’t really enjoy the hunt for Abraham, the scene where he and his mother openly talk about killing Julia right in front of her is perfectly-pitched comedy.
- Abraham is in fact Max Perron, head of Construction and Protection, which means exactly what you think it means. Apparently nobody is who they seem on Sneaky Pete.
- Check back on Sunday for a review of episode two!
