Pop culture obsessives writing for the pop culture obsessed.
We may earn a commission from links on this page

Justin Townes Earle: Harlem River Blues

We may earn a commission from links on this page.

On his fourth album, Harlem River Blues, Earle turns his focus from rural backwaters to the Big Apple, where he currently lives. It opens with the country/blues title track, delivered complete with a backup gospel choir: Earle sings so joyously about planning to drown himself in the river that it almost sounds like a good idea. It’s an odd way to begin, but it sets an off-kilter mood that goes well with the album’s nomadic feel. While a number of songs are grounded in New York stories—a lovelorn couple in Brooklyn, a subway worker’s daily life—some of the more powerful tracks have a wider scope. One of the strongest, “Wanderin’,” pairs the story of a drifter with a catchy, circular melody. Elsewhere, Earle trades ambition for tradition: “Learning To Cry” clearly nods to the Hank Williams school of classic country, though it walks a line between inspired and derivative. For all its strengths, Harlem River Blues never comes together thematically. Like his characters, Earle never seems to know where he wants to be.