Chicago Justice’s pedigree sets it up to fail

The only episode screened for critics still has plenty of pissing matches, whether it’s Dawson—who made his way over from Chicago P.D.—insisting he’s right about a former co-worker’s innocence, or State’s Attorney Mark Jeffries (Carl Weathers) pushing for a grand jury because he’s worried about appearances. What is new here is that, unlike Schiff and McCoy, Jeffries doesn’t deny he’s a politician. He just sees it as part of the job, like meeting with the reverend who pressures him to bring a cop to justice for allegedly killing an unarmed young man in his custody.

That’s actually old hat, but Chicago Justice’s contemporary setting casts a new light on this fraught relationship with community leaders. Real-life grassroots action for police reform has risen in the years since McCoy left his fictional office, and it’s one of the many issues that will reportedly be addressed. It’s a tall order for the series, let alone a 45-minute episode, and “Uncertainty Principle” chooses to live in the gray than side with the bleeding hearts or bleed blue. Instead, the episode focuses on how errors can be made on both sides of the law, a point it drives home through former ADA Paul Robinette (Richard Brooks), who’s now a defense lawyer.

Robinette isn’t the only Law & Order character who makes an appearance this episode; his former boss, Ben Stone, is Peter’s dad, who’s had some kind of falling out with his son. Although he is only ever mentioned, the action grinds to a halt whenever he does come up, precisely because of his name. On the show, it carries enough weight to make characters pause; for the viewer, it recalls the early days of Wolf’s famous procedural, which is to Justice’s detriment. Peter’s daddy issues don’t make him much more interesting, and his courtroom address at episode’s end comes off as a disclaimer for the show instead of a wise observation about the importance of nuance.

Although one episode doesn’t offer cast members much of a chance to gel, they should at least make an impression. Only Weathers’ gravitas is memorable. Winchester has little affect and sounds the same when he’s negotiating with opposing counsel as he does apologizing to a defendant. Barbaro continues the L&O tradition of filling the second chair with a beautiful, idealistic woman, but she otherwise looks lost. Seda and Carter each possess an appealing caginess, but that also feels like a holdover from their Chicago P.D. and Justified days. The episode flails under the weight of multiple legacies: In addition to the through-lines of the other Chicago shows, there’s its New York connection. In order to get the wheels of Justice moving, Wolf and his showrunner, Michael S. Chernuchin (another Law & Order vet), will have to choose between the two.